law://eu/cjeu/1980/c-4-80/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-17Mr D'Amico says in his statement of case that it is obvious that the rigid application of rules of incompatibility may have damaging results for a migrant worker if a benefit enjoyed by virtue of the national legislation of a State is reduced to nothing owing to a national rule which comes up against situations which are not contemplated by that national legislation. In such cases it is necessary to determine whether the national provisions cancelling the right to a benefit payable to a migrant worker by virtue of periods of insurance which he has completed in a Member State are compatible with Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty.He refers to the case-law of the Court contained in Cases 184/73 Kaufmann [1974] ECR 517 and 83/77 Naselli [1978] ECR 683, according to which Article 11 (2) of Regulation No 3 (to which Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 corresponds) is “the counterweight to the advantages which Regulations Nos 3 and 4 procure for workers by enabling them to claim the simultaneous application of the social security laws of several Member States and its purpose is to prevent them from deriving from that application advantages which the national legislation considers excessive; therefore the restrictions referred to in Article 11 (2) only apply to insured persons in so far as the benefits acquired by applying those regulations are concerned”.In this case the applicant acquired entitlement to the Belgian pension pursuant to the application of Community regulations. Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 may not have the effect of reducing the Belgian benefit to nothing and of leaving the applicant, as the counterweight of that loss, the benefit of only the apportioned Italian invalidity pension, especially since he never applied personally for that Italian pension.Articles 37 and 40 of Regulation No 1408/71 make a distinction in the case of invalidity pensions between legislation based on the risk which does not make the amount of invalidity benefit dependent on the length of the periods of insurance (so-called Type A legislation), and legislation which does make the amount of benefits dependent on the length of the periods of insurance (so-called Type B legislation). The so-called Type B legislation treats invalidity as premature old-age. The Italian legislation on invalidity is of the B type. An invalidity pension has the characteristics and the constituent elements of an early retirement pension and does not undergo any change when retirement age is reached. The Italian invalidity pension can accordingly be regarded as corresponding to an early retirement pension and as such does not bar the grant of the Belgian retirement pension.Mr D'Amico proposes the following answer to the questions referred to the Court:“Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71, which makes application of a national provision such as that set forth in Article 25 of Arrêté Royal No 50 of 24 October 1967 possible, is incompatible with Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty if its effect is to reduce pensions payable under the legislation of a single Member State to nothing.For the purposes of the application of Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 the invalidity benefits which, in accordance with Article 43 of the same regulation, are not converted into old-age pensions on account of their permanent character, are to be regarded as early retirement pensions”.The Office National des Pensions pour Travailleurs Salariés (ONPTS) first goes into the Belgian legislation applicable and the method of calculation adopted by the Office following the judgment of 21 October 1975 in Case 24/75 Petroni [1975] ECR 1149.Because Mr D'Amico could show 25 years of employment as a miner in Belgium he was able to benefit from the provisions of the first paragraph of Article 10 (2) of Arrêté Royal No 50 and consequently be deemed to have a number of additional calendar years equal to the difference between 30 and 25. He established that he had received benefit for 194 weeks in Italy, from 1 March 1947 to 13 September 1952, which was deemed to be equivalent to six years of work. In the case of a worker who has been employed in Belgium as a mineworker and has been employed abroad otherwise than in mines the Office takes into consideration the fact that according to Belgian law entitlement to the pension is acquired only at l/45th per year and not l/30th and takes only two-thirds of that insurance record into consideration to determine the number of added notional years as a mineworker which must be ignored in order to comply with the 100 % limit rule, or 30/30ths. In Mr D'Amico's case the six years of work in Italy multiplied by 2/3rds produces four. Four added notional years as a mineworker are therefore to be ignored. The Belgian pension is therefore calculated at 26/30ths, or an amount of Bfr 234 925.The Office believes that the answer to the questions submitted was in large measure given in the judgment by the Court on 19 June 1979 in Case 180/78 Brouwer-Kaune [1979] ECR 2111.Article 25 of the Arrêté Royal is perfectly compatible with the provisions of Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71. On the other hand that would not be the case if the benefits were calculated with reference to the aggregation and apportionment rules.Article 50 of the regulation has no application; a minimum benefit is provided in Belgium only by the legislation on invalidity pensions for mineworkers.Article 25 of the Arrêté Royal is compatible with Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty on two grounds: it does not contain any discrimination on the grounds of nationality, and, provided the legislation of a Member State complies with the principle of equal treatment, Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty do not require Member States to take into account, in their national legislation, characteristics specific to the legislation of other countries.The Government of the Italian Republic emphasizes in the first place that Mr D'Amico has completed, both in Belgium and in Italy and on the basis of different years which do not overlap, two periods of insurance, each of them sufficient to afford entitlement to respectively an old-age pension in Belgium and invalidity pension in Italy. Therefore he has no need to rely on Community rules in order to bring about the fulfilment of the conditions required by the national legislation of each Member State. The question which arises is whether the rule against overlapping contained in the Belgian legislation may be regarded as being compatible with the Community system and whether it is permitted by Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71. From the guidelines evinced in the judgment of the Court in Case 34/69 Duffy [1969] ECR 597 it seems obvious that the provisions set forth in the first part of Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 has no application at all in this case.It follows that national legislatures cannot be left to promulgate provisions imposing restrictions on migrant workers which the Community legislature itself is not empowered to impose and which in any event lack any reciprocal arrangements (unlike that provided, pursuant to the Community rules on overlapping, by Regulation No 1408/71).The Italian Government proposes the following answer to the questions:“A national rule against overlapping which, in the absence of reciprocal arrangements and Community rules, has the effect of reducing social security benefits granted to a migrant worker under the national law of a single Member State on the ground that such a worker has been granted another social security benefit, which is itself payable under the national law of another single Member State, is not compatible with the EEC Treaty or with Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71”.The Belgian Government maintains that it is clear from Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 that there is no incompatibility between Article 25 of Arrêté Royal No 50 and Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71. The compatibility of the said Article 25 with the provisions of Articles 46 and 50 of Regulation No 1408/71 is also beyond question.As regards the compatibility of Article 25 in point with Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty, foreigners are not treated differently from Belgian nationals and therefore there is no incompatibility.The Commission takes the view that Article 50 of Regulation No 1408/71 does not enter into this case for the reasons explained by the ONPTS.Where the compatibility of the Community provisions in question is concerned, if there is a problem of compatibility it is rather the result of a lacuna in the Community rules. It is apparent from the case-law of the Court that although the Court recognizes the applicability of national rules against overlapping in the case of benefits payable to a worker under the national legislation of a single Member State, it nevertheless views Article 46 (1) as a provision restricting the effect of national rules against overlapping. National provisions, including rules against overlapping, may have application provided only that the effect thereof is more advantageous to a worker than that obtained by applying Article 46 of the regulation. Situations are at issue which are expressly referred to by that article, either directly or by way of reference made by other provisions of the regulation (Article 40 (1), Article 43).The problem is different with regard to the rule against overlapping contained in Article 25 of Arrêté Royal No 50 which contemplates a situation in which there are concurrent benefits and which is not expressly dealt with by the Community rules. It prohibits the overlapping of benefits of a different nature. The payment of retirement pension is suspended on account of the grant to the individual concerned of an invalidity benefit.An application of Article 25 of Arrêté Royal No 50 which deprives the individual concerned of the whole of the retirement pension acquired by virtue of 25 years of work as a miner underground in Belgium owing to a small invalidity pension which he receives in another Member State may hardly be regarded as being compatible with the general objectives of Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty and with the scheme of Regulation No 1408/71, particularly in the light of the case-law of the Court.The observations of Mr Advocate General Capotorti in Case 180/78 cited above showed that in situations such as this the proper view to be taken is that the fact that the benefits in question are of different content does not fix the limits resulting from Article 46 of Regulation No 1408/71 in the case of the application of national rules against overlapping. Mr Advocate General Capotorti stated that“the effects of the national provisions against the overlapping of benefits must be restricted even in the case of the award, in different States, of concurrent invalidity and old-age pensions to which the worker is entitled as a result of insurance periods completed mainly at different times in the two States concerned”.The Advocate General concluded :“If the case concerns national rules against the overlapping of benefits which take into consideration the old-age pension drawn by the insured person in another State, for the purpose of reducing his invalidity pension, the different nature of the two concurrent pensions must not be used to render inapplicable those Community principles or rules which guarantee the worker's entitlement to benefits, acquired in the State in which the aforesaid rules against overlapping are in force, at least within the limits of the apportionment provided for in Article 46”.In its judgment in the same case the Court of Justice ruled:“The absence of any express provision covering that type of case must be regarded as a lacuna. There is no objective reason to apply in that type of case a rule different from that applied in the cases expressly referred to. The protection of the rights which the person concerned possesses by virtue of national legislation alone, without having recourse to the system of aggregation and apportionment, and respect for any advantages resulting from that system, are mandatory principles applying equally in all situations. Consequently, the systematic interpretation of the provisions of the regulation enables Article 40 (1) to be applied by analogy to cases such as the present one. If it were not possible to adopt that solution, it could even be said that the Council had failed to carry out completely the duty incumbent upon it, by virtue of Article 51 of the Treaty, to adopt such measures in the field of social security as are necessary to provide freedom of movement for workers”.The problem is in different terms in this case inasmuch as the relevant national rule against overlapping is not concerned with what happens to the individual's invalidity benefit but with what happens to his retirement pension and it is decidedly more difficult to find the solution by reference to an express provision of Regulation No 1408/71. Yet the requirements are strictly the same and the considerations taken into account in the Brouwer-Kaume case may be applied here. There is every reason to believe that the scheme of Article 46, which it appears should be seen as embodying a rule of common law, should also be capable of application, if only by analogy, in a situation such as this.In all the circumstances, national authorities should treat old-age pensions and invalidity pensions on the same footing. Indeed, such treatment is expressly provided for by Regulation No 1408/71 in the case of certain Member States where the application of Article 12 (2) is concerned. Following the accession of the three new Member States provisions to that effect were inserted in Annex V to the regulation.That point of view was precisely the one adopted by the responsible Belgian authorities in their circulars and departmental memoranda sent by the Minister of Social Security to the ONPTS. Those instructions require the social security organizations concerned to treat a foreign invalidity pension, granted at the normal pensionable age in Belgium, as a retirement pension.The Commission proposes the following answers to the questions put by the Tribunal du Travail:1. A rule against overlapping contained in the national legislation of a Member State the effect of which is to bar entitlement to an old-age pension acquired under that legislation when the interested party may claim a benefit under the legislation of another Member State by reason of periods of employment completed by him under the legislation of that State is incompatible with Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty establishing the European Economic Community.2. Consideration of the question raised has disclosed no factor of such a kind as to affect the validity of Articles 12, 46 and 50 of Regulation No 1408/71, as the meaning and scope thereof have been defined by the Court of Justice”.The Council contends in its observations that an application of Article 25 of Arrêté Royal No 50 such as in the instant case, whereby the interested party is deprived of the entire retirement pension to which his 25 years of work in the Belgian mines entitle him because he is in receipt of an Italian invalidity pension by reason of his having worked in Italy, is unacceptable and even incompatible with the objectives of Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty, particularly in the light of the case-law of the Court. It advances arguments similar to those put forward by the Commission and believes that the scheme of Article 46 of the regulation must be applied by analogy in this case.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.