law://eu/cjeu/1981/c-117-81/hd_1_1_3_2@2026-11-16In the applicant's view, there has been an infringement of the provisions of Article 25 of the Staff Regulations to the effect that: “Any decision adversely affecting an official shall state the grounds on which it is based”, since the letter of 14 July 1980 is confined to mentioning the contested decision without stating the grounds on which it is based.To the extent to which his application was considered unacceptable on grounds connected with the actual wording of the vacancy notice the applicant considers that he was entitled to know the basis of the conditions required for filling Post No 120 in so far as that basis seems to follow from the Commission decision dated 23 July 1975 on the purpose and detailed rules for the application of the system of rotation in delegations and offices in nonmember countries. The applicant emphasizes that the decision was annexed to the Commission's defence and was in no way referred to in the contested letter. That observation confirms the failure of the decision notified to the applicant on 14 July 1980 to state the grounds on which is was based.A statement of the general reasons for a decision to reject an application on the one hand allows the unsuccessful applicant to act with knowledge of the facts and on the other prevents the administration from persisting in a course likely to affect the successful applicant adversely.In the applicant's opinion the failure to state reasons cannot be justified by the defendant's concern not to prejudice the applicant in so far as the rejection of the latter's application for Post No 120 is not the result of a consideration of the comparative merits of all the competitors.The Commission emphasizes that the submission of a formal defect relied on by Mr Morello in the aforesaid Case 9/76 and rejected by the Court related precisely to a failure to state the grounds on which a decision to refuse admission to an internal competition was based.In the Commission's opinion sufficient reasons were given in the contested letter since the applicant could not be unaware that Post No 120, as shown in the vacancy notice, was reserved to officials paid from operational appropriations. When he was informed that his application was rejected, the applicant thus necessarily knew the reasons.However, assuming that Post No 120 was open to all officials of the scientific and technical staff — both to those paid from operational appropriations and to those paid from research appropriations — then, in the Commission's opinion, it would still be necessary to take account of the principles recognized by the Court in the case of a new assignment requested by an official.It follows inter alia from the judgments in Joined Cases 33 and 75/79 Kuhner v Commission [1980] ECR 1677, Case 188/73 Grassi v Council [1974] ECR 1099 and in particular Case 101/77 Ganzini v Commission [1978] ECR 915 that the appointing authority is not required to state the reasons for which it considered another candidate more suitable for the proposed duties than the official not selected “since the recitals of such a statement of reasons might be prejudicial to the candidate”.In citing that case-law the defendant's purpose is to show that, even if the applicant had not been disqualified from applying and if the comparative merits of all the applicants had been considered it would have been required to state reasons for its decision.Alternatively, in case the rejection of his candidature is based on the fact he is an official of the scientific and technical staff paid from appropriations in the research and investment budget, the applicant makes the following submissions:
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.