law://eu/cjeu/1978/c-33-78/hd_1_1_2_2_1@2026-11-18The question as to which law should govern interpretation of the concepts used in the Convention has been dealt with in various judgments of the Court of Justice. After declaring in paragraph 11 of the judgment of 6 October 1976 in Case 12/76 Tessili [1976] ECR 1473 that “neither of these two options (namely an independent interpretation or reference to the substantive rules of the law applicable under the rules of conflict of laws of the court before which the matter is first brought) rules out the other since the appropriate choice can only be made in respect of each of the provisions of the Convention” the Court took the view in its judgments of 14 October 1976 in Case 29/76 LTU v Eurocontrol [1976] ECR 1541 and 14 July 1977 in Joined Cases 9 and 10/77 Bavaria v Eurocontrol [1977] ECR 1517 at p. 1525, paragraph 4, that “the principle of legal certainty in the Community legal system and the objectives of the Brussels Convention … require in all Member States a uniform application of the legal concepts and legal classifications developed by the Court in the context of the Brussels Convention”. Finally the judgment of 12 November 1977 in Case 43/77 Industrial Diamond Supplies [1977] ECR 2175 gave a uniform and independent interpretation of the concept “ordinary appeal” within the meaning of Articles 30 and 38 of the Convention.In view of the guiding lines of this case-law the Commission takes the view that the interpretation of the concept of “branch, agency or other establishment” must be uniform and based on the Convention. The Court of Justice rightly began in the judgment of 6 October 1976 in Case 14/76 De Bloos [1976] ECR 1497 to interpret the concepts in question in this way.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.