law://eu/cjeu/1978/c-180-78/hd_1_1_2_2@2026-11-17Before submitting its observations on the question of interpretation as such, the Commission first makes some preliminary remarks. It points out that it is surprising to find that, although the minimum rate of incapacity for work required in order to become entitled to a pension under the Netherlands legislation, which is based on the risk involved, is lower than that required by the German legislation, the appellant in the main action did not receive invalidity benefits from the competent Netherlands institution in 1970 and her invalidity was not recognized in the Netherlands until October 1972. It goes on to point out that the German invalidity pension was granted in 1970 in respect of partial incapacity, while the Netherlands invalidity pension relates to total incapacity for work. It seems then that the German pension should have been reviewed to take account of the worsening of the invalidity in accordance with the provisions of Article 41 of Regulation No 1408/71. It goes on to observe that it is strange that the Netherlands pension was not reduced in 1973 pursuant to Regulation No 1408/71 and that it was reduced by a decision taken in 1976 under the national rules against overlapping of benefits, whereas the German pension was converted into an old-age pension. The Commission also points out that the German old-age pension seems to be based on a period of full-time employment, while the Netherlands invalidity pension is granted only for previous part-time employment.Thus there is only a partial overlapping and it would be more just, in so far as the Netherlands rule against overlapping is applicable, to apply it only to that part of the Netherlands benefit which overlaps with a fraction of the German old-age pension corresponding to the pan-time employment. Finally, the Commission emphasizes that from 1950 to 1957 the appellant in the main action continued to pay voluntary contributions to the German insurance organization, while at the same time being compulsorily insured in the Netherlands. It follows that the present case raises the question whether, in applying the national rule against overlapping, account must be taken of the voluntary insurance periods which are superimposed on compulsory insurance periods. That question depends on the application of Article 46 of Regulation No 574/72 of the Council of 21 March 1972, fixing the procedure for implementing Regulation No 1408/71 (Official Journal, English Special Edition 1972 (I), p. 159). The Court was asked to interpret that article in Case 176/78, Schaap v Bestuur van de Bedrijfs-vereniging voor Bank en Verze-keringswezen, Groothandel en Vrije Beroepen. The Commission refers to the observations which it submitted in that case.As regards the preliminary question properly so-called, the Commission observes that, although it does not emerge directly from the question, it is clear from the decision making the reference that the problem raised in the present case concerns once again the question whether it is legitimate in relation to Community law to apply a national rule against overlapping in the event of overlapping between two benefits acquired in two Member States. However, whereas in the other cases referred to the Court it was question of overlapping between benefits of the same type, in particular invalidity benefits, here it is a question of overlapping between two benefits which are not of the same type, namely in the one case an old-age benefit resulting from the conversion of an invalidity pension and in the other case an invalidity benefit. The Commission goes on to state that Regulation No 1408/71 contains a special provision covering the problem of overlapping between such an old-age pension, resulting from the conversion of an invalidity pension, and an invalidity pension; the provision in question is Article 43 of that regulation. However, that provision only concerns the case of a worker who is already in receipt of an invalidity pension under the legislation of two Member States when one of those two benefits is converted into an old-age pension. As the said Article 43 authorizes the overlapping of the two benefits within certain limits, the question submitted to the Court of Justice by the national court in fact amounts to asking whether in the case in question, where entitlement to the Netherlands pension arose after the conversion of the German invalidity pension into an old-age pension, it is proper to apply Chapter 3 of Regulation No 1408/71, which would in all cases allow workers to be guaranteed a pro rata pension where the application of the national legislation against overlapping proves less favourable than the scheme established by Article 46 of Regulation No 1408/71.As the problem of applying Chapter 3 of Regulation 1408/71 by analogy is raised in the light of Article 43, the Commission recalls the mechanism set up by that article and also the ratio legis of the provision in question. With regard more particularly to paragraphs (2) and (3) of Article 43, the Commission observes essentially that they concern invalidity benefits which are not or have not yet been converted into old-age benefits. According to paragraph (2) the institution responsible for providing the invalidity benefit must continue to pay it until such time as it must convert that benefit into an old-age pension. That provision thus permits overlapping between an invalidity pension and an old-age pension without any reduction other than that which the invalidity pension underwent, where appropriate, at the time when it was first granted. Consequently it should be interpreted as meaning that the application of the first sentence of Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 is excluded and thus national provisions against overlapping are not applicable. As regards Article 43 (3), that provision covers the particular situation of an individual who has been subject exclusively to legislation of type A and is at a given moment entitled to an old-age pension under the legislation of at least one Member State which did not grant him any invalidity pension, whilst he remains entitled to a full invalidity pension under the legislation to which he was subject at the time when the risk materialized. In such a case where Chapter 3 has not been applied for the award of the invalidity pension, paragraph (3) of Article 43 provides a corrective factor in relation to paragraph (2) of the same provision. The institution responsible for providing the invalidity benefit may recalculate the amount of the benefit pursuant to Article 46, to which Article 49 (1) (a) refers, as if the worker satisfied the conditions required by the legislation which it applies for entitlement to old-age benefits, replacing the theoretical amount provided for in Article 46 (2) (a) by the amount of the invalidity benefit. That would permit the reduction provided for in Article 46 (3) to be applied and would in all cases guarantee the worker the pro rata amount when that is higher than the amount resulting from the application of the national provisions against the overlapping of benefits.The Commission goes on to state that the ratio legis of Article 43 confirms the conclusion that, apart from the corrective factor provided for in paragraph (3), Article 43 of Regulation No 1408/71 excludes the application of national provisions against overlapping. In fact, if Chapter 3 of Regulation No 1408/71 was applied for the award of invalidity pensions, the invalidity pension which is not converted into an old-age pension and which therefore continues to be paid will have been reduced where appropriate. Besides, the old-age pension which replaces the invalidity pension is often of the same amount as the latter. If, on the other hand, Chapter 3 was not applied when the invalidity pension was awarded, and if the worker completed a long period of insurance in the Member State responsible for providing an old-age pension, the granting of an old-age pension which overlaps with a full invalidity pension could then lead to unfair overlapping. For that reason Article 43 (3) introduced a corrective factor permitting the reduction to be applied which had not taken place when the invalidity pension was awarded.The Commission goes on to observe that it is none the less worth noting that it is clear from the very wording of Article 43 of Regulation No 1408/71 that it presupposes that the entitlement to an invalidity pension under the legislation of one Member State precedes entitlement to the old-age pension under the legislation of another Member State. Hence the court making the reference was quite right to consider that in principle that provision was not applicable to this case. Thus it seems, according to the Commission, that in this case only Article 49 of Regulation No 1408/71 is applicable. That provision in fact lays down the rules according to which a benefit is awarded when the person concerned does not simultaneously satisfy the conditions imposed by all the bodies of legislation under which periods of insurance or residence have been completed. The said Article 49 belongs to Chapter 3 of Regulation No 1408/71 which, in accordance with Article 40 (1), applies by analogy for the award of invalidity pensions when one of the bodies of legislation to which the worker has been subject is not of the type referred to in Article 37 (1) (type A). Hence the Commission considers that the answer to the question submitted can only be in the affirmative.The Commission then points out that the problem raised by the case of the appellant in the main action is not completely solved by such an answer. Taking account of the scope of Article 43, it is necessary also to ascertain how the provisions of Chapter 3 must be applied. Article 49, and more particularly paragraph (1) (b) (ii) thereof, is the provision applicable to this case. The application of that provision entails the granting of an independent invalidity pension, the overlapping of which with an old-age pension may entail the application of the national provisions against overlapping of benefits by virtue of the first sentence of Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71. One is then in a surprising situation, to say the least, whereby, according as the right to old-age benefits arises after or before the acquisition of the right to the invalidity benefit, overlapping is either permitted totally or partially, or prohibited and the benefit reduced to zero if the national provision against overlapping is particularly severe. That difference in treatment is due solely to the restrictive wording of Article 43. It results from the application of the provisions in force and is due solely to a lacuna in the Community rules. The Commission goes on to state that the same treatment, namely the guarantee provided by Article 43, should be accorded to all cases of overlapping between an invalidity pension and an old-age pehsion. The application by analogy of Chapter 3 provided for in Article 40 (1) of Regulation No 1408/71 implies that it is necessary to have recourse to the provisions of Article 46, which moreover is in accordance with the case-law of the Court on the overlapping of pensions.Consequently the Commission proposes the following answer to the question submitted by the court making the reference:‘Article 40 (1) of Regulation No 1408/71 must be interpreted as meaning that when a worker has been successively subject to invalidity legislation based on the materialization of the risk and to legislation which makes the amount of the invalidity benefit dependent on periods of insurance or vice versa, Chapter 3 of Regulation No 1408/71, and in particular Article 46, is applicable by analogy to the payment of the invalidity benefits.’
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.