law://eu/cjeu/1977/c-115-77/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-19The appellants in the main action confine themselves to lodging a statement of the family allowances paid in their favour by the Belgian Fund to their stepfather.The respondent in the main action considers that Article 79 (3) of Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71 prescribes two conditions for the suspension of the right to orphans' benefits :1. Such benefits must constitute orphans' pensions or corresponding benefits (Article 78 (1)); and2. It is necessary with regard to children who are primarily recipients under the provisions of Article 78 (1) that a right to family benefits or allowances should be acquired under the legislation of a Member Sute by virtue of the pursuit of a professional or trade activity.If those conditions are fulfilled the right to the benefits due under the abovementioned provisions must be suspended in its entirety.In fact the rule in Article 79 (3) applies only to children who are entitled to benefits. This is clear from the last sentence: ‘In such a case, the persons concerned shall be considered as members of the family of a worker’, which must mean that for reasons of equality of treatment and where there are a number of different rights to benefits the children must not be considered as survivors of a worker but as members of the family of a worker and that they cannot on that particular ground claim a right to an orphans' pension but merely a right to family benefits or allowances under the legislation of a Member Sute by virtue of the pursuit of a professional or trade activity.The Italian Government maintains first of all that since no provision of national legislation prescribes the suspension of the orphans' pension in the present case the order making the reference must be interpreted to mean that the suspension which has been brought before the national court is based solely upon Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71. Furthermore, it is for the Court of Justice to establish whether the preliminary questions referred to it are concerned exclusively with the interpretation or in addition with the validity of Article 79 (3) of that regulation.The Iulian Government then emphasizes that in its view, on the basis of the wording of Article 1 of the regulation, there is a difference in kind between family allowances (of which the direct and sole recipient is the worker, not the member of the family on account of whom they are paid) and an orphans' pension (of which the direct and sole recipient is the orphan, even if he is represented for the actual receipt thereof by the natural or legal person actually maintaining him). The fact that this difference which, in addition, is also recognized by Article 44 (3) of the regulation, which excludes orphans' pensions from the scope of Chapter 3, ‘Old age and death (pensions)’, of Tide LU, is not fully taken into consideration in Article 78 (1) (or, in consequence, in Article 79) may appear as an internal contradiction within the regulation. In fan ‘the pursuit of a professional or trade activity’ (Article 79 (3) and Article 12 (3)) constitutes the individual act of a specific person, the exercise of a personal choice; whilst it is possible to justify such act's producing legal effects with regard to invalidity benefits or the anticipated old-age benefits payable to the very person responsible for that act, it is impossible to justify that act's producing legal effects with regard to a third parry and adversely affecting his interests. In the present case the two orphans have suffered the suspension of their rights to the orphans' pension as the result of the second marriage of their mother and by virtue of the pursuit of a professional or trade activity by their stepfather.On the basis of the foregoing considerations the Iulian Government proceeds to consider in particular the proper interpretation of the provisions of Article 78 (1) and Article 79 (3) of Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71.Article 48 (2) of the Treaty prohibits ‘any discrimination’ between workers of the Member States and also between those entitled under them to insurance benefits deriving from an occupation. There is no suspension of a person's entidement to an orphans' pension while he remains within the Member Sute required under national legislation to pay that pension. On the other hand, such suspension may come into operation if Article 79 (3) becomes applicable.Acceptance of the interpretation which the respondent in the main action places upon that provision would result in an unjustified difference in treatment between an orphan who remained within a Member Sute and one who, moving within the Community, transferred his residence to another Member Sute.Furthermore, Article 51 of the Treaty established the principle of the ‘retention’ of the right to insurance benefits and of the payment of such benefits when workers and ‘their dependants’ move from one Member Sute to another within the Community. The Iulian Government maintains that there would be a violation of the principle that the place of residence of the recipient of insurance benefits is of no importance, if the ‘suspension’ referred to in Article 79 (3) of the regulation were to produce the effect urged by the respondent in the main action.Furthermore, the interpretation which the respondent in the main action places upon the legislation in question is incompatible with the objective of avoiding privileged situations consisting in the overlapping of an orphans' pension with family allowances amounting to more than was provided for under the legislation of the Member Sute applicable to the deceased worker. In order to attain this objective it is sufficient to establish that the amount of the benefits which an orphan obtains pursuant to the legislation of the Member Sute to which the deceased worker was subject constitutes a ceiling which may not be exceeded when the orphan moves to the territory of another Member Sute; in this way the orphan who moves within the Community is not adversely affected by the application of a provision of Community legislation.Alternatively, the orphan moving from one Member Sute to another could be permitted to exercise an option, through a declaration made by his legal representative, for ‘mixed’ treatment consisting of a number of benefits provided by institution of different States which together are not less than the benefits to which he is entitled under the legislation of the Sute to which the deceased worker was subject.The Iulian Government relies upon the decisions of the Court of Justice in Case 24/75, Petrani ([1975] ECR 1149) and in Case 112/76, Manzoni ([1977] ECR 1647) and recalls the Court's dictum that the aim of Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty would not be attained if, as a consequence of the exercise of their right to freedom of movement, workers were to lose advantages guaranteed to them by the laws of a single Member Sute. This principle must also apply in favour of the ‘dependants’ of a deceased worker and result in a declaration that Article 79 (3) is in part unlawful.The Iulian Government states, however, that it seems possible on a correct interpretation of Article 79 (3) to attain the desired aim of avoiding both placing orphans in a privileged situation and treating them unfavourably in relation to the treatment guaranteed them under the legislation of an individual Member Sute. In fact the sentence ‘… the persons concerned shall be considered as members of the family of a worker’ shows clearly that the legislature was thinking principally of family allowances and intended to set up a scheme for such allowances. The link with benefits which are not ‘of the same kind’ as family allowances is not contained in Article 79 (3) but follows as a result of the reference to ‘paragraph 2 and under Articles 77 and 78’.It thus appears possible to maintain that mat assimilation involves suspension only where benefits ‘of the same kind’ are concerned, and more particularly that Article 79 (3) prohibits the overlapping of family allowances in favour of the same orphan under the legislation of a number of Member States.Furthermore, regard must be had to the fact that ‘the right … to family benefits or family allowances’ under the legislation of the Member Sute in which the professional or trade activity referred to in Article 79 (3) was pursued does not appear to constitute a ‘right’ which cannot be renounced. Consequently, it cannot be' ruled out that the orphan (or his legal representative) may renounce that part of the ‘right’ which exceeds the amount of the benefits previously received and thus exercise an option in favour of the treatment most beneficial to him.The Iulian Government suggests that the following reply should be given to the questions submitted:— Article 79 (3) of Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71 must be interpreted to mean that it precludes the overlapping of several family allowances theoretically due under the legislation of several Member States ‘with respect to’ the same ‘child’ but not the overlapping of an orphans' pension granted by one Member Sute with family allowances granted by another Member Sute to the individual on whom the child is held to be dependent.— Alternatively, Article 79 (3) of Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71 must be interpreted to mean that it entitles the child to opt for the retention of benefits which are payable to him under Articles 77 and 78 of that regulation in so far as is necessary to ensure that he receives treatment as favourable as that which he previously enjoyed.The Commission observes first that, unlike the general system laid down by Article 12 (2) and (3) of Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71, Article 79 (3) establishes a specific prohibition on overlapping within the framework of Community law.The Commission next considers the view inherent in the questions submitted by the court making the reference, that the right of the appellants in the main action to an orphans' pension is governed by the statement of the persons covered by Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71, and maintains that the facts on which the dispute in the main action turns do not provide any grounds for the conclusion that the deceased father, the mother or the stepfather of the appellants are or were workers moving within the Community. In those circumstances the appellants' rights to a German orphans' pension and to Belgian family allowances can be coordinated in accordance with the provisions of Article 79 (3) only if the persons thereby covered include, apart from workers moving within the Community, workers who are not moving within the Community.Although Article 78 (2) and Article 2 (1) (the general provision concerning the persons covered by the regulation) do indeed expressly include workers who were or are covered by the legislation of a single Member Sute, that merely amounts to taking account of the fact that all movements do not necessarily bring about the application of the laws of several countries. For example, a worker may possibly move before commencing his first employment. It follows that the provisions of Article 79 (3) of the regulation relate only to orphans' benefits directly or indirectly affected by the movement of a parent and not to benefits intended for orphans who, on other independent grounds, are entided under the legislation of several Member States. In the present case the suspension of the German orphans' pension can only be decided under the provisions of the Reichsversicherungsordnung and not under Community law.Only if the overlapping of the German orphans' pension with the Belgian family allowances were due to the fact that the appellants' father or stepfather moved between the said Member Sutes, which, the Commission maintains, was not the case with the events involved in the main action, would the Commission raise the questions put by the court making the reference, beginning with the final question, since if that question is answered in the affirmative the two former questions become devoid of purpose.The Commission first remarks that the orphans' pension and the family allowances constitute quite disimilar benefits and then states that Anide 79 (3) relates moreover to family benefits for orphans, who are considered both in their general status as children and in their specific status as orphans. Furthermore, Article 79 governs as a whole the overlapping of benefits within the meaning of Article 78 with benefits payable in the Sute of residence by virtue of the pursuit of a professional or trade activity. The overlapping of those two categories of benefits appears to entail the suspension of the rights acquired in the competent Member Sute in accordance with Anide 78.It should be noted in order to clarify the provisions of Article 79 (3) that those provisions concern only one of two possible cases of overlapping, namely overlapping with benefits provided by virtue of the pursuit of a professional or trade activity and not overlapping with benefits provided on the basis of residence. This latter case of overlapping is covered by Article 10 (1) (b) of Reguladon No 574/72 (as modified by Reguladon No 878/73) fixing the procedure for implementing Reguladon No 1408/71. Those two provisions, read together, provide a complete picture of the Community rules covering all possible cases of overlapping.In accordance with those provisions the overlapping of rights to family benefits or family allowances, supplementary or special orphans' pensions with rights to family benefits or family allowances payable in the Sute where the orphans reside is governed as follows:1. Where rights are acquired in the Sute of residence by virtue of the pursuit of a professional or trade activity the right to benefits due under Article 78 is suspended (Article 79 (3)).2. Where acquisition of the right to benefits payable in the Sute of residence is not subject to conditions of insurance or employment and where the person on whom the orphans are dependent(a) does not pursue a professional or trade activity in the territory of that Sute rights acquired in the Sute of residence are suspended (Anide 10 (1) (b));(b) pursues a professional or trade activity in that territory rights acquired in pursuance of Anide 78 are suspended but not rights to benefits which are not family allowances, that is to say orphans' benefits or orphans' pensions (Article 10 (1) (b)).The exception set out in 2 (b) above is relevant to the present case since it provides a basis for the conclusion that the overlapping of special allowances or pensions provided for orphans in the competent Sute in accordance with Article 78 with family allowances provided in the Sute of residence in which the trade or professional activity is pursued not merely cannot be prohibited but must be guaranteed. What holds good in the case of Article 10 (1) (b) cannot be otherwise in the case of Article 79 (3).It can thus be considered that Article 10 (1) (b) confirms that the overlapping of benefits granted to orphans as such with family benefits provided without regard for that particular status does not constitute an unjustified overlapping of benefits from a social point of view.In conclusion, the Commission is of the view that the following reply could be given to the questions submitted:1. Article 79 (3) of Regulation No 1408/71 prohibits the overlapping of rights under Article 78 and Anide 79 (2) of the said regulation with rights to family benefits or family allowances acquired by virtue of the pursuit of a professional or trade activity where the overlapping of such rights is due to circumstances relating to the movement within the Community of the insured worker.2. According to the provisions of Article 79 (3) the right to supplementary or special allowances for orphans or orphans' pensions is to be suspended only in so far as it overlaps with rights similar in kind to family benefits or family allowances acquired by virtue of the pursuit of a professional or trade activity.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.