law://eu/cjeu/1979/c-93-79/hd_1_1_3@2026-11-18In its application the Commission maintains that the mandatory nature of the directive as regards the result to be achieved means that the Member States are required to observe the periods laid down. This also emerges from the case-law of the Court (cf. judgment in Case 10/76, Commission v Italian Republic [1977] ECR 1359).Case-law (judgment in Case 100/77, Commission v Italian Republic [1978] ECR 879) shows just as clearly that a Member State cannot rely upon domestic difficulties or provisions of its national legal system, even its constitutional system, for the purpose of justifying a failure to comply with obligations and periods resulting from Community directives.In its defence the Italian Government stresses that the two draft laws submitted to the Senate in October 1977 were not adopted as a result of the premature dissolution of the legislature. It feels that the fact that it had adopted a decree-law on 14 April 1978 proves that it has not spared any efforts to carry out its obligations and the fact that these efforts were not successful was due to political and parliamentary events. It hopes that the approval of Parliament will be obtained shortly so that the present dispute may be considered to have lost its point.In its letter of 24 August 1979 the Commission states that neither the intention nor the hope of the Italian Government, nor the reasons given to explain the failure to implement the directive in question, can alter the fact that the said failure to implement the directive amounts to an infringement of the Treaty.The Commission, represented by A. Prozzillo, acting as Agent, and the Italian Government, represented by I. M. Braguglia, Avvocato dello Stato, presented oral argument at the sitting on 22 November 1979.The Advocate General delivered his opinion on 6 December 1979.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.