law://eu/cjeu/1981/c-238-81/hd_1_1_1@2026-11-22Mrs Van der Bunt-Craig, of British nationality, lived in the United Kingdom from her birth on 31 January 1914, and followed a career as a nurse there.In 1938 she married Mr Van der Bunt, of Netherlands nationality, who had been working in the United Kingdom from 1919 and therefore paid contributions to the United Kingdom social security system. From 1 January 1955 Mr Van der Bunt received a retirement pension and in August 1955 he moved to the Netherlands with his wife. From 1 August 1961 Mr Van der Bunt received an old-age pension in the Netherlands pursuant to the Nederlandse Algemene Ouderdomswet [General Law of the Netherlands on Old Age, hereinafter referred to as “the Old-Age Law”].On 4 February 1974 Mrs Van der Bunt-Craig, then aged 60, was granted a retirement pension in the United Kingdom amounting to £ 6 per week paid exclusively on the basis of her husband's social security insurance and contributions.Following the death of Mr Van der Bunt, on 17 September 1974, the amount of the retirement pension was increased. From 23 September 1974 Mrs Van der Bunt received a pension of £10 per week which continued to be paid on the basis of her husband's insurance and contributions.On 4 October 1974 she applied for a widow's pension in the Netherlands under the Nederlandse Algemene Weduwen- en Wezenwet [General Law of the Netherlands of 9 April 1959 on widows and orphans], hereinafter referred to as “the Widows and Orphans Law”.On 12 July 1976 Mrs Van der Bunt-Craig returned to live in the United Kingdom.By a decision of 29 December 1975 the Raad van Arbeid granted Mrs Van der Bunt-Craig a widow's pension which, in accordance with Article 8 (1) and (4) and Article 25 of the Widows and Orphans Law, was due to her from 1 September 1974 to 1 January 1979. The aforementioned provisions envisage, on the one hand, that the Netherlands widow's pension accrues from the first day of the month in the course of which the widow fulfils the conditions required for the acquisition of the right to that pension and, on the other hand, that the widow has no longer any right to pension from the month during which she reaches the age of 65.However, regard being had to the fact that, up to and including February 1975, Mrs Van der Bunt-Craig had been receiving the balance of the retirement pension granted to her husband under the Old-Age Law and that the amount of that benefit was greater than that of the widow's pension, the latter, in accordance with Article 30 (1) of the Widows and Orphans Law could only be paid to her from 1 March 1975.The main action concerns the application by the Raad van Arbeid of the provisions of the Royal Decree of 20 March 1968 (Staatsblad, No 174), which, on the basis of Article 30 (a) of the Widows and Orphans Law, seeks to avoid or to limit cases of the overlapping of a benefit granted under the Widows and Orphans Law with a benefit granted under the social legislation of another country.The Raad van Arbeid considered that, to the extent to which the retirement pension is granted to Mrs Van der Bunt-Craig as a result of the insurance and social security contributions of her husband, that benefit is a survivor's benefit within the meaning of Article 1 of the aforementioned Royal Decree which provides:(1) In the event of a widow's pension due under the Widows and Orphans Law overlapping over the same period with one or more survivor's benefits due under the social legislation of one or more other States the widow's pension shall be reduced by such an amount as is commensurate with the proportion which the length of completed periods of insurance or work of the person whose death is the basis for entitlement to widow's pension under the legislation of the other State or States bears to the length of the period between the date on which the deceased reached 15 years of age and the date on which he died....(3) If the aggregate of the reduced widow's pension and the survivor's benefits payable under the legislation of one or more States is less than the amount of the widow's pension before it was reduced pursuant to paragraph (1) hereof a supplement shall be awarded equivalent to the difference between the aggregate and the last-mentioned amount.”In application of those provisions, the Raad van Arbeid, by its decision of 29 December 1975, reduced the Netherlands widow's pension, which had been granted at the full legal rate from 1 September 1974, by 52.09% with effect from 23 September 1974 at which date the retirement pension had been increased in the United Kingdom because of the death of Mr Van der Bunt. A supplementary payment was, moreover, granted to Mrs Van der Bunt-Craig pursuant to Article 1 (3) mentioned above.As far as the rate of exchange applied to the conversion of the retirement pension into Netherlands currency is concerned, the Raad van Arbeid applied the rate referred to at the end of Article 3 of the Royal Decree of 20 March 1968 which provides as follows:(1) The conversion into Netherlands currency of the survivor's benefit due under the social legislation of another State, which is necessary for the application of Article 1, shall, in the case of benefits of a State which is a member of the International Monetary Fund, be effected at the rate accepted by that Fund as applicable on the date on which the amount to be paid is determined. If the rate accepted by the International Monetary Fund (that is to say, the parity rate) does not enable a satisfactory conversion to be effected or if there is no such rate, the rate quoted on the Amsterdam stock exchange, or, if there is no such rate, a rate to be given by the Nederlandse Bank, shall be used as the conversion rate.”The last two rates mentioned in that provision correspond to the conversion rates determined by Regulation (EEC) No 574/72 of the Council of 21 March 1972.On 22 January 1976 Mrs Van der Bunt-Craig brought proceedings against that decision before the Raad van Beroep [Social Security Court], The Hague.In her claim she asked the Raad van Beroep to change the disputed decision in the following manner:1. The retirement pension cannot be assimilated to the widow's pension under the Widows and Orphans Law.The applicant states that in the United Kingdom there is no pension specifically for widows, all retirement benefits being referred to as “retirement pensions”. Under the provisions of the United Kingdom legislation, a married woman's only right to a retirement pension derives from the contributions made by her husband. The amount of that pension is increased after the husband's death.Thus, in Mrs Van der Bunt-Craig's opinion, the retirement pension may be distinguished from the widow's pension under the Widows and Orphans Law inasmuch as the legal character of the latter is determined exclusively with reference to the status by virtue of which it is awarded.2. The plaintiff should receive the legal amount of the widow's pension as determined by the Netherlands rules.The plaintiff states that the amount of the United Kingdom pension is significantly lower than that of the reduction applied to the Netherlands pension, to such an extent that she receives a pension of a sum lower than the statutory minimum.3. The plaintiff observes that for the purposes of the conversion of the retirement pension into Netherlands currency, the Raad van Arbeid used the conversion rate laid down by Community regulations. That rate is notional inasmuch as it takes no account of the real value of the pound but of its value in relation to the European unit of account. According to the plaintiff, the Raad van Arbeid also decided not to take into account differences in the exchange rates occurring after 23 September 1974.By a judgment dated 26 April 1977 the Raad van Beroep quashed the contested decision of the Raad van Arbeid in so far as it held that the full amount of the retirement pension was paid to the plaintiff by reason of her status as a survivor within the meaning of Article 1 (1) of the Royal Decree of 20 March 1968.According to the Raad van Beroep it is possible that the question whether the total amount of the retirement pension or only the amount of the increase in that benefit should be deducted from the Netherlands widow's pension is irrelevant when the amount due is awarded. However, in the view of the Raad van Beroep, that is not the case if the amount of the retirement pension converted into Netherlands currency is later reduced as a result of a fall in the value of the pound sterling, the amount of the supplementary payment granted in the Netherlands none the less remaining the same.The Raad van Beroep makes it clear that the Raad van Arbeid was correct in applying the conversion rate on 23 September 1974, which implies that later variations in the rate can have no effect on the amount of the compensating benefit even if, in view of the fall in the value of the pound, that is to the plaintiff's detriment. The Raad van Beroep states that that result arises not from a decision of the Raad van Arbeid which is capable of being quashed, but from the application of mandatory provisions.The Raad van Arbeid brought an appeal against that judgment before the Centrale Raad van Beroep.For the purposes of the investigation of the case, the Centrale Raad van Beroep in January 1980 decided to put the following three questions to the Department of Health and Social Security in London:— Under which Act of Parliament or order was Mrs Van der Bunt's retirement pension awarded as from 4 February 1974 and as from 23 September 1974?— Is the amount of the retirement pension awarded to Mrs Van der Bunt as from 23 September 1974 dependent on the number of contributions paid by her deceased husband?— Does the retirement pension awarded to Mrs Van der Bunt as from 23 September 1974 constitute a “benefit to survivors”?By a letter dated 20 May 1980 the Department of Health and Social Security stated that:— Both the retirement pension paid to Mrs Van der Bunt from 4 February 1974 and the widow's pension paid to her from the death of her husband on 17 September 1974 were paid under the National Insurance Act 1965 as amended by Regulation 7 (1) of the National Insurance (Widow's Benefit and Retirement Pensions) Regulations 1972;— All the United Kingdom benefit paid to Mrs Van der Bunt from 4 February 1974 is regarded as retirement pension to which she is entitled in her own right, despite the fact that it is based entirely on her late husband's contributions. Thus the benefits payable to Mrs Van der Bunt should not be regarded as survivor's pensions.Having considered the United Kingdom authorities' reply and the judgment of 14 May 1981 (Case 98/80, Romano v Institut National d'Assurance Maladie-Invalidité, [1981] ECR 1241), the Centrale Raad van Beroep, by order of 11 August 1981, decided to refer the following questions to the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling:1. If a pension which is received solely by virtue of national legislation also overlaps with a benefit of a different kind of another Member State should the application of a national provision against overlapping benefits be restricted in such a way that where the application of the national legislation is less favourable than that of the rules contained in Article 46 of Regulation No 1408/71 that article must be applied?2. Must Article 107 of Regulation No 574/72 be construed to mean that the method for converting currencies laid down by that article also applies to the conversion pursuant to a national provision of overlapping benefits which is saved by Article 12 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 of benefits of another Member State?3. Do the objectives underlying Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty establishing the European Economic Community require that current benefits (calculated solely on the basis of national law or under the rules contained in Article 46 of Regulation No 1408/71) whose amount is dependent at the time they are awarded inter alia on the amount of one or more benefits due under the legislation of one or more Member States should be calculated periodically in accordance or by analogy with the provisions contained in Article 107 of Regulation No 574/72 in view of changes in the exchange rates?If so, when those periodical recalculations are made, should(a) account be taken of the amount of the foreign benefit or benefits applicable on the date of the recalculation notwithstanding the provisions contained in Article 51 of Regulation No 1408/71;(b) a comparison be made on each occasion between the amount of benefit due under national law and the amount calculated in accordance with the rules contained in Article 46 of Regulation No 1408/71?”It appears from the Supplementary Order submitted to the Court that the Centrale Raad van Beroep is of the view that the retirement pension and the Netherlands widow's pension are payments of the same kind inasmuch as they are both exclusively based on the insurance and contributions paid by the deceased husband. According to the Centrale Raad van Beroep it follows from section 32 of the National Insurance Act 1965 and in particular from the subsidiary conditions in subsection (3) (a) thereof, that the husband's death altered the conditions for the grant of the retirement pension. The fact that it was increased from £6 to £10 after the husband's death is sufficient to demonstrate that the pension changed its nature, or at least its legal basis.The Centrale Raad van Beroep specifies that the first question submitted for a preliminary ruling is put in case it is necessary to regard the benefits in question as being of a different nature.Moreover the Centrale Raad van Beroep has considered which conversion rate should be applied in the calculation of the supplementary benefit envisaged by Article 1 (3) of the Royal Decree of 20 March 1968.The Centrale Raad van Beroep is of the opinion that the conversion rate provided at the end of Article 3 (1) of the aforementioned Royal Decree, namely “the rate quoted on the Amsterdam stock exchange, or, if there is no such rate, a rate to be given by the Nederlandse Bank, shall be used as the conversion rate”, corresponds to the conversion rate provided for by Article 107 of Regulation (EEC) No 574/72 of the Council of 21 March 1972, at least in the version of that regulation applicable until 1 January 1975.The same does not apply to the rate fixed, pursuant to Regulation (EEC) No 2639/74 of the Council (Official Journal L 283, p. 1), by the new Article 107 which entered into force on 1 January 1975.Regard being had to the precedence of Community law over the provisions of national law, the Centrale Raad van Beroep is of the view that, in the application of the national provisions for the prevention of overlapping benefits, it should no longer act on the basis of Article 3 (1) of the aforementioned Royal Decree but on the conversion rate determined by the new Article 107 of Regulation No 574/72.Furthermore, the Centrale Raad van Beroep emphasizes that fluctuations in the conversion rate may affect the amount of the benefits granted to migrant workers and may create an obstacle to the free movement of workers. It observes that in Decision 99 of 13 March 1975 (Official Journal C 150, p. 2) the Administrative Commission of the European Communities on Social Security for Migrant Workers specified that Article 107 (1) of Regulation No 574/72 involves no obligation to recalculate current benefits periodically to take into account variations in conversion rates; however, the Centrale Raad van Beroep believes that that decision is not binding.Finally the Centrale Raad van Beroep discusses whether, in the course of any periodical recalculations to be carried out as a result of variations in the conversion rate, it must, on the one hand, take into consideration variations in the amount of overseas payments which have arisen, in particular, as a result of changes in the cost of living and, on the other hand, while making those new calculations, once again compare the amount payable under national legislation and the amount payable under the provisions of Article 46 of Regulation No 1408/71.The reference for a preliminary ruling was lodged at the Court Registry on 27 August 1981.Pursuant to Article 20 of the Protocol on the Statute of the Court of Justice of the EEC written observations were submitted by the Raad van Arbeid, represented by its President, L. C. van Dalen, by the Government of the Netherlands, represented by F. Italianer, Secretary General at the Ministry for Foreign Affairs, acting as Agent, and by the Commission of the European Communities, represented by J. Amphoux, Legal Adviser, assisted by G. Vandersanden of the Brussels Bar, acting as Agents.Upon hearing the report of the Judge-Rapporteur and the views of the Advocate General, the1 Court (Second Chamber) decided to carry out a preparatory inquiry pursuant to Article 21 of the Statute of the Court and Article 45 of the Rules of Procedure.In a letter of 11 June 1982 the Registrar of the Court asked the Raad van Arbeid to provide a detailed, written account by 17 August 1982 of the origin and development of the dispute covering both the facts and the legal issues arising.The Raad van Arbeid's reply was lodged at the Court Registry on 17 August 1982.The replies of the Raad van Arbeid to the question put by the Court have been included in the statement of the facts and written procedure set out above.By order of the President of the Court of 7 October 1982 the case was assigned to the Third Chamber.The date of commencement of the oral procedure was fixed after the completion of the preparatory inquiry pursuant to Article 54 of the Rules of Procedure.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.