law://eu/cjeu/1979/c-9-79/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-20The Government of the Kingdom of the Netherlands points out that, according to its title, the purpose of Article 10 of Regulation No 574/72 is to ensure that the application of Regulations Nos 1408/71 and 574/72 does not give rise to a right to family benefits or family allowances during the same period or pan of a period under the legislation of more than one Member State.Having regard to the purpose of the provision in question it is of no importance whether it is the wife (‘echtgenote’) or husband (‘echtgenoot’) who exercises a professional or trade activity on the territory of a Member State whose legislation does not make the acquisition of the right to the benefits or allowances in question subject to conditions of insurance or employment.This interpretation is corroborated by the French and English versions of the provision in question. Furthermore any other interpretation would hardly be compatible with the prohibition on discrimination on the basis of sex as laid down by Council Directive No 79/7/EEC of 19 December 1978 on the progressive implementation of the principle of equal treatment for men and women in matters of social security (Official Journal 1979, L 6, p. 24).The Commission remarks first of all that, so far as it has been able to judge from the file, the Netherlands family allowances are not paid in their entirety but only to the extent to which they exceed the German family allowances, in pursuance of Article 10 (1) (b) of Regulation No 574/72.The Commission then gives a summary of the Netherlands legislation applicable to the case.The 1962 Law provides for a so-called ‘national’ insurance which, in pursuance of Article 7 thereof, grants family allowances to persons who are insured under that law. All residents who have attained the age of 15 are insured and so are non-residents who are subject to income tax by reason of a professional or trade activity pursued on Netherlands territory within the framework of a relationship of employment (Article 6 (1)).In pursuance of the Laws of 1939 to 1962 any worker resident in the Netherlands is entitled to family allowances for the first and second children (Article 17). A person who is entitled to allowances by virtue of an incapacity for work amounting to at least 45 % in pursuance of the 1966 Law is also deemed to be a worker within the meaning of the first-mentioned law (Article 8 B). As regards the condition of residence it is appropriate to refer also to Article 1 of the Ministerial Decree of 20 December 1969 by virtue of which a worker not residing in the Netherlands is however deemed to have his residence there if and so long as he is insured in pursuance of the 1962 Law.In approaching the question referred to the Court the Commission emphasizes first that the two Netherlands laws applicable in this case make the right to family allowances subject to certain conditions. Hence there is no doubt, according to the Commission, that Article 10 of Regulation No 574/72 does not apply to this case.However, the Commission thinks it advisable to make some observations on that article.The purpose of Article 10 of Regulation No 574/72 is to avoid any unjustified overlapping of benefits. It is clear that the problem to which that provision relates may arise both when a male worker is in receipt of benefits and hence is entitled to family allowances in pursuance of Article 77 and as regards a female worker. If the Dutch version is taken literally and if therefore overlapping of family allowances is prohibited only when a male person is entitled in pursuance of Article 77, that would be tantamount not only to treating fundamentally identical cases differently but also to creating a difference in treatment between two cases according to whether a female or a male worker is involved. Such an interpretation would be contrary to the principle of equality of treatment between men and women as expressed in Article 119 of the Treaty and in the Council Directive of 19 December 1978.Hence the conclusion must be that the provisions of Article 10 (1) (b) concern both the cases referred to so that the expression ‘echtgenote’ (wife) must be understood as meaning husband as well as wife.Furthermore the versions in the other languages have used terms which include both male workers and female workers. The Court has already stated expressly in several judgments that the need for a uniform interpretation of Community regulations makes it impossible for the text of a provision to be considered in isolation but on the contrary requires that, in cases of doubt, it should be interpreted and applied in the light of the versions existing in the other languages (see in particular the judgment of the Court of 5 December 1967, Case 19/67, Van der Vecht, [1967] ECR 345).In its reply to a question asked by the Court, the Commission adjusted the views adopted by it as set out above and supplied further explanations.Family allowances in Germany are only paid where the claimant is domiciled or habitually resident in the territory where the law applies, that is to say, in the Federal Republic of Germany (Article 1 of the Bundeskindergeldgesetz [Federal Law on family allowances], BGBl 6 February 1975 p. 413, as amended by the Law of 14 December 1976, BGBl p. 3341). The remaining conditions do not include requirements relating to insurance or employment.The German legislation on family allowances is therefore of the type mentioned in Article 10 (1) of Regulation No 574/72, so that that article should be applied to Mrs Wösdörfer's case.In this instance it is the provision set out in subparagraph (b) which applies, as Mrs Wörsdörfer's entitlement to family allowances depends on Article 77 of Regulation No 1408/71. According to the first sentence of Article 10 (1) of Regulation No 574/72 the German benefits should be suspended because benefits are due under Article 77 during the same period and for the same children.The second sentence, however, contains an exception to this rule where a person entitled to benefits under Article 77 of Regulation No 1408/71 or — in particular — the spouse exercises a professional or trade activity in the territory of the Member State where there are no conditions of insurance of employment (Germany, in this instance). In such cases the entitlement to the allowances under Article 77 is suspended (that is, in the Netherlands) and the person concerned is then entitled to the benefits or family allowances of the Member State in whose territory the children reside.Finally, the Commission refers to the decision in the Rossi case (judgment of 6 March 1979, Case 100/78). In that case the Court declared that the rule set out in Article 79 (3) of Regulation No 1408/71, designed to avoid overlapping of family allowances, is applicable only to the extent to which it does not, without cause, deprive the persons concerned of the benefit of a part of the legislation of a Member State, and that entitlement should therefore be suspended only to the extent of the amount actually being paid.Since Article 10 of Regulation No 574/72 no more provides the answer to the problem of suspending benefits which are greater than those benefits with which they overlap than does Article 79 the Commission is of the opinion that that article should also be interpreted along the lines of the judgment of the Court referred to above. The competent authorities in the Netherlands can thus suspend entitlement to family benefits only up to the amount of the German family allowances (Kindergeld) and must, if appropriate, pay the surplus to Mrs Wörsdörfer.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.