Shell Petroleum NV and Others v European Commission (T-343/06)

Judgment of 27 Sept 2012

law://eu/cjeu/2006/t-343-06/para_89@2026-11-12

89Moreover, the applicants may not rely on the case-law that it cannot be for the Commission alone, which notifies any objections and adopts the decision imposing a penalty, to determine the documents of use in the defence of the undertaking concerned (Aalborg Portland and Others v Commission, paragraph 36 above, paragraph 126; Solvay v Commission, paragraph 83 above, paragraphs 81 and 83; and Atlantic Container Line and Others v Commission, paragraph 83 above, paragraph 339). That argument, relating to documents within the file compiled by the Commission, cannot apply to the replies given by other parties concerned to the statement of objections.

Shell Petroleum NV and Others v European Commission (T-343/06)

Key facts

History · 1 version