law://eu/cjeu/1981/c-298-81/hd_1_1_3@2026-11-16The Parliament raises no objection to the admissibility of the action but it considers that, in accordance with the Rules of Procedure, the applicant cannot be allowed to make good in his reply a deficiency in the conclusions formulated in the application.In his first submission, the applicant points out that it was impossible for the appointing authority to consider the comparative merits of the officials eligible for promotion without organizing an internal competition, as provided for in Article 29 (1) (b) of the Staff Regulations of Officials in view of the fact that certain of the duties attaching to the vacant post, such as vocational training, had never before been performed by officials in Grade L/A 4. In the absence of any frame of reference and in view of the novelty of the post, it was not possible to make a decision solely on the basis of the periodic report because that report could not contain any information relating to those duties, which moreover were not described in a precise manner in the vacancy notice. The vacancy notice is therefore void. If a step in the recruitment procedure is void, it follows that the disputed decision to promote one of the candidates must also be void.The Parliament points out in the first place that the above submission according to which the vacancy notice is void, is inadmissible inasmuch as the applicant did not claim it to be void in the conclusions'set out in his application.In addition, the Parliament emphasizes that it had merely followed the chronological order prescribed by Article 29 of the Staff Regulations for the consideration of the different steps in the recruitment procedure. The appointing authority is free to choose between the different means of recruitment. Similarly, the administration has an exclusive discretion as regards the description of the nature of the duties relating to a vacant post.In his second submission, the applicant maintains that it is not established that the President of the Parliament was empowered to act as appointing authority in the circumstances of the case. The appointment of the President as appointing authority made by Decision No 175/62 of the Bureau of the Parliament on 12 December 1962, in the form of a sub-delegation, is not valid because the Bureau itself had no authority so to act. The Rules of Procedure of the Parliament of 26 July 1958 contain no provision which empowers the Bureau to act in that sphere and Article 49 of the Rules of Procedure of November 1969 is identical in that respect. It is therefore the institution itself, namely the Parliament, which should have designated the appointing authority according to Article 2 of the Staff Regulations. In the absence of such a decision, only the Parliament itself is empowered to act as the appointing authority.The Parliament states that the disputed decision was adopted on the basis of Decision No 175/62 of the Bureau of 12 December 1962 concerning the designation of the appointing authority according to which the Bureau“Having regard to Article 2 of the Staff Regulations of Officials ...Decides that the powers conferred by the Staff Regulations of Officials on the appointing authority ... shall be exercised :(i) ...(c) by the President, on the proposal of the Secretary General :For the application of the provisions of Articles ..., 29, ... 45, to officials of Category A, Grades 1 to 7 inclusive, and of the languages, staff, Grades 1 to 6 inclusive ...; however, advance notification shall be given to the Bureau of decisions in connection with the filling of posts in Category A:...”That decision was adopted under the former Staff Regulations, Article 2 of which already contained a provision identical to Article 2 of the present Staff Regulations. The applicant's theory that a plenary sitting of the Parliament itself must regulate its administrative organization is absurd, as it is a deliberative body with a large number of members. For that reason the Parliament in its Rules of Procedure, both in the version in force at the time of the disputed promotion (Article 49) and in that in force at the time of the adoption of Decision No 175/62 of the Bureau which was published in Official Journal 2449/62 of 15 October 1962 provides as follows :1. Parliament shall be assisted by a Secretary General appointed by the Bureau.2. The Secretary General shall head a secretariat the composition and organization of which shall be determined by the Bureau.3. The Bureau, after consulting the appropriate committee of Parliament, shall decide the number of staff and lay down regulations relating to their administrative and financial situation.”The Bureau was therefore empowered to designate the appointing authority in accordance with the Staff Regulations.In his third submission, the applicant maintains that the abovementioned decision of the Bureau was not observed because, in this case, the Bureau was not informed in advance. The applicant considers that the distinction made by the decision of the Bureau between officials of Categories A and L/A is explained as a clerical error.The Parliament points out that the wording of the decision of the Bureau clearly limits to officials in Category A the requirement of advance notification and it is impossible to extend it, by means of interpretation, to officials of the languages staff. In that respect it refers to the judgment of the Court of 13 July 1972 (Case 90/71, Bernardi v Parliament, [1972] ECR 603). Moreover the provision merely makes a recommendation, and does not impose an obligation. Failure to observe it cannot therefore entail nullity.In his fourth submission, the applicant claims that it is not established that the President of Parliament gave his personal consideration to the examination of the comparative merits required by Article 45 of the Staff Regulations, since his letter of 4 September 1981, which dismissed the complaint, referred only to a thorough investigation undertaken by the President's staff and did not state that the President had personally conducted such an investigation. It is therefore for the Parliament to provide the evidence that such a personal examination of the periodic reports and the merits of the candidates actually took place.The Parliament states that the disputed decision was actually taken by the President of the Parliament himself. It is for the applicant to establish the contrary, and there is absolutely no evidence to that effect.In his fifth submission, the applicant maintains that it has not been established that the appointing authority undertook a genuine examination of the merits of the candidates and their periodic reports and that it did not merely consider Mr Fua's memorandum of 8 October 1980 in which the decisive factors were presented incompletely and inaccurately.The Parliament replies by referring to the absence of any evidence and points out that the memorandum in question was drawn up in accordance with administrative practice. It does not prove that the appointing authority failed to consider the prescribed criteria.In his sixth submission, the applicant claims that the appointing authority did not take into consideration the fact that the applicant's abilities were more impressive than those of the successful candidate. It did not take into account the degrees and certificates, in particular in law, which he held in addition to the two theses on subjects relating to economics which he completed in the course of his studies. Those facts appeared in his file and he drew attention to them again at the time of his application for the post. Mrs Cattarino on the other hand, did not have the specific knowledge of legal affairs, political science, economics or scientific matters referred to in the notice. Mr Fua's memorandum of 8 October 1980 shows that the candidates' files were not examined fully and fairly, with the necessary care, in particular in so far as the fact that the applicant, unlike Mrs Cattarino, had on several occasions been called upon to serve as a member of a selection board was not taken into account.According to the Parliament, that submission must fail because it questions the discretionary power of the appointing authority. The applicant's qualities were noted in his periodic report and taken into consideration as part of the examination of merits, as is also shown by Mr Fua's memorandum.The applicant's seventh submission alleges misuse of power. The appointing authority did not expressly refute the allegation made by the applicant in his request of 1 October 1980 and in his complaint of 19 April 1981 that the posts in question had been reserved for the oldest officials. Moreover, the wording of Mr Fua's memorandum supports that conclusion. Thus the appointing authority automatically selected the oldest official in the English and Danish Divisions. The applicant suggests that, in reality, when recruitment is by competition, the age of the candidates may be a negative factor.The posts in question were therefore actually reserved in advance for the oldest candidates, which constitutes a misuse of power.The Parliament disputes the assertion that the posts concerned were reserved in advance for the oldest official or the one with the greatest seniority in each division. However, it points out that age and seniority may be a factor, even a decisive factor, when other conditions and qualifications are equal.In his eighth submission, the applicant maintains that the fact that the President of the Parliament adjudicated on both the promotion and the complaint constituted a breach of the principle nemo judex in re sua. The decision on the complaint should have been taken by the Bureau of the Parliament.The Parliament replies to that submission that the principles which govern legal affairs cannot be applied to the administrative procedure, instituted by Article 90 of the Staff Regulations, which in no way has the character of proceedings before a court of law.As regards the evidence in support of the various submissions, the applicant considers that the Parliament should complete the file by submitting all the necessary papers, and in particular those relating to the description of the duties of Linguistic Adviser, the way in which the vacancy notice was drafted and settled, the choice of the procedure provided for in Article 29 (1) (a) of the Staff Regulations, the training, qualifications and merits of Mrs Cattarino including her personal file and her periodic reports together with the documents to which, in addition to Mr Fua's memorandum of 8 October 1980, the President of the Parliament must have had access. The applicant has therefore asked the Court to request the Parliament to submit those documents.The Parliament replies that it has provided the applicant's file and has included necessary or helpful documents in the annex to its defence. The applicant's request for supplementary information, in particular as regards the request for the production of the personal file of an official who is not a party to the action, is not justified.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.