law://eu/cjeu/1969/c-63-69/hd_1_1_3@2026-11-19The submissions and arguments of the parties as to the admissibility of the application may be summarized as follows :The defendant first alleges that, taken as a whole, Regulation No 1670/69 has general application in that it determines, as regards products subject to the common organization of the market in the rice and cereals sectors, the provisions for giving effect to the rules introduced by Regulation No 1586/69 of the Council. Consequently the question raised by the present application is whether the two contested provisions constitute an exception in this respect, in that their nature is not primarily legislative, so that they can be regarded as a decision of direct and individual concern to the applicants. It is from this viewpoint that the defendant develops its arguments, first as regards the fixing of the compensatory amount on exports and secondly as regards the provision in Article 6, paragraph 2.A — After outlining the situation produced on the one hand by the devaluation of the French franc and on the other by the adoption of Regulation No 1586/69 of the Council, the defendant concludes that the fixing of the amounts of the import subsidies and of the compensatory amounts charged on exports for common wheat forms an integral part of the machinery set up by Regulation No 1586/69 of the Council and set in motion by Regulation No 1670/69 of the Commission. The position as regards common wheat is equally that of wheat or mesiin flour, which are products of first-stage processing and therefore closely bound up with the system applicable to common wheat.Moreover it is obvious, according to the defendant, that the provision fixing the compensatory amounts for exports has general application in view of the following considerations :— the provision in question applies to objectively determined situations ;— it has legal consequences for categories of persons (and of transactions) which are viewed in a general and abstract manner with reference to their share in the market for the product in question.It also follows from the last consideration that the applicant has no grounds for claiming that the fixing of the compensatory amount on exports is of individual concern to it, since there is nothing to distinguish it in this respect from the other participants in the market in question.Considering it unnecessary to establish whether the contested provision is of direct concern to the applicant, the defendant thereby concludes that this submission is inadmissible.B — According to the defendant the application directed against the second paragraph of Article 6 of Regulation No 1670/69 is also inadmissible. Its main points in this context are as follows :— Since Article 2 of the above regulation is in the nature of a regulation, any provision which, like the second paragraph of Article 6, lays down the conditions of its application ratione temporis, shares that nature ;— The second paragraph of Article 6 has general application and concerns the applicant solely by reason of his being a member of a category which, moreover, is not the only category envisaged ;— if, moreover, Article 6 is considered in relation to the fixing of the level of the compensatory amount, that fixing is not of direct and individual concern to the applicant in so far as it takes effect from 11 August 1969;— in this context it is not possible to rely on the fact that at the time when the regulation was adopted the persons concerned by it were identifiable, in order to justify the conclusion that they were at that time distinguished individually by virtue of this fact, and thus that they were concerned as individuals;— Such a view would make the contested measure subject to two different sets of rules, the first applicable during the period of retroactivity, and the other for the remainder of the period of application of the measure, an unacceptable result, according to the defendant.The applicant alleges, first, that the contested provisions should be examined to see whether they are of direct and individual concern to it without first stopping to conduct an examination of the nature of these provisions in abstracto. In this respect it refers to the judgment of the Court in Case 40/64 (Sgarlata and Others v Commission of the EEC, [1965] E.C.R. 215 et seq.).Next it remarks that it in no way contests the principle underlying the fixing of the compensatory amount on exports of wheat or mesiin flour, but solely the fixing of that amount at the sum of 81.87 FF per metric ton of flour.It cannot be argued that this provision is not clearly of direct and individual concern to it, because the result of the fixing is a loss to it of 10.80 FF per metric ton exported, or 1.08 FF per quintal. It is quite obvious that the increase in the mill FOB charges and the sacking price is not the same for all the various undertakings exporting flour and that the charges must differ according to the geographical location of the factory and the size of the sacking plant. Thus, even though the amount has to be fixed at a flat rate, it must take into account that increase in the cost price. In any event it cannot be considered as affecting all the undertakings concerned in a similar fashion and this alone, according to the applicant, is sufficient to destroy the argument on the point set out in the interlocutory application.Next the applicant claims that the case-law of the Court reveals that the concept of individuality does not imply that only one natural or legal person may be concerned by the measure in question; it can equally well support the proposition that more than one person can be affected, provided that such persons are clearly identifiable and that their activities are carried out in the same marketing centre. That is precisely the case here, the undertakings affected having been recognized as such by the Commission on the date of the contested measure, the only date relevant in the present instance.On the other hand the contested provision also concerns the applicant directly by virtue of the losses it has suffered consequent upon the fixing of the compensatory amount at 81.87 FF per metric ton.As regards the second head of its conclusions the applicant notes that in the interlocutory application it is claimed that the arguments used to support the submission that the first head of the conclusions is inadmissible are equally valid for the second. It points out that the head of the conclusions directed against Article 6 is not a subsidiary claim but a principal one, and invokes the same arguments against the submissions in the interlocutory application as it used with regard to the first head of the conclusions, and considers that no further observations are called for.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.