law://eu/cjeu/1977/c-131-77/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-17The plaintiff in the main action begins by describing the market in powdered whey, which is a by-product from the manufacture of cheese; it was previously discharged into the drainage system, a procedure subsequendy prohibited in order to conserve the environment. The whey is processed into powder by evaporation of the water and then still contains between 10 and 12 % albumen, between 70 and 75 % lactose, 8 % mineral salts and between 4 and 5 % water. Approximately 90 % of the powdered whey is used in the agricultural sector as animal feed.The raw material is practically free and the cost price of the finished product, which may be taken by way of example as DM 55 to 65 per 100 kg, is made up of the manufacturing, storage and distribution costs. Such selling prices are the result of supply and demand on the market and divergences of 50 or indeed 100 % sometimes occur. In 1976 Community production amounted almost to 600000 tonnes whilst the rest of the world produced only 200000. Community manufacturers received national export aids in 1975 and 1976. The profit margins for this period were approximately DM 1 per quintal whilst the monetary compensation was DM 5.37.With regard to the first question submitted by the Finanzgericht the plaintiff in the main action states that Article 1 of Regulation No 539/75 is at variance with Article 1 (2) (b) of Regulation No 974/71 of the Council since the price of powdered whey does not depend on the price of skimmed-milk powder in respect of which intervention measures were provided within the framework of the common organization of the agricultural markets. Account should also be taken of Article 2 (2) of Regulation No 974/71 which states ‘… the compensatory amounts shall be equal to the incidence, on the prices of the product concerned, of the application of the compensatory amount to the prices of the product referred to in paragraph (1), on which they depend’. Since the ‘value of the milk’ contained in the powdered whey is nil the price of the powdered whey does not depend on the price of the intervention product (skimmed-milk powder). The imposition of a countervailing charge thus amounts to the imposition of a charge having an effect equivalent to a customs duty.The Commission itself, in the recitals in the preamble to Regulation (EEC) No 1824/77 (Official Journal L 203 of 9 August 1977, p. 7), pertinently stated that ‘for non-intervention products the calculation should, in principle, be based on the price of milk without taking account of specific processing costs’; whey should therefore not be subject to monetary compensation. In Case 28/76 (Milac v Hauptzollamt Freiburg) the Commission, in its own observations, maintained that powdered whey depends on powdered milk because of its use, that is to say as animal feed; the Commission states that this dependence is ‘purely economic’ that is to say it depends on nutritional value. However, this does not constitute dependence on the price level within the meaning of the regulations. The plaintiff in the main action therefore concludes that Article 1 of Regulation No 539/75 is at variance with Article 1 (2) (b) of basic Regulation No 974/71 and with Articles 9, 12 and 13 of the EEC Treaty.with regard to the first part of the second question submitted by the Finanzgericht the plaintiff in the main action recalls that the sole factor constituting the market price of powdered whey is the processing cost since the value of the raw material does not affect the composition of prices. The Commission itself adopted this point of view, albeit belatedly, when it enacted Regulation No 1824/77 (Official Journal L 203 of 9 August 1977, p. 7) by abolishing compensation at the frontier for powdered whey. This latter view is in accordance with the case-law of the Court of Justice since the Court stated in its judgment of 12 November 1974 (Case 34/74 [1974] ECR 1217) that with regard to derived products, compensation for fluctuations of currencies should be in proportion to the incidence on the prices of the said derived products of the application of the compensatory amount to the basic product to the exclusion of the fixed component of the levy which was established in order to protect the processing industry. The Court, in its judgment of 17 June 1975 (Case 93/74 [1975] ECR 661) stated that when the levy on the basic product is zero, no compensatory amount may be charged on derived products. Finally in its judgment of 17 March 1976 (Joined Cases 67 to 85/75 [1976] ECR at p. 408) the Court, in view of the fact that the object in establishing the system of monetary compensatory amounts was the maintenance of single prices, emphasized that the granting or levying of such amounts was acceptable only if trade in the product in question would be disturbed in their absence. In the present case the levying of such amounts is the sole cause of the disturbance adversely affecting exporting manufacturers and importers.The Commission itself recognized that this view is correct by abolishing compensatory amounts on agricultural products whose price was principally determined by the processing costs (Regulation No 722/75, Official Journal L 71 of 20 March 1975). Powdered whey must a fortiori qualify for such treatment since the value of the end product is determined solely by the processing costs. From a purely legal point of view this conclusion is unavoidable and cannot be affected by appraisals at the discretion of the administration.The reply to Question 2 (a) submitted by the Finanzgericht des Saarlandes should thus be that the fixing of monetary compensatory amounts is contrary to the provisions of Article 1 (3) of Regulation (EEC) No 974/71 if the market price of the product in question, in this case powdered whey, is determined solely by manufacturing costs and it is unnecessary to consider in this connexion whether the market price falls in the present case to a level equal to or less than the level of production costs.With regard to the second part of the second question submitted by the Finanzgericht the plaintiff in the main action emphasizes that a reply serves no purpose, in view of the replies which have already been suggested. Nevertheless it adds that the Commission cannot rely in this case on the wide discretionary power which the Court acknowledged the Commission to possess in its judgment of 22 January 1976 (Case 55/75 [1976] ECR 30, paragraphs 7 and 8); no ‘complex economic situation’ is involved with regard to powdered whey, a product whose price fluctuates in terms of supply and demand. The Commission itself has through its behaviour, in certain situations, recognized that in such cases monetary compensatory amounts give rise to disturbances. Mr Gundelach, the Commissioner responsible for agricultural matters, has admitted that the system constitutes ‘the worst error’ committed in the Common Agricultural Policy. In the present case this is clear.Furthermore compensation for powdered whey at the frontier is, like that for other milk products, the result of political pressure. This is shown by the fact that the Commission and the national experts on the Management Committee decided to abolish compensation despite a sharp reaction from the Government of the Federal Republic. The plaintiff in the main action accordingly hopes that the Court, concurring with the endeavours of the Commission, will declare compensation at the frontier unlawful and in breach of Article 1 (3) of Regulation No 974/71 with regard to products for which the price fluctuates and is determined freely on the market without the influence of monetary measures.The Commission considers that the two questions submitted by the Finanzgericht in fact concern the validity of Regulation No 539/75 and it suggests that the questions should be considered together with regard to basic Regulation No 974/71.The Commission describes the manufacturing process for powdered whey, which is produced because it became impossible to discharge it any longer as effluent and because of the parallel development of a profitable market in animal feed where it has partially replaced powdered milk. Comparison of the protein and fat content of those two products shows that it is profitable to use powdered whey instead of skimmed-milk powder whilst the relationship between the prices of the two products corresponds to that between their respective protein contents. Since the price of skimmed-milk powder is determined by the intervention price this price must be multiplied, after taking account of the aid granted for animal feed, by the coefficient 0.389105 which expresses the relationship between the respective protein contents, in order to obtain the maximum price at which powdered whey may properly be preferred to skimmed-milk powder. It is clear from a comparative table of the prices of the two products that powdered whey has been able to compete effectively with skimmed-milk powder. Although the market price of powdered whey is considerably influenced by the manufacturing costs it has remained from 1971 to 1977 at a level justified by its protein content.With regard to the fixing of the monetary compensatory amounts applicable to powdered whey the Commission recalls that this constitutes a power in matters of economic policy which may be exercised within the limits established by Regulation No 974/71 and in the interest of the proper functioning of the organization of the market. The exercise of such a power presupposes a wide margin of discretion and its exercise does not cease to be lawful except in the case of manifest error in using the margin of discretion (judgments in Cases 97/76 [1977] ECR 1063; 74/74 [1975] ECR 533; 55/75 [1976] ECR 19; 29/77 [1977] ECR 1835). The compensatory amount applicable to powdered whey was derived from the relationship between the price of that product and the price of skimmed-milk powder with corrections whenever there was a variation of approximately 10 % from the intervention price for skimmed-milk powder, which in practice correspond to the market price owing to the surplus production of the latter product.The Commission recognizes that the application and the calculation of the compensatory amounts relating to powdered whey constitute a borderline case. It nevertheless observes that:— On the one hand it is possible in many cases to substitute powdered whey for skimmed-milk powder; the price of the former depends on the latter to a certain extent although it is not so closely related that the two prices automatically register a pro portionate increase. In fact powdered whey is also a surplus product but since, unlike skimmed-milk powder, it is not covered by intervention, its price is influenced largely by supply and demand.— On the other hand the manufacturing costs have a considerable effect in the composition of the price of powdered whey: it sometimes has to be sold at a loss, which is taken into account in calculating the price of cheese.It was thus in order to avoid a disturbance of trade, which would ultimately have disrupted the working of the intervention system for skimmed-milk powder, that the Commission decided to apply in 1971 the system of compensatory amounts to powdered whey.The subsequent abolition from 5 September 1977, by Regulation No 1824/77, of the compensatory amounts applied to powdered whey is to be explained in a wider context. The Commission tries to keep the number of products covered by this system very low and is taking progressively less account of the processing costs in calculating compensatory amounts. In view of the importance of such items in the cost of manufacturing powdered whey the Commission, complying with requests from traders, including the plaintiff in the main action, considered that in the circumstances then prevailing, perhaps only temporarily, the absence of compensatory amounts for that product would not disturb trade. However, a decision in this sphere must also take into account possible effects on the profitability of the cheese industry.The Commission finally emphasizes that the method of calculating the monetary compensatory amounts applied to powdered whey was not the usual method of derivation, which consisted in taking account only of the protein content, but took into consideration the relationship between the market prices of powdered whey and of skimmed-milk powder. This method of calculation involved the fixing of monetary compensatory amounts which were clearly lower than those which would have been produced by the usual method and traders like the plaintiff in the main action have no ground for complaint, since the result is reasonable from an economic point of view.In conclusion the Commission suggests that the reply to the questions submitted by the Finanzgericht des Saarlandes should be as follows:‘Consideration of the question raised has disclosed no factor of such a kind as to affect the validity of Regulation (EEC) No 539/75 of the Commission of 28 February 1975 in so far as it provides monetary compensatory amounts applicable on the importation of powdered whey.’
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.