law://eu/cjeu/1983/c-104-83/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-18In Mr Cinciuolo's view the Institut National is wrong in claiming that Article 51 covers only invalidity, old-age, and survivor's pensions and does not extend to benefits of any other kind. On the contrary, account must be taken of the connection between Articles 51, 46 and 12 of Regulation. No 1408/71 to determine whether or not the stabilization rule in Article 51 is applicable.When Article 51 contemplates the possibility of recalculation of the benefits it refers to Article 46. That in turn is directly connected with Article 12 which lays down the rules against overlapping of benefits. It is as a result of the combined application of those two articles with Article 7 (1) (c) of Regulation No 574/72 of the Council of 21 March 1972 laying down the procedure for implementing the aforesaid Regulation No 1408/71 (Official Journal, English Special Edition 1972 (I), p. 159) that the invalidity benefit due solely under the Belgian legislation was reduced when it was. Accordingly, changes in the Italian benefits ought not now to affect the Belgian benefits. Mr Cinciuolo refers on that issue to the judgment of the Court of 2 February 1982 in Case 7/81 Sinatra, [1982] ECR 137).On the other hand, account must be taken for the purpose of recalculating the benefits of, for example, any worsening of the party's incapacity and any increase in the degree of invalidity. Article 51 (2) and the procedure referred to in Article 49 of Regulation No 574/72 apply in such a case.In view of the foregoing Mr Cinciuolo considers that the answer to be given to the question referred to the Court for a preliminary ruling might be as follows:“Article 51 (1) of Regulation No 1408/71 applies equally to benefits other than pensions, such as benefits for accidents at work and occupational disease, if the amount of the pension was affected at the outset by such other benefits and if subsequent alterationsthereof are attributable to occurrences not personal to the insured.”According to the Institut National, since Article 51 of Regulation No 1408/71 refers only to Article 46 which relates to benefits of the same kind and contains no reference to Article 12 and since, moreover, Article 12 (2) enables the national provision against overlapping to be applied when the insured receives benefits of the same kind paid in accordance with Articles 46 and 51 and one or more benefits of a different kind (or other income), it is easy to perceive that the machinery established by Article 51 applies, strictly speaking, solely to benefits of the same kind.In the opinion of the Institut National the aforegoing analysis, which is rather of a formal nature, may be confirmed by citing reasons appertaining more to the merits than to the form.It must not be forgotten that Article 12 refers to benefits or income presumed to be quite different from the benefits of the same kind to which Article 46 (and Chapter 2 to Title III) relates. It is not only a question of benefits of a different kind (Article 12 (2)) but also income or salary arising from a professional or trade activity, which is referred to in Article 12 (3) (see also Article 7 (1) (b) and (c) of Regulation No 574/72 which relates to the application of Article 12 (2) and (3)).The Institut National considers that the profoundly different nature of income received from pursuit of a professional or trade activity (in comparison with benefits of the same kind within the ambit of Chapter 2 of Title III) makes it incompatible with the application, for the purposes of an adjustment, of a procedure such as that provided for in Article 51. In the case of an invalid for example, income from a professional or trade activity resumed part-time is a very variable factor as regards both increase and reduction.In view of the application of the rules on overlapping to benefits of the same kind and to other benefits or income the Institut National does not accept Mr Cinciuolo's proposition that the original situation in relation to the benefit should remain unaltered, for that would prevent reconsideration of the insured's position some time after, for example in the event of an invalid's having to reduce the amount of work which he had been able to do.Whereas it may be presumed that adjustment made in the case of benefits of the same kind as a result of a reassessment due to an increase in the cost of living would give an equivalent result, on the whole, it appears obvious that such a procedure cannot be used when the calculation of the benefit involves factors or matters which cannot be compared or assimilated to a benefit of the same kind, such as income from a trade or professional activity resumed part-time or benefits of a different kind such as, for example, those awarded for an accident at work or for occupational disease which are of a special nature (since subsequent developments may necessitate a revision of the percentage fixed) and scarcely compatible with the adjustment procedure provided for in Article 51.The Institut National is therefore of the opinion that Article 51 refers solely to benefits of the same kind awarded in the States in question pursuant to Article 46 and does not apply to the aforesaid benefits when they are reduced because the beneficiary also receives a benefit of a different kind or other income or salary. Any reassessment of such benefits or income may thus involve a recalculation and, if necessary, a further reduction.The Institut National concludes that the question referred to the Court for a preliminary ruling should be answered as follows :“Subsequent adjustments of a benefit of a different kind, such as benefits relating to accidents at work or occupational disease, which originally affected the amount of the invalidity, old-age or survivors' pension awarded pursuant to Article 46 of Regulation No 1408/71 are not covered by the provisions of Article 51 (1) and (2) of Regulation No 1408/71.”The Commission refers first to the aforesaid judgment in the Sinatra case in which the Court emphasized that the main objective of Article 51 was to simplify administration.It observes that Article 46 of Regulation No 1408/71 involves a comparison between the “independent” benefits based solely on national law and “Community” benefits, namely those obtained as a result of aggregating periods as provided for in Article 45 thereof.It is for the purpose of avoiding having to make a new comparison to determine the most advantageous scheme at each alteration of one or more of the benefits granted that Article 51 restricts the need for a recalculation to the cases mentioned in its paragraph (2), namely an alteration in the method of determining the benefits or in the rules for calculating them.The problem to be resolved is whether Article 46 must be interpreted strictu sensu, or given a wider interpretation so as to include benefits of a different kind which by reason of the national provisions against overlapping are also involved in the operation of the procedure provided for by Article 46.In the Commission's view, the present case is indeed concerned with benefits of a different kind. It appears from the case-law of the Court that when, as in the present case, a worker enjoys an “independent” benefit in a Member State he is entitled to the highest benefit out of, on the one hand, that which he may claim under the legislation of that Member State in its entirety, including any provision against overlapping which it may contain, and on the other hand the benefit which he may claim pursuant to the provisions of Regulation No 1408/71 in its entirety. The part of the calculation relating to the “Community” benefit is based on Article 46 as a whole, including paragraph (3) thereof (see the judgments of the Court of 16 May 1979 in Case 236/78 Fonds National de Retraite v Mura [1979] ECR 1819 and 5 May 1983 in Case 238/81 Van der Bunt [1983] ECR 1385).It follows that in calculating the Community pension pursuant to Article 7 (1) (c) of Regulation No 574/72 account is to be taken of the national provisions against overlapping. Thus the original calculation is to be made, according to Article 46, taking into account the benefits of a different kind covered by the national provisions against overlapping.In the Commission's view it follows that in view of the ratio legis of Article 51 as interpreted by the Court in the aforesaid Sinatra case the article must, as a provision implementing Article 46, be taken to refer to all benefits included in the original calculations, including benefits of a different kind taken into account in the national provisions against overlapping.In consequence the Commission proposes that the question referred to the Court for a preliminary ruling should be answered as follows:“Article 51 (1) of Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71 applies to all benefits of the States concerned which are taken into account for the purposes of the calculations and comparisons to be made under Article 46, including paragraph (3) thereof and its implementing provisions.”
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.