law://eu/cjeu/1977/c-7-77/hd_1_1_3_2_3@2026-11-19The applicant considers that the post in question had been reserved for a person of a specific nationality and that it was necessary to appoint Mr Capuano whose previous appointment to that post had been annulled by the Court. Following that annulment the defendant had decided to dispense with the procedure of appointment through promotion or transfer in which Mr Capuano, as a member of the temporary staff, could not take part. Finally, Mr Capuano was appointed after an internal competition to which he was the only person admitted and this is contrary to the very concept of a competition. It must be open to question whether there can still be a competition when only one candidate is admitted.The defendant observes that the applicant is unable to furnish any serious evidence in support of his statements.The specific qualifications of the successful candidate in the competition and his thorough experience in particular in the potato sector show that the outcome of the competition is perfectly logical and in any case that it cannot, in itself, constitute evidence of misuse of powers. The Selection Board exercised its full powers in complete independence, in strict compliance with the conditions laid down in the notice of competition.Finally, the defendant emphasizes that a distinction must be drawn between the proceedings for annulment directed against the decision refusing to admit the applicant to the competition and the proceedings for the annulment of the competition and of the subsequent appointment on the one hand and the inferences to be drawn on the other. Even supposing for the sake of argument that the Court were to find that the decision refusing to admit the applicant to the competition was irregular and in particular that such irregularity consisted in an inadequate statement of reasons or in an infringement of a procedural requirement the defendant does not consider that this finding must entail the annulment of the contested decisions. In this connexion it refers to the judgment of 29 September 1976 in Case 9/76 Morello v Commission [1976] ECR 1415.The applicant maintains that there has been a misuse of powers because the competition for one person is contrary to the very concept of a competition. The Staff Regulations furthermore confirm this view when they lay down in the fourth and fifth paragraphs of Article 5 of Annex III that the list of suitable candidates shall wherever possible contain at lean twice as many names as the number of posts to be filled.The applicant asks whether, at any rate if several candidates have applied, it is not legally necessary, as soon as it has been decided that only one candidate may enter, to dispense with the competition and instead to hold an open competition.The defendant states that the relevant provisions of the Staff Regulations do not contain anything prohibiting competitions with a single candidate. Further, in practice this situation is not unusual in internal competitions. Finally it should be recalled that the sole concern of the Selection Board at the stage of the examination of qualifications is to check that such qualifications meet the conditions in the notice of competition; the provision laying down that ‘wherever possible at lean twice as many names as the number of posts to be filled’ shall be put forward only applies to drawing up the list of suitable candidates after the tests.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.