law://eu/cjeu/1976/c-10-76/hd_1_1_3@2026-11-16In the submission of the Commission, first of all the Italian Republic failed to fulfil its obligation to enact before 29 July 1972 the measures necessary to give effect to the directive and, furthermore, Law No 14 of 2 February 1973 only fulfilled its obligations under that directive very incompletely.Indeed:(a) whereas the directive applies to all procedures for the award of contracts, both ‘open’ and ‘restricted’ (Article 5), the Italian Law applies only to the procedure for award by restricted invitation to tender, termed ‘licitazione privata’;(b) Article 29 (3) of Directive No 71/305/EEC provides for the progressive abolition of the Italian ‘anonymous envelope’ procedure, but the Italian Law makes no mention of this subject;(c) The second paragraph of Article 12 of the directive provides for the publication of notices of contracts in the Official Journal of the European Communities: the Italian Law limits itself (Article 7) to providing for the publication of notices in the Official Journal of the Italian Republic;(d) In Articles 16 (d) and 17 (a) the directive lays down the obligation to indicate the time-limit for the completion of the works. The Italian Law makes no provision in this connexion;(e) The criteria for qualitative selection, specified as essential in Articles 20, 24, 25 and 26 of the directive (vocational aptitude, financial and economic standing and technical knowledge or ability), which must be observed by the authority awarding contracts, are not mentioned in the Italian Law, which thus maintains the wide discretionary powers conferred on authorities awarding contracts by the previous provisions;(f) Under the last paragraph of Article 15 of the directive, requests for participation and invitations to tender may be made by telegram, telex message or telephone. As the Italian Law makes no mention of this subject, the Commission is of the opinion that the prohibition on tendering by telegram is still in force in Italy;(g) The time-limit fixed by authorities for receipt of requests to participate must not, according to the directive (first paragraph of Article 14) be less than twenty-one days from the date of sending the notice of contract; the Italian Law limits itself to providing a minimum time-limit of 10 days from the publication of the notice;(h) The Italian Law does not lay down any obligation formulated in Article 29 (5) of Directive No 71/305/EEC to justify to the Advisory Committee the rejection of tenders considered to be too low.The Italian authorities moreover implicitly accepted the findings of the Commission and realized the need to adjust the Italian legal system to the Community provisions, as is shown by the existence of the bill submitted to the Chamber of Deputies on 13 August 1974 and not yet passed.As appears from the judgment of the Court of Justice of 21 June 1973 (Case 79/72, Commission v Italian Republic [1973] ECR 667 at p. 672) the failure to observe the time-limit laid down first by the Directive (29 July 1972) and subsequently by the reasoned opinion (1 May 1975) constitutes a serious failure by a Member State to fulfil its obligations.In its defence the Italian Government points out that the bill presented to the Chamber of Deputies on 13 August 1974 is designed to amend existing law to the extent necessary to put the directive into effect.It was for reasons of legal certainty that the provisions of the directive were reiterated in a Law, a procedure which offers greater guarantees but takes longer. The Italian Government hopes that the bill will be passed as soon as possible, so that the subject-matter of the action may be considered as having ceased to exist.In its reply the Commission points out that the defendant does not challenge the validity of the submissions and conclusions formulated in the application. It stresses, as has already been done in the reasoned opinion of 1 April 1975, that Bill No 3219 submitted to the Chamber of Deputies on 13 August 1974 would in large measure satisfy, both as to substance and as to form, the conditions set by Council Directive No 71/305. The Commission acknowledges that the nature of the Italian legal system is such that it is impossible to carry out the necessary amendments and adjustments in national law by any instrument other than a Law: no possibility exists of adopting lesser measures, such as administrative measures.It observes however that the choice of form and methods for giving effect to Community directives left to national authorities by Article 189 of the EEC Treaty is subject to limitations. One limitation of an external kind is constituted by the subject-matter of the directive If for example the directive is aimed at circumscribing the extent of the discretionary power of public authorities, the national measures for giving effect to it inevitably have the nature of legislative acts, that is to say, acts which are mandatory and binding on the administration and capable of creating rights for individuals which are enforceable in a court of law. One limitation which might be described as ‘internal’ is constituted by the state of national substantive law governing the subject-matter of the directive. The choice of the methods used to adjust the internal legal system will be conditioned by the form of the instruments already in existence; the choice will have to obey the principle of the hierarchy of the sources of law in force in each national legal system.It follows from these considerations that an instrument having force of law appears to constitute the only method capable of allowing proper application of Directive No 71/305.If it is true, as the Italian Government states in its defence, that other Member States have not considered it appropriate to give effect to the directive by way of legislation, it should however be observed that, on the practical level and as to its substance, the directive is nevertheless applied in those Member States.Whilst joining with the Italian Government in hoping for the immediate passing of Bill No 3219 by both Houses, the Commission feels that it must emphasize the seriousness of the infringement committed by the Italian Republic. Directive No 71/305 introduces machinery appropriate to stimulate effective competition between undertakings in the Community, by coordinating procedures for the award of public contracts. Failure to put it into effect hinders and delays the process of interpenetration in the sphere of public works contracts.The Italian Government did not lodge a rejoinder.In the oral procedure, on 6 July 1976, the parties enlarged upon the arguments put forward in the written procedure. At the request of the Court, the Commission produced a list of the measures taken in the Member States to give effect to Directive No 71/305/EEC.The Advocate-General delivered his opinion at the hearing on 13 July 1976.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.