law://eu/cjeu/1978/c-253-78/hd_1_1_2_5@2026-11-17According to the Government of the United Kingdom, the question asked by the court making the reference is twofold: it asks on the one hand whether certain luxury products whose brand image is important can benefit from the exemption provisions contained in Article 85 (3) of the EEC Treaty and on the other whether in the present case the companies in question benefit therefrom in Community law. The Government of the United kingdom intends to confine its observations to the second part of the question.That second part in turn implies the three following questions:(a) Has an individual exemption been granted under Article 85 (3) of the Treaty and Article 9 (1) of Regulation No 17?(b) If not, is there an applicable block exemption?(c) If there is neither an individual exemption nor a block exemption, does the agreement in question satisfy the requirements of Article 85 (3) so as to be capable of receiving an individual exemption?So far as the three questions set out above are questions of fact, the Government of the United Kingdom observes that the jurisdiction of the Court under Article 177 is to give rulings on questions of interpretation of Community law and not to determine issues of fact or to apply Community law to the facts.So far as the above questions relate to whether Article 85 (3) is applicable, the Government of the United Kingdom observes moreover that under Article 9 (1) of Regulation No 17 the Commission has sole power to grant exemptions, the role of the Court being to review the exercise of that power and that, in relation to block exemptions, it is for the Commission or for national courts to decide whether there is an applicable block exemption.Having said that, the Government of the United Kingdom would nevertheless make the following observations. In all four cases, the defendants allege that the Commission has authorized the agreements in question under Article 85 (3). This is clearly stated in the judgment making the reference in Case 1/79, where page six of the judgment of the Tribunal de Grande Instance, Paris, says:“The lawyers claim that the company's selective distribution system was authorized by a decision of the Commission of the European Communities of 26 March 1976 ... Consequently, by the abovementioned decision the Commission of the European Communities approved, on the basis of Article 85 (3), the selective distribution system practised by Parfums Rochas S.A. as regards the rules of competition in the European Communities.”The United Kingdom expresses very grave doubts in this respect. An individual decision of exemption may only be granted by way of decision (Article 6 (1) of Regulation No 17/62) and the decision must itself be published in the Official Journal (Article 21 (1) of the regulation). The Government of the United Kingdom points out that no decision of the Commission relating to these four cases and in particular of 26 March 1976 relating to the Rochas company has been published in the Official Journal. It is not clear whether there is any applicable block exemption in this field but whether there is or not does not fall to be decided by the Court.According to the United Kingdom, it seems that in these four cases the Commission, as it had already done in Case 59/77, Etablissements A. de Bloos S.p.r.l. v Bouyer S.C.A., [1977] ECR 2359, simply decided to take no action. This is confirmed by the Commission's statements in paragraphs 57 to 59 of the Fifth Report on Competition Policy. The agreements in question have merely been dealt with by a decision to “close the file” in the case.Referring to the opinion of Mr Advocate General Mayras in the de Bloos case quoted above, the United Kingdom claims that a decision to “close the file” is not an exemption under Article 85 (3). As no decision of exemption under Article 85 (3) has been taken by the Commission in respect of the agreements in question and in view of the exclusive competence given to the Commission by Article 9 (1) of Regulation No 17, the Government of the United Kingdom concludes that the Court should refrain from answering the questions in the four cases before the Court directed as to whether a particular agreement benefits from that provision.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.