law://eu/cjeu/1978/c-179-78/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-20Rivoira submits that Question 1 finds an answer in the principles laid down by the judgment in Case 52/77 Cayrol v Rivoira [1977] ECR 2261. It emerges from that judgment (paragraphs 24 to 26 of the decision) that the basic condition for the application of Article 115 of the Treaty was fulfilled at the time, and that the French Republic neither applied for nor obtained the authorization referred to in the second sentence of the first paragraph of Article 115. That authorization would only have enabled it to exclude Spanish grapes from Community treatment and to check the origin of that product in trade within the Community.It emphasizes that goods in free circulation enjoy Community treatment in any Member State. In the present case, the various consignments of grapes were travelling under cover of Certificates DD1 or T2. According to Rivoira, those certificates bear witness to the lawful admission of the goods into free circulation within the meaning of Article 9 (2) of the Treaty (judgment of 15 September 1976 in Case 41/76 Donckerwolcke [1976] 2 ECR 1921).As to Question 2, Rivoira argues that there is a difference between customs rules and any other measure of customs supervision. The latter are of a purely administrative nature and cannot include penalties such as seizure of the goods or any pecuniary penalty fixed according to the value of the goods (paragraphs 37 and 38 of the decision in Case 52/77 cited above). Among such administrative contraventions are those concerning the declaration of Community origin. It follows from Case 52/77 (Cayrol v Rivoira cited above) that an inaccurate statement of origin cannot be regarded as an infringement of a rule of customs law.Consequently, such a statement also cannot be punished under the penal rules laid down for cases of infringement of customs law.It also emerges from the case-law of the Court that there is discrimination inasmuch as in the present case the inaccurate statement of origin — as a quality control — does not attract penalties in respect of all products marketed within the State concerned but under the strict provisions of the Code des Douanes attracts penalties only in respect of imponed products (Case 53/76 Bouhelier [1977] ECR 197).According to the provisions of Regulations Nos 58/62 (Official Journal, English Special Edition 1959-1962, p. 204) and 158/66 (Journal Officiel No 192, 27 October 1966, p. 3282/66), statements relating to the origin of the goods were required in order to protect the interests of consumers; they are not a customs matter (paragraph 48 to 50 of the decision in Case 52/77 cited above).The French Government confirms first of all that it is true that for 1970 and 1971 France had not availed itself of the opportunity afforded by Article 115 of the Treaty to take necessary protective measures with the agreement of the Commission.It considers that it was entitled to ask importers for the origin of table grapes imported into France under the conditions laid down by the case-law of the Court (Case 41/76 Donckerwolcke and Case 52/72 Cayrol v Rivoira cited above). Statement of the origin of products was intended precisely to enable the French authorities to keep a watch on impon trends in order to be able to avail itself of the procedure provided for in Article 115 of the Treaty should the need arise.Consequently, an inaccurate statement of such origin made with a clearly fraudulent purpose may be subject to a penalty. The Court did not deny that such penalties were possible so long as they were not disproportionate having regard to the purely administrative nature of the contravention.However, the present case in fact concerns a fraudulent manoeuvre and not a mistake made in good faith.The French Government submits that if such a manoeuvre is proved, it should be subject to criminal penalties irrespective of the imposition of an administrative penalty applying to a mere mistake in the statement of origin.The Commission submits that Question 1 should be given a negative answer, as is already apparent from the judgment in Case 52/77 cited above.This conclusion is confirmed by the express terms of Article 1 (1) of Regulation No 2513/69 of the Council of 9 December 1969 on the co-ordination and standardization of the treatment accorded by each Member State to imports of fruit and vegetables from non-member countries (Journal Officiel No L 318, p. 6), from which it emerges that the power left to the Member States by that provision to apply certain quantitative restrictions is limited to imports of the products concerned from non-member countries.The scope of the principle of free movement of goods in relation to products coming from non-member countries which are in free circulation in a Member State was clearly defined by the judgment of 15 December 1976 in Case 41/76 Donckerwolcke [1976] 2 ECR 1921 and by the judgment of 30 November 1977 in Case 52/77 Cayrol v Rivoira [1977] ECR 2261.Finally, in 1970 and 1971 a Member State could not prohibit the introduction into its territory of table grapes of Spanish origin coming from another Member State where they were in free circulation, without having been duly authorized to do so by the Commission under Article 115 of the Treaty.The answer to Question 2 is clear from a mere reading of the words used by the national court. A criminal conviction under a national legislative provision which has been held to be contrary to Community law is also incompatible with that law (judgment of 16 February 1968 in Case 88/77 Minister for Fisheries v Schonenberg and Others [1978] ECR 473).However, having regard to the provisions of the French Code des Douanes on the basis of which the national court has to give judgment, it is possible to see the question as having a wider scope.In this connexion, the Commission puts forward the following arguments.Through extensive use of the technique of assimilation or legal fictions or presumptions, the French Code des Douanes frequently confers a particularly broad ambit upon the concepts which it employs. This is true in particular of the offence of importing or exporting prohibited goods without a declaration or of false declaration of prohibited goods. Not only does the contravention refer to a concept of prohibited goods which is itself very broad owing to Article 38 of the Code des Douanes, but in extreme cases it can also consist in the declaration of goods which are not prohibited, in particular in the case envisaged in Article 426 (3) of the Code des Douanes which is one of the legal bases of the judgment of the Tribunal de Grande Instance of 26 January 1976. Unlike Article 426 (2) concerning ‘false declarations whose purpose or effect is to evade application of the prohibition measures’, Article 426 (3) relates to false declarations irrespective of their purpose or of their effect or of the measures concerning the goods which form their subject-matter.The false declarations to which it refers are punished as such.note Article 426 (3) makes into a criminal offence the contravention which such a false declaration constitutes because of the aggravating factor of the contravention's having been committed ‘by means of false, inaccurate, incomplete or inapplicable invoices, certificates or any other documents’.Thus, in the Commission's submission, according to the French Code des Douanes, Article 426 (3) may be applied even where the goods concerned do not form the subject-matter of any measure prohibiting or restricting importation.In the present case, the problem is to what extent the application of that provision and the criminal convictions to which it can lead are compatible with the rules of the Treaty in the case of goods in free circulation moving between Member States.The Commission argues that the answer is to be found in the judgments in the cases of Donckerwolcke and Cayrol v Rivoira cited above. It emerges from this case-law that the provisions of the Treaty on the free movement of goods preclude the possibility of a mistaken declaration of the first origin of goods in free circulation introduced into the territory of a Member State from another Member State giving grounds for the application of a penalty of the kind which Article 414 of the French Code des Douanes lays down for false declarations deemed to be imports or exports of prohibited goods without a declaration. That penalty (the seizure of the goods and a fine equal to twice the value of the goods) cannot be justified inasmuch as it is intended to enforce a prohibition or restriction on importation which ex hypothesi is inapplicable to the goods under consideration in the absence of an authorization duly given under Article 115 of the Treaty. It is moreover patently disproportionate having regard to the needs of the State as regards knowledge of the movement of goods.On the basis of the foregoing considerations, the Commission suggests that the question referred to the Court should be answered as follows:1. Although the Member States could — having regard to the combined provisions of Article 1 of Regulation No 2513/69 and of Articles 1 and 11 of Annex I to the Agreement between the EEC and Spain — continue to apply to table grapes of Spanish origin during the part of the year between 1 July and 31 December quantitative restrictions in existence prior to Regulation No 2513/69, those provisions did not allow them to extend the application of such restrictions to imports of table grapes of Spanish origin from another State in which they were in free circulation in the absence of an authorization duly given by the Commission under Article 115 of the Treaty.2. A criminal conviction for contravention of a prohibition on imports which is contrary to Article 30 of the Treaty is itself incompatible with that Article.A mistaken declaration concerning the first origin of goods in free circulation coming from another Member State cannot give grounds for the application of a criminal penalty of the kind which Article 141 of the French Code des Douanes lays down for false declarations deemed to be imports or exports of prohibited goods without a declaration, since such a penalty is patently disproportionate having regard to what is necessary for the purposes of enabling a Member State to obtain reasonably complete and accurate information on the movement of goods falling within specific measures of commercial policy.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.