The observations of the Commission may be summarized as follows:(1) Article 13 (a) of Regulation No 3, as worded at that time, provides that:‘Wage-earners and assimilated workers whose permanent residence is in the territory of one Member State and who are employed in the territory of another State by an undertaking having in the territory of the former State an establishment to which they are normally attached (“ waarbij zij gewoonlijk werkzaam zijn”) shall be subject to the legislation of the former State as though they were employed in its territory, in so far as the probable duration of their employment in the territory of the latter State does not exceed twelve months; if such employment continues beyond twelve months, the legislation of the former State shall continue to apply for a further period of not more than twelve months, on condition that the competent authority of the latter State, or the agency designated by it, has given consent thereto before the end of the first twelve month period.’In accordance with these provisions, the Commission considers the relevant Netherlands legislation to be applicable in the present case.(a) The condition laid down in Article 13 (a) that the worker concerned should be permanently resident in the Netherlands does not raise any problem in this case.(b) The requirement in Article 13 (a) that the workers must be employed by an undertaking having an establishment (in this instance in the Netherlands) ‘to which they are normally attached’ forms the subject-matter of one of the additional questions in the order of reference and is at the centre of the discussion.In principle, by virtue of Article 12 workers are subject to the legislation of the State in whose territory they are employed, even if the undertaking which employs them is established in the territory of another Member State.As an exception to this rule, Article 13 (a) allows the legislation of the country in which the undertaking is established to take effect, subject, as is stated in the phrase in question, to the existence of a specific economic link between the workers and the undertaking which has temporarily posted them to anothercountry.The Netherlands version of this phrase (‘waarbij zij gewoonlijk werkzaam zijn’) suggests the existence of a link between the present employment and earlier employment in an establishment situated in the territory of another Member State and thus appears to prevent the application of Article 13 (a) in this instance.
However, the meaning of the other three versions of this phrase is different; they express no more than an organic relationship between the workers and the undertaking which is temporarily employing them in the territory of another Member State (‘stabilimento da cui i lavoratori dipendono normalmente’, ‘etablissement dont ils relèvent normalement’, ‘Betrieb dem die Arbeitnehmer gewohnlich angehoren’). These three phrases correspond to the Dutch phrase (‘bedrijf, waaraan hij gewoonlijk verbonden is’) which was inserted in the new Article 13 by Regulation No 24/64 of the Council.
Moreover, the preparatory documents were prepared exclusively in French and the expression ‘dont ils relevent normalement’ (‘to which they are normally attached’) was to be found in all the preliminary drafts.
Article 13 (a) should therefore be inter preted to apply to workers who are engaged solely in order to carry out work in the territory of a Member State other than that in which the establishment to which they are attached is situated. This interpretation is in accordance with that given by the Administrative Commission in its Decision No 12 of 18 September 1959.
The Commission of the European Communities, therefore, attaches little importance to the fact that the work assigned to the workers in the country to which they are temporarily posted is different from that normally carried out by that undertaking in the country in which it is established, as it in no way weakens the link between the worker and the undertaking.
The Commission therefore replies in the negative to the additional question put forward on this point.
On the other hand, the Commission states that in the case of a ‘temporary loan of labour’, application of the legislation of the State in which the undertaking is established could not be justified because in such a case the worker no longer comes under the authority of this undertaking in carrying out his work.
(c) As regards the question posed by the Centrale Raad regarding the meaning of the word ‘employment’ in the phrase ‘the probable duration of their employment’, the Commission considers that in the light of the present text, which is laid down by Regulation No 24/64 and which refers to the ‘anticipated duration of the work’, this expression must be interpreted in the original text of Article 13 (a) as applying to the worker himself rather than to the work. This modified wording is in no way intended to interpret the earlier text, but represents a concern to combat the abuses to which the latter had given rise.
(2) As regards the interpretation of Article 12, the second part of the first question raises the problem whether a worker may be considered as being employed, within the meaning of this article, in the territory of the country in which he permanently resides when an accident occurs in this territory during transport at the employer's expense to his place of employment.
The Commission takes the view mat this question is identical with the question whether, for the purposes of the application of Article 12, the journey must be treated as the place of employment and whether an accident occurring in circumstances such as those of the present case constitutes an industrial accident.
The Commission considers that the distinction which is made in national law between industrial accidents in the true sense and accidents which occur during the journey to the place of employment cannot influence the solution which emerges from the conflict of laws, as it might lead to the adoption of different solutions according to the laws applicable.
Moreover, reference cannot be made to a principle of national law in determining the legislation to be applied.
If the territory in which the accident happened were to be decisive as regards the legislation applicable, such legislation would vary according to the traffic hazards in that country.
The result in this instance would be to render Article 12 meaningless, since a worker would be subject to two legislative systems rather man to one.
As a result of the principle of the obliteration of frontiers in the field of social security for workers an accident which occurs during the journey to the place of employment must be considered as occurring in the territory of the Member State whose legislation is applicable. It is therefore unnecessary to consider whether the worker is already employed during the journey.
(3) As regards the Centrale Raad van Beroep's question whether a court in a Member State is bound by a decision taken by the Administrative Commission — a question concerning the interpretation of Article 43 of Regulation No 3 — the Commission of the European Communities states:
(a) that in interpreting Community provisions, national courts are not obliged to follow the interpretation of the Administrative Commission, as is shown by the wording of the second part of Article 43 (a);
(b) that, although the courts concerned regard them as mere expressions of opinion, these decisions still carry great weight; that the members of the Administrative Commission are in fact chosen from among the highest officials in each national administration; that they are especially well qualified officials, many of whom have been involved in the studies concerning the ‘European Convention on Social Security for Migrant Workers’.
(4) As the Netherlands legislation providing for a compulsory insurance scheme in respect of industrial accidents for workers employed outside the Netherlands already applies to the defendant, the court referring the matter asked whether the Netherlands legislation may also be applied ‘at the same time and in addition’ to the relevant Belgian legislation, should the latter be applicable under Article 12 of Regulation No 3.
On this point the Commission makes the following observations:
(a) To what extent is a simultaneous application of the relevant Belgian and Netherlands legislation possible as regards benefits}
As regards the problem of the simultaneous application of several legislative systems, the Court in its judgment in Case 92/63(Moebs, nee Nonnenmacher) laid down the principle that Article 12 of Regulation No 3 ‘does not prohibit Member States other than those in the territory of which wageearners or assimilated workers are employed from applying their social security legislation to such persons’. However, the Court considered that the position might be different where a Member State other than that in whose territory the worker is employed ‘requires him to contribute to the financing of an institution which would not accord him supplementary protection by way of social security in respect of the same risk and of the same period’.
In this instance the burden or contributions is transferred and passes from the workers to the employers who direcdy or indirecdy support the exclusive burden of compensation. In the case of the simultaneous application of both Belgian and Netherlands legislation, the employer concerned finds himself in this instance subject to claims for the amounts due under the legislation of both States. As the Advocate-General emphasized in the case of Moebs, nee Nonnenmacher, for an employer to pay a double contribution in respect of a single risk is contrary to the aim of Article 12 and also, in the opinion of the Commission, to the objectives of Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty, as well as to Articles 59 et seq.
Moreover, having regard to the fact that the activities of the employer in another Member State constitute a provision of services within the meaning of these articles, such a solution results in his being discriminated against in a manner prohibited by these articles.
(b) The Commission considers that Community law is not opposed to a temporary application of the relevant Netherlands legislation, which awards benefits to the person concerned until settlement of the action, subject to a possible appeal against the employer.
This solution is justified by Article 51 of the Treaty. As the Court said in the case of Moebs, nee Nonnenmacher, the Treaty has placed upon the Council ‘the duty to lay down rules preventing those concerned, in the absence of legislation applying to them, from remaining without protection in the matter of social security’.
This is the result of the dispute over the conflict of laws because, since the Netherlands institutions were doubtful over the interpretation of Article 13 (a), they have refused to award the benefits to which the worker was entitled as long as the question of the application of the Netherlands legislation is not settled. This absence of protection is even more serious in that it arises from the very existence of Community rules on the conflict of laws.
In the absence of express provisions in the regulations and by virtue of the obligation often referred to by the Court to interpret the regulations in accordance with Article 51, the Commission states that it must be acknowledged that the Netherlands institutions are bound to pay the relevant benefits to the worker concerned until such time as the application of different legislation enables that worker to receive these benefits from another social security institution.
The Commission envisages two methods of finally allotting the charges between the institutions, once the rights of the workers are protected:
— if the solution which emerges from the conflict of laws leads to the application of the Netherlands legislation, the Netherlands institution must pay the benefits in question;
— if, on the contrary, Belgian legislation must be applied, apart from the usual reimbursement of benefits in kind, the Netherlands institution must be entitled to bring an action against the employer for the benefits paid in cash or, if necessary, against the Belgian guarantee fund, even if it entails reimbursing the employer for any contributions paid.