law://eu/cjeu/1976/c-9-76/hd_1_1_3_1_2@2026-11-19The applicant states that Article 25 of the Staff Regulations of Officials provides that “Any decision adversely affecting an official shall state the reasons on which it is based”. Furthermore the Court of Justice has ruled that the first stage of the tasks of a Selection Board entails “particularly where the competition is based on formal qualifications, … the matching of the qualifications offered by the candidates against the qualifications required by the competition notice”; the qualifications “must be matched on the basis of objective facts which are moreover known to each candidate in his own case” and the results must “be supported by sufficiently clear reasons” (Judgment of the Court of 15 March 1973, Case 37/72, Marcato v Commission [1973] ECR 361 at page 369 and Judgment of the Court of 4 December 1975, Case 31/75, Costacurta v Commission [1975] ECR 1571).The Commission states that it is evident from the letter of 12 February 1976 that the Selection Board has stated the reasons on which the contested decision was based and that the submission is therefore unfounded.The applicant replies that it is evident that the submission is well founded alone from the fact that “the contents of a decision are legally, in respect of the person to whom it is addressed, those which appear from the notification” with the result that, in the present case, the contested decision is deemed not to state the reasons on which it is based.If the Court were not to accept this view the reasons which were subsequently communicated to the applicant nevertheless do not satisfy the requirements laid down by law. The Selection Board merely repeated the text of the competition notice without making any reference to the individual situation of the applicant. Its report, which the applicant annexes to his reply, contains no comparative analysis at all of the candidates' files of the applicant and the other officials excluded from the tests on the one hand and on the other, those of the applicants who were admitted to the competition.The Commission replies that the first argument raised by the applicant would deny the administration the possibility of correcting any administrative, drafting or typing error. The fact that the reasons for a decision are communicated after the communication of the substance of the decision does not adversely affect the official provided that the reasons were in fact formulated by the author of the decision at the time of making the decision. In the present case the applicant's demands are satisfied by the communication contained in the letter of 12 February 1976; in these circumstances it is evident from the case-law of the Court of Justice that the submission is unfounded (Judgment of the Court of 12 December 1967, Case 15/67, Bauer v Commission [1967] ECR 397; Judgment of the Court of 30 October 1969, Case 33/68, Rittweger v Commission [1969] ECR 393).If it becomes evident from the application that the person concerned has not acquired the necessary professional experience it is sufficient, for the purposes of a statement of reasons, for the Selection Board to repeat the wording of the competition notice. Finally it is clear from the passages from the judgment in the Costacurta case referred to by the applicant that the Selection Board was not obliged to undertake a comparative analysis of the candidates' files.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.