law://eu/cjeu/1983/c-37-83/hd_1_1_3_2_2@2026-11-18The plaintiff claims that the provision in question also contravenes Article 30 of the Treaty and cannot be justified by reference to the first sentence of Article 36.According to the plaintiff the present issue is to verify the legality of a provision, namely, in this case, to check the compatibility of Article 11 of the directive with the Treaty. According to the first paragraph of Article 173, subparagraph (b) of the first paragraph of Article 177 and Article 184 of the Treaty it is also possible, in the course of proceedings to examine the validity of a provision, to consider whether a directive, as an “act of the institutions of the Community” (third paragraph of Article 189 of the Treaty), is valid or invalid as an “infringement” of the Treaty.Referring to the Court's judgment of 8 July 1975 in Case 5/75 (Rewe [1975] ECR 843) the plaintiff submits that phytosanitary inspections, to which plant products from another Member State are subject at the frontier, constitute measures having an effect equivalent to quantitative restrictions and are prohibited subject to the exceptions laid down in Article 36 of the Treaty. Since each consignment of fruit and potatoes imported from a Member State is accompanied by a phytosanitary certificate issued by the exporting State, the inspections carried out by the importing State constitute a second check. According to the plaintiff the only additional checks which may be carried out lawfully in the importing Member State are those which are carried out occasionally and by sampling and which in fact relate to goods which may have been contaminated by harmful organisms during transportation, something that is moreover highly unlikely since the relevant authority's phytosanitary certificate must also relate to the packaging and means of transport of the goods by virtue of Article 6 (1) of the directive.Inspection of up to one-third of imported consignments is not necessaiy within the meaning of the first sentence of Article 36. The plaintiff supports that contention by referring to the Court's order of 4 March 1982 in Case 42/82 R (Commission v French Republic [1982] ECR 841) in which the Court gave a ruling on the extent to which inspection by sampling is admissible and declared that prior to the consignments of the goods in question being put into free circulation such inspections must be restricted to a maximum of 15 % of the consignments presented at the frontier except in cases where there is specific evidence of a particular danger. In the present case, at most, inspection of a maximum of 15 % of imported consignments would be justified and they must be spread as evenly as possible over time and over all the products.The defendant emphasizes in his submission that it has been observed in the field for which he is responsible that inspections by the exporting Member States have not always proved to be effective and that anomalies have been and still are found with regard to imports. He points out moreover that, as a general rule, the maximum limit for inspections is not reached. He annexes to his submissions a list of the objections of all the offices responsible for the inspection of plant products in the Federal Republic of Germany for the period from 1 January 1977 to the beginning of March 1983 with regard to consignments which had to be rejected.The Irish Government states that what is at issue in this case is not a national measure adopted by a Member State but rather a provision contained in a directive adopted by the Council under Articles 43 and 100 of the Treaty. As the directive is based on Article 43 of the Treaty, Article 38 (2) has the effect of removing in the present case the need to examine the justification for the measures contained in the last two sentences of Article 11 (3) of the directive by reference to Article 36 of the Treaty. In those circumstances the Irish Government is of the opinion that the provisions in question may not be reviewed by the Court.If the Court should, contrary to that opinion, rule on the validity of the relevant provisions with regard to Articles 30 and 36, there is a presumption in favour of the validity of those provisions which is in practice virtually conclusive. The Irish Government rejects the analogy made by the plaintiff by reference to the Court's order in Case 42/82 R. That order is not a rule of law but rather an interim measure in a particular case, the subject matter of which was completely different from that of a provision of Community law contained in a Council directive. Control measures on the importation of wine are primarily a matter of protecting the consumer whereas phytosanitary inspection measures concern plants which may introduce a disease or a pest capable of infesting the ground and of affecting future crops. Despite the certificate issued by the exporting Member State, there is a risk that infection may be introduced in intra-Community trade so that it is not excessive to inspect up to one-third of imports. The absence of the necessary level of import monitoring might cause Member States to invoke the safeguard clause contained in Directive No 77/93/EEC.The Irish Government concludes that on the basis of those arguments there is no reason to doubt the validity of the provisions in question.The Council refers to the Court's judgments of 15 December 1976 in Case 35/76 (Simmenthal [1976] ECR 1871), 20 February 1979 in Case 120/78 (Rewe [1979] ECR 649), 8 November 1979 in Case 251/78 (Denkavit [1979] ECR 3369), 17 December 1981 in Case 272/80 (Frans-Nederlandse Maatschappij voor Biologische Producten [1981] ECR 3277), 31 March 1982 in Case 75/81 (Blesgen [1982] ECR 1211) and 8 July 1975 in Case 4/75 (Rewe [1975] ECR 843).It is of the opinion that while the phytosanitary checks carried out by the importing Member State in this case must be regarded as measures having an effect equivalent to quantitative restrictions, Community law provides for exceptions which apply in this case. In that respect it relies on the judgment in Case 4/75 Rewe, cited above. The exceptions are laid down in Article 36 of the Treaty and that article may be relied on directly because Directive No 77/93/EEC has not replaced it with a completely new scheme.The Council emphasizes that this case concerns a legal act of the Community and that the argument may therefore concentrate on that act. Reference should therefore not be made to those cases which are concerned only with unilateral measures adopted by the Member States and in which their compatibility with Articles 30 and 36 was assessed. More relevant is the Court's judgment of 25 January 1977 in Case 46/76 (Bauhuis [1977] ECR 5) concerning Directive No 64/432/EEC whose object was to concentrate inspections of exports from one Member State to another in the exporting State “so that inspections at the frontier organized unilaterally by the importing Member State become unnecessary or are at least reduced to an occasional check that the veterinary and public health measures which are required to be taken in the exporting Member State have been complied with” (paragraph 27). It follows from that judgment that the measures are not adopted by each Member State in order to protect its own interests but by the Council in the general interests of the Community. That judgment therefore supports the view that such inspections are not to be regarded as unilateral measures which hinder trade but rather as operations intended to promote the free movement of goods in particular by rendering ineffective the obstacles to such free movement which might be created for health inspections adopted pursuant to Article 36 (paragraph 30).The Council concedes that Directive No 77/93/EEC, unlike Directive No 64/432/EEC, cannot be regarded as a true harmonizing directive. Nevertheless even where harmonization already exists the Court has recognized the legality of inspections by sampling (see paragraph 20 of its judgment in the Simmenthal case, cited above). The same should apply a fortiori where the approximation is only partial as in this case. In support of this argument the Council once again refers to the judgments in Cases 251/78 and 272/80, cited above. The Council therefore takes the view that a second inspection carried out on up to one-third of consignments is indeed compatible with Article 36 of the Treaty.The Council next considers what the position would be if the Court declared that the penultimate and final sentences of Article 11 (3) of Directive No 77/93/EEC do not fall within Article 36 of the Treaty. Matters would then revert to how they were previously, that is to say the situation would be governed by international law relating to plant protection as laid down by the international convention signed at Rome on 6 December 1951 (Food and Agricultural Organization) which came into force in all the Member States of the Community before the EEC Treaty came into effect. According to Articles VI (1) (a) and VI (2) (a) and (f), the contracting parties have full authority to introduce import restrictions, including the possibility of carrying out a second inspection of all consignments in a systematic and complete manner. The Council therefore states that, “far from being contrary to the Treaty and the Court's case-law”, the one-third rule “has reduced the freedom of action of the Member States in that specific situation.”With regard to the plaintiff's reference to the Court's order in Case 42/82 R the Council notes that that order has lost its validity since final judgment was given on 22 March 1983 [1983] ECR 1013). The plaintiff, nevertheless interpreted that order as a decision of principle concerning the question of the extent of phytosanitary inspections. The Council submits several arguments opposing such an interpretation: To expect decisions of principle from orders given under Article 186 of the Treaty rests on a misconception of the nature of such orders. It would seem to be hazardous to draw a conclusion before knowing and examining the full text of the Court's judgment. Lastly it remains to be verified whether the same provisions are capable of applying to fruit on the one hand and to wine on the other since the inspections serve different purposes.The Council argues finally that the complete text of the order confirms its view. Since the defendant State in Case 42/82 itself considered that inspection by sampling approximately one consignment in 10 was sufficient to guard against any risks, the Court, as a precaution, set the percentage of inspections at 15% in the provisional measures it ordered ad interim. In the final judgment, however, the Court did not give a ruling on the proportion of 15% but it did state that systematic analysis of all imports or of three consignments out of four was contrary to Articles 30 and 36 of the Treaty.In conclusion on that point the Council considers that reducing the proportion inspected from 100% to no more than one-third amounts to substantial progress as referred to in the 12th and 16th recitals of the preamble to the Directive No 77/93/EEC.On the basis of the foregoing, the Council's investigation has not revealed the existence of any factors capable of affecting the validity of the contested provisions. The double inspections permitted by the directive-are without doubt measures having an effect equivalent to quantitative restrictions, yet they are lawful because they fall within the exceptions provided for in Article 36 of the Treaty.The Commission begins its submissions on the present point by recalling the problem as expressed by the Verwaltungsgericht in its request for a preliminary ruling where it was unsure to what extent, at the present stage of the development of Community law, taking into account the harmonization accomplished by Directive No 77/93/EEC, the carrying out of double phytosanitary inspections of one-third of consignments of fruit and potatoes from a Member State was justified, in the absence of any particular reason, for example, signs giving rise to a suspicion that the product was contaminated.The question of the compatibility of the second subparagraph of Article 11 (3) of Directive No 77/93/EEC with Article 30 of the Treaty can, in the Commission's opinion, be divided into three parts:(a) Does Article 30 of the Treaty apply to intra-Community trade in fruit and potatoes?(b) According to which principles does Article 30 of the Treaty apply to legal acts of the Community, in particular to directives on harmonization?(c) Is the second subparagraph of Article 11 (3) of Directive No 77/93/EEC compatible with those principles?With regard to the applicability of Article 30 to fruit and potatoes, the Commission refers to Article 38 (1) of the Treaty, according to which the common market is to extend to agriculture and trade in agricultural products. Under Article 38 (2) the rules laid down for the establishment of the common market are to apply to agricultural products, save as otherwise provided in Articles 39 to 46. On that basis the Commission considers that intra-Community trade in fruit and potatoes is subject to the provisions of Article 30 of the Treaty.Next the Commission considers whether the prohibitions in Articles 30 and 36 are addressed exclusively to the Member States. In its view there can be no doubt that the articles are addressed principally to the Member States because the aim was to abolish the quantitative restrictions applied by the Member States when the common market was established and to prevent their re-introduction. In those circumstances it would be absurd to prohibit the Council or Commission from maintaining or adopting quantitative restrictions or measures having an equivalent effect.It does not necessarily follow that Article 3 (a) of the Treaty provides for “the limitation, as between Member States, of customs duties and of quantitative restrictions on the import and export of goods, and of all other measures having equivalent effect” (only) as a duty imposed on the Member States, when the provision states that it is also the subject of “the activities of the Community” for the purposes set out in Article 2. The Council and the Commission interpret that as meaning not only that they must carry out the tasks expressly assigned to them in Chapter 2 of Title 1 on “Free movement of goods” but also that in the exercise of all their other powers under the Treaties they must pursue the objective of eliminating obstacles to trade in the Community.The Commission takes the view that in this case it is necessary to determine how important the objective of eliminating obstacles to trade is to the harmonization, under Article 100 of the Treaty, of provisions laid down by law and regulation, and to define the duties imposed on the Council and the Commission. In fact that is the sole purpose of the present litigation.Where the purpose of the harmonization directive under Article 100 is, as in this case, to facilitate the functioning of the common market by approximating national supervisory measures, the initial presumption must be that the inspections to be harmonized are not prohibited as such by Article 30 but are, on the contrary, justified under Article 36. Otherwise the Commission could have commenced proceedings pursuant to Article 169 against the Member States for infringement of Article 30 to force them to withdraw the various supervisory measures.It is therefore the responsibility of the Community legislature to attempt to approximate the various existing national inspection systems in such a way that the objectives set out in Article 3 (a), namely the elimination, as between Member States, of quantitative restrictions and all other measures having an equivalent effect, are taken into account as much as possible. The Commission points out that it is difficult to state in abstract terms, by means of legal rules, to what extent the purpose of the approximation of national supervisory provisions is to be effected by harmonization measures. The optimum solution would be the total elimination of all checks within the Community while the most narrow solution would be to harmonize the rules in such a way that the checks do not hinder intra-Community trade any more than they did before harmonization. Between those extremes lies an area within which the Community institutions must meet their goal of harmonization taking account of the principles of necessity, proportionality and nondiscrimination.It follows that the legality of Community measures to harmonize inspections in intra-Community trade must be assessed in accordance with specific criteria as defined above. That principle has been confirmed both in academic writings and in the Court's case-law (see its judgment of 24 October 1973 in Case 10/73 Rewe [1973] ECR 1175 and its judgment in the Baubuis case, cited above), showing that the measures adopted under Community law may not be equated a priori with obstacles to trade adopted unilaterally by the Member States even if the Community measures involve some hindrance to such trade.In addition the Commission attempts to show that the contested directive does not have any more detrimental effect on trade than the former national supervision and that the directive does not infringe the principles of proportionality, necessity and non-discrimination.The Commission sets out the relevant provisions of the International Convention on Plant Protection and concludes that that convention in no way restricts the supervisory powers of the importing States. In comparison with the previous legal position, Directive No 77/93/EEC does, however, considerably restrict the supervisory powers of the Member States thus clearly facilitating intra-Community trade both for the business circles concerned and for the supervisory authorities. First, in particular by giving a common definition of harmful organisms and of specific requirements on the importation of goods, it enables exporting Member States to apply their own phytosanitary legislation when inspecting plants instead of complying with foreign legal provisions as they had to before: supervision is thus simplified considerably and the procedure is therefore more transparent and less haphazard for the exporting Member State. Another major step forward is the fact that the inspection certificate is legally binding and that therefore the number of inspections is limited. The importing Member State's power to carry out inspections is therefore considerably reduced.The principle of necessity, argues the Commission, means that the rules laid down to attain an objective recognized by the legal system must be effective, adequate and necessary: since plant protection is one of the objectives recognized by the legal system and phytosanitary inspections on exportation and importation are an effective and appropriate means of attaining that objective, the only question remaining is whether the contested system of inspection is also necessary to attain that objective.The Commission explains that the “one-third rule” was not at first in its original proposal. After more than 10 years of discussions, resumed in 1973 after the accession of the United Kingdom, Ireland and Denmark, the Council adopted the definitive text of the directive in December 1976 including that rule. The inclusion of the “one-third rule” was the expression of the Council's desire to reconcile two conflicting but equally important objectives. The concept of occasional inspections reflects the intention to hinder trade in this respect as little as possible, while the “one-third rule” reflects the desire to minimize the risks attached to the new provisions adopted by the Community. Moreover, by general agreement a transitional period of four years was fixed for the implementation of the new rules on inspections.The Commission examines at length the risks involved in trade in plants and emphasizes in particular that inspection by the importing Member State serves only to cross-check that the inspection carried out by the consignor State was effective. However the cross-check is accompanied by an additional inspection allowing the diagnosis of contamination that was neither present nor verifiable when the first inspection was carried out by the consignor State. It is therefore not simply a second, duplicated inspection and the system is justified by the fact that it relates to biological matter.In addition the Commission emphasizes that unlike products such as wine which, if they are of low quality or contaminated, cause injury which is limited to the products themselves or the consumers thereof, the consequences of plant diseases are never limited just to the specimens affected. Moreover, as the term “quarantine disease” clearly indicates, the diseases in question are epiphytic diseases which spread very rapidly and which cause immense damage.With regard to the principle of proportionality the Commission submits that a distinction must be drawn between the problem of the proportionality of a rule of law and the problem of its implementation; no such distinction was made by the plaintiff or the Verwaltungsgericht when they attempted to apply an order of the Court concerning the unlawful implementation of Community supervisory measures to the adoption of Community supervisory rules.The Commission maintains that if the plaintiff's reasoning based on the Court's order in Case 42/82 R were correct, it would also be necessary to hold that the provisions governing the wine sector which require the Member States to ensure compliance with Community law and which do not impose a 15% limit on inspections are unlawful.Next the Commission refers to the judgment of 22 March 1983 in Case 42/82 (Commission v French Republic [1983] ECR 1013) according to which the measures of verification carried out must be necessary for attainment of the desired objective and must not create obstacles to trade which are disproportionate to that objective. In that respect it recalls its submissions concerning the necessity of the measure at issue and adds that it does not create disproportionate obstacles to the detriment of the business circles concerned but that Directive No 77/93/EEC is in fact the first step towards eliminating such obstacles. If the directive had not been adopted, the international convention would still be applicable with no restrictions as to the form of supervisory measures.The Commission notes that neither the plaintiff nor the national court has attempted to put forward any argument to support the view that the “one-third rule” is disproportionate. Furthermore, with regard to the implementation of the directive, it points out that the provision in question should in fact rule out inspections being carried out unreasonably frequently. According to the Commission there is no other evidence to suggest that the inspections actually carried out are contrary to Article 30, as would be the case, for example, if the inspections were excessively long.Finally the Commission states that the second subparagraph of Article 11 (3) of Directive No 77/93/EEC does not infringe the principle of non-discrimination either. The final sentence of Article 11 (3) expressly provides that products from different Member States must be treated equally.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.