law://eu/cjeu/1976/c-85-76/hd_1_1_3_5_3@2026-11-22The applicant replies that as far as concerns the absence of proof of any misconduct on its part the defendant deliberately overlooks the fact that even genuine fidelity rebates (which are not found in this case) are in principle acceptable under competition law (judgment of the Court of 11 June 1968 in Case 22/67 De Wendel et Cie SA v Commission of the European Communities [1968] ECR 263).An offence cannot originate in the anticipation of the effects of a fidelity rebate which is in principle acceptable.The defendant has put forward in the present case some views which it has never put forward before and which are inconsistent both with its own practice and the case-law of the Court of Justice. They are as follows:— the applicant's market shares of about only 50 % are themselves factors establishing that there is a dominant position on the market;— the fact, which is not disputed, that all the markets in vitamins are expanding is irrelevant;— the conduct on the market and market performance are not determinative;— proof of the power to fix prices is unnecessary;— there may be a finding that the applicant dominates the market in spite of proof that, under the pressure of ‘strong’ and ‘tough’ competition it lowered its prices considerably owing to the action taken by its ‘aggressive’ competitors and had to accept extensive losses of its market shares;— the financial strength of its competitors, which is beyond all doubt much greater, is not material;— in the context of Article 86 a careful consideration of the interests involved is impossible;— under Article 86 the effects of the course of conduct to which exception is taken are not material.On the other hand the defendant also relies on the judgment of 16 December 1975 in the ‘Sugar Case’ and thus confirms that from 1964 to 1973 a good many objections were not foreseeable. As far as concerns the dominant position as well as the abuse the criteria which were determinative in the ‘Sugar Case’ for the application of Article 86 and the gravity of the infringement are not present.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.