law://eu/cjeu/1979/c-99-79/hd_1_1_2_2_1@2026-11-22Referring to the judgments given by the Court in Joined Cases 23, 24 and 52/63 [1963] ECR 217, Joined Cases 53 and 54/63 [1963] ECR 239, Case 54/65 [1966] ECR 185 and Joined Cases 8 to 11/66 [1967] ECR 75, the defendants in the main action maintain that the letter of 16 December 1974 did not exhibit any of the characteristics which, according to the case-law of the Court, are those of a decision. That letter cannot moreover a fortiori be considered as negative clearance or an exemption; in this connexion, it is necessary to observe that in any case the conditions as to publication laid down by Regulation No 17 with regard to the adoption of such measures have not been fulfilled in this case. The letter of 16 December 1974 is therefore no more than the expression of the opinion of a head of department which is not binding upon the Commission. Lancôme cannot rely upon that letter as against third parties for the purpose of alleging that its selective distribution system has been accepted by the Commission.The defendants in the main action criticize next the informal solution adopted by the Commission for the perfumery sector. There is a specific means by which the Commission can draw up a uniform solution for a sector of the economy within the Community system of competition. This is the block exemption granted by regulation which contains guarantees for third parties (preliminary publication and the opportunity of submitting observations). The Commission is acting in conflict with the Community legal order when it reacts to a request for negative clearance or exemption by an unofficial letter which is not binding upon it. The Commission must in all cases adopt a formal decision so as to comply with the rules laid down by Regulation No 17.If the letter of 16 December 1974 was not a decision the question of provisional validity would then arise. The defendants however consider that the Lancôme distribution system cannot be covered by the provisional validity for the following reasons :
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.