law://eu/cjeu/1978/c-255-78/hd_1_1_3@2026-11-19The applicants emphasize first, that they duly followed the procedure for appeals laid down in Articles 90 and 91 of the Staff Regulations and that the application is therefore admissible.As regards the substance they maintain that the requirement of specific experience in two specialities was not set out in the notice of competition under heading II (eligibility).They state that reference was made only to the choice of two specialities under heading I of the notice of competition (nature of duties) in order to ascertain the field in which the candidates wished to be tested. In no case is the selection board for the competition entitled to depart from the conditions for admission to the point of adding new ones which are not expressly provided for.The applicants consider that headings I and II of the notice of competition have different objectives.An examination of the conditions for admission as they are laid down in heading II of the notice of competition shows that under A (which applies to the holders of a certificate of advanced secondary education) reference is made to the requirement of experience in the field chosen by the candidate (and not in two specialities).On the other hand, under B (which applies to candidates who do not possess a certificate of advanced secondary education) no specific field of knowledge is referred to.The applicants consider that the selection board was therefore forbidden to attach the requirement of nine years' experience applying under B to any field whatever and, a fortiori, to specialities. Similarly it cannot be maintained that, by analogy, points I and II of the notice had to be limited so as to add conditions for admission which were not expressly provided for.By acting in that manner the selection board infringed the first paragraph of Article 5 of Annex III to the Staff Regulations and based its decision on a ground which is legally incorrect.The applicants observe in the alternative that it emerges from their personal files and, in particular, from their periodic reports, that they each have at least nine years' practical experience in at least one of the specialities chosen by them.The Commission recalls, first of all, that when considering the question whether it is expedient to submit a complaint before an application is lodged the Court held that:‘Nevertheless this procedure is devoid of purpose where a complaint is directed against the decisions of a selection board in a competition since the appointing authority is not empowered to review such decisions.Accordingly the general plan both of the administrative procedure and of the court procedure militates against an interpretation of Article 91 (2), which, if taken literally, would merely result in a futile prolongation of the procedure.’(judgment of 16 March 1978, Ritter von Wüllerstorff und Urban v Commission, Case 7/77 [1978] ECR 769, paragraphs 7 and 8).The Commission leaves the question of the admissibility of the application to the Court.As regards the substance the Commission claims that the selection board rightly took the view . that the practical experience required had to have been acquired in the two specialities chosen by the candidates. It considers that the notice of competition must not be given an expository or even a grammatical interpretation but that, on the contrary, account must be taken of the administrative authority's aim in drawing up notices of competition, which is to do everything to ensure that the posts available are awarded to officials who possess an academic or practical training which is in keeping with them.The Commission's practice as regards notices of competition shows that under the heading ‘Qualifications and practical experience’ the conditions for admission to the competition provide that the practical experience must have been acquired in the performance of duties in the field specified under the heading ‘Nature of duties’.While no longer insisting on that link in the case of officials who possess a certificate of advanced secondary education the administrative authority maintains it as regards candidates who do not possess such a certificate.In view of the fact that the conditions for admission laid down in Notice of Competition No COM/BT/7/76 provided that candidates who possess a certificate of advanced secondary education had to have a certain minimum practical experience in the field chosen, it must a fortiori be assumed that the practical experience required of the candidates who do not possess such a certificate must necessarily also be in the field chosen. In that connexion the Commission refers to the third subparagraph of Article 5 (1) of the Staff Regulations and claims that a candidate who does not possess a certificate of advanced secondary education and who is therefore at the outset less well-qualified cannot enjoy wider conditions for admission than a candidate who does possess such a certificate.The Commission contests the argument put forward by the applicants to the effect that the selection board could not require candidates, even those holding a certificate of advanced secondary education, to give evidence of practical experience in the two specialities chosen.In accordance with the terms of Article 1 (c) of Annex III to the Staff Regulations the appointing authority must specify the nature of the duties attaching to the posts to be filled. That prerogative also involves the power to decide that a certain field covered by the competition must be subdivided into various specialities and that each candidate for a post in Category B must provide evidence of mastery of two of those specialities. The link between the practical experience required and the field chosen must therefore exist in relation to the two specialities chosen.The applicants are unable to provide evidence of any experience in the second speciality chosen, namely printing in the case of Mrs Anselme and photoengraving in the case of Mr Constant.In their reply the applicants maintain that the procedure was in no way irregular as regards Articles 90 and 91 of the Staff Regulations. It is neither forbidden nor inapposite to acknowledge that following receipt of a complaint the appointing authority has the power, where appropriate, to request the selection board for a competition to reconsider its position. Far from being unavailing such a procedure is likely to result in a settlement of the dispute and a decision to abandon the legal proceedings.The applicants stress the difference in wording which exists between the conditions for admission applicable to the candidates who possess a certificate of advanced secondary education and those applicable to the other candidates.To follow the interpretation advocated by the Commission would mean that the candidates themselves must interpret the conditions for admission, with the obvious risks of errors which may result. It cannot be conceded that a text whose very nature requires it to be clear and unambiguous in order to ensure objectivity and legal certainty should have to be interpreted by reference to the ‘administrative authority's aim’.The examples given by the defendant of the practice followed by the administrative authority rather show that any link which may be required between the practical experience of the candidates for a competition and a field specified under the heading ‘Nature of duties’ must result from the actual wording of the notice of competition.The applicants maintain that their personal files show that they each possess at least nine years' practical experience of duties of a technical nature classified by the Staff Regulations as of Category C standard, in accordance with the conditions for admission laid down in the notice of competition.Even supposing that it were appropriate to provide evidence of at least nine years' practical experience in the two specialities chosen, which the applicants contest, the notice of competition does not specify whether there must be nine years' experience in each of the specialities in question or, on the contrary, whether experience in each of the specialities is to be taken into account cumulatively. The fact that that particular, which is surely essential, is not clear from the wording of the vacancy notice as it stands shows that that was not the criterion which was to determine the admissibility of the applications for the competition.In its rejoinder the Commission observes that the judgment in Case 7/77 (Ritter von Wüllerstorff und Urbair v Commission, [1978] ECR 769) is completely in line with the case-law laid down in the Marcato cases (Case 44/71, Marcato v Commission [1972] 1 ECR 427, and Case 37/72, Marcato v Commission [1973] 1 ECR 361) and was confirmed by the judgment in the Salerno case (Joined Cases 4, 19 and 28/78 Salemo and Others v Commission [1978] ECR 2403).It claims that the wording of the notice of competition must be considered as a whole and that there can be no question of taking account of the condition relating to practical experience without having regard to the specialities chosen by the candidates.The notices relating to competitions held prior to the competition in dispute, which are produced by the Commission in an annex to the rejoinder, show that the practical experience required of the candidates who do not possess a certificate of advanced secondary education had to be in keeping with the nature of the duties to be performed.The Commission maintains that no account can be taken of the apparent disparity in the wording in the notice of competition in question. Having regard to the provision in the third subparagraph of Article 5 (1) of the Staff Regulations, the condition of practical experience in the field chosen which is required of candidates who possess a certificate of advanced secondary education must a fortiori be imposed on those candidates who do not possess such a certificate.Entirely as an alternative the Commission puts forward the view that if the Court were to think fit to annul the decision by which the Selection Board for Competition No COM/BT/ 7/76 refused to admit the applicants to the tests it would not be appropriate, having regard to the interests of the service and the legitimate interests of the successful candidates, to annul the tests relating to that competition or the appointments made in consequence thereof.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.