law://eu/cjeu/1971/c-90-71/hd_1_1_3_3_2@2026-11-22The applicant maintains that in creating a vacancy in the interest of a candidate whom it evidently wished to favour, the Parliament was clearly acting contrary to Articles 4 and 7 of the Staff Regulations.In fact Mrs Dell'Omodarme was accorded advantages which were not justified by the interests of the service. The behaviour of the Parliament in the appointment procedure provides a body of evidence that the outcome of this procedure was fixed in advance. The period during which the vacancy notice was posted up was arranged in such a way that it was to be expected that the applicant would not apply for the post, since on the one hand he had left Luxembourg on 7 July 1971 for his holiday in Italy on the very day when the notice was published and on the other the Administration could not but be aware that on the closing date for applications, 20 July 1971, he would still be on holiday. Consequently, the posting of the vacancy notice must be characterized at the least as an attempted subterfuge which, in view of the fact that the Parliament had already failed in a first case against the applicant (judgment of the Court of Justice of 16 March 1971 in Case 48/70, Bernardi v European Parliament [1971] ECR 195) relating to the annulment of two interim appointments of Mrs Dell'-Omodarme to the grade to which she has now been promoted, can only be intended to facilitate the promotion of that lady. In his reply the applicant further asserts that the adoption of a decision of promotion on the basis of an incomplete and unsigned periodic report without notifying the Bureau of the Parliament constitutes a misuse of powers, the probable object of which is thereby to revive the situation declared unlawful by the Court.The defendant maintains that the submission by the applicant of his application on 19 July suffices to prove that he knew of the vacancy notice. The Parliament formally rebuts the accusation that it has endeavoured to perpetrate a subterfuge. It had neither the time nor the inclination to indulge in such underhand dealings.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.