means: applicable to the notified measure(s), mandatory national standards that are more stringent or ambitious than the corresponding Union standards, or mandatory national standards adopted in the absence of Union standards.
(c)Part III.5 is replaced by the following:‘PART III.5.ASUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION SHEET ON STATE AID FOR TAKE-UP MEASURESThis supplementary information sheet should be used for notifications of aid for take-up measures deployment covered by the Commission Guidelines on State aid for broadband networksnote(“Broadband Guidelines”).1.GENERAL INFORMATION1.1.Please provide a detailed description of the aid measure and of its objectives.…1.2.Please explain why, in your view, the aid measure amounts to State aidnote.…1.3.Please indicate whether the aid measure consists of:
(a)An online registry of all eligible service providers (or an equivalent alternative platform) will be implemented.…
(a)Start and end date of each public consultation carried-outnote.…
(a)Whether the existing or planned backhaul networks are based:
☐Fibre
☐other technology with the same performance of fibre
☐other technologies without the same performance of fibre
(a)Start and end date of each public consultation carried-outnote.…
(a)For an aid measure concerning fixed access networks, please provide the following information:
(i)If the State intervention concerns white or grey areas, please indicate whether the subsidised networks at least triple the download speed provided by existing network(s), and represents a significant new infrastructure investment bringing significant new capabilities to the market (for example, in terms of availability, capacity, speeds and competition)note.…
(ii)If the State intervention concerns mixed (i.e., white and grey) areas, please state reasons why the dissociation of white and grey areas is not justifiednote.…Moreover, please confirm that the following cumulative conditions are fulfillednote:
—The overbuilding of the grey areasnote does not create undue distortions of competition, based on the results of a public consultation.
—The overbuilding is limited to maximum 10 % of all premises in the target area.
—The subsidised networks at least triple the download speed provided by network(s) already existing in the white part of the mixed area, and provide substantially better services than the ones available in the grey part of the mixed area.
(a)Please indicate whether the aid is granted on the basis of an open, transparent and non-discriminatory competitive selection procedure, in line with the principles of public procurementnote.☐Yes ☐No
(a)Whether and, if so, how undertakings willing to participate in a competitive selection procedure are encouraged to use available existing infrastructures to deploy the subsidised networksnote.…
(a)General information.
(i)Please confirm that wholesale access will be granted as early as possible before starting to provide the relevant services and, where the network operator also intends to provide retail services, at least 6 months before the launch of those retail servicesnote.…
(ii)Please confirm that the subsidised networks will offer access under fair and non-discriminatory conditions, specifying whether this implies the upgrade and/or increase of the capacity of existing infrastructure, where necessary, and the deployment of sufficient new infrastructurenote. Please provide details in this regard.…
(iii)Please confirm that the terms, conditions and prices for the wholesale access products will be indicated in the documents of the competitive selection procedure and on a comprehensive website, at national or regional level, accessible to the general public without any restrictions (specifying the relevant web address)note.…
(iv)Please confirm that wholesale access will also be granted to parts of the network that have not been State funded or that may not have been deployed by the aid beneficiary if necessary to render the wholesale access effective and to enable access seekers to provide their servicesnote.…
(a)Please confirm that the clawback mechanism will be applied for the lifespan of the subsidised networknote.☐Yes ☐No
(a)Please confirm that your authorities will publish (i) the full text of the decision approving the aid measure and its implementing provisions (or a link to them), and (ii) information on each individual aid award exceeding EUR 100000, in accordance with Annex IInote (within 6 months from the date of award of the aid or, for aid in the form of tax advantages, within 1 year from the date that the tax declaration is due)note,
☐In the Commission’s transparency award modulenote.
☐On a comprehensive State aid website (providing the relevant web address). In this case, please specify whether it is national or regional websitenote and easy access to the information registered in the aid website is allowed (i.e., the general public must be allowed to access the website without restrictions)note.…
(a)Start and end date of each public consultation carried-outnote.…
(a)An online registry of all eligible service providers (or an equivalent alternative platform) will be implemented.…
(a)Start and end date of each public consultation carried-outnote.…
(a)Please confirm that the Member State will publish (i) the full text of the decision approving the aid measure and its implementing provisions (or a link to them), and (ii) information on each individual aid award exceeding EUR 100000, in accordance with Annex IInote (within 6 months from the date of award of the aid or, for aid in the form of tax advantages, within 1 year from the date that the tax declaration is due)note,
☐In the Commission’s transparency award modulenote.
☐On a comprehensive State aid website (providing the relevant web address). In this case, please specify whether it is national or regional websitenote and easy access to the information registered in the aid website is allowed (i.e., the general public must be allowed to access the website without restrictions)note.
…
(a)Performance of the existing and planned (in the relevant time horizon) networks that have been mapped (for example, download speed, upload speed, latency, packet loss, packet error, jitter, service availability)note.…
(a)None of the existing or credibly planned networks provide a download speed of at least 300 Mbps under peak-time conditionsnote.☐Yes ☐No
(a)Start and end date of each public consultation carried-outnote.…
(a)The type (for example, 3G, 4G, 5G, 6G, others) of networks and their number available in the intervention area
(b)Consumers are free to consult the registry.…
(b)Content of each public consultationnote.…
(b)Performance criteria of the existing or planned (in the relevant time horizon) backhaul networks that have been mapped.…
(b)Content of each public consultationnote.…
(b)For aid measure concerning mobile access networks, please explain if and how the aid measure will ensure an improvement of mobile services’ availability, capacity, speeds and competition capable of fostering the adoption of new innovative servicesnote.…
(b)If yes:
(i)Please explain if and how the design of the competitive selection procedure is capable of fostering the widest possible participationnote.…
(ii)Please confirm that, if the number of participants to the competitive selection procedure or the number of eligible bids is not sufficient, an independent auditor will be entrusted with the assessment of the winning bid (including cost calculations)note.…
(iii)Please confirm that the tender will be awarded on the basis of the most economically advantageous offernote and provide details in this regard.…
(iv)Please indicate the objective, transparent and non-discriminatory award criteria and specify the relative weighting of each criterionnote.…
(b)Whether and, if so, how undertakings willing to participate in a competitive selection procedure are encouraged to provide detailed information on the existing infrastructures that they own or control in the planned intervention area in due time to be taken into account when preparing the bids, specifying the type of information requestednote.…
(b)Wholesale access terms and conditions.
(i)Please indicate for how many years effective wholesale access will be granted to:
☐Active products (except VULA)note …
☐VULAnote …
☐New infrastructuresnote …
(ii)Please confirm that, if State aid is granted for new infrastructure, the infrastructure will be large enough to meet access seekers’ current and evolving demandnote.☐Yes ☐No
(iii)Please explain how the new infrastructure will be able to meet access seekers’ current and evolving demand (for example, size of the ducts, number of fibres, etc.).…
(iv)Please confirm that the same access conditions apply to the entire subsidised network, including the parts of the network where existing infrastructure has been usednote
(b)Please confirm that the rules of the clawback mechanism are set out transparently and clearly in the competitive selection procedure’s documentationnote. Please provide details in this regard.…
(b)Please confirm that the information under point 10.1. will be available for at least 10 years from the date on which the aid was granted, will be published in a non-proprietary spreadsheet data format, which allows data to be effectively searched, extracted, downloaded and easily published on the internet (for instance, in CSV or XML format).☐Yes ☐No
(b)Content of each public consultationnote.…
(b)Consumers are free to consult the registry.…
(b)Content of each public consultationnote.…
(b)Please confirm that the information under point 4.4 will be available for at least 10 years from the date on which the aid was granted, will be published in a non-proprietary spreadsheet data format, which allows data to be effectively searched, extracted, downloaded and easily published on the internet (for instance, in CSV or XML format).☐Yes ☐No
(b)How future investment plans in the relevant time horizon of the aid measure have been assessed to establish their credibilitynote. Inter alia, please indicate:…
(i)The evidence requested to, and submitted by, the relevant stakeholders to demonstrate the credibility of their investment plansnote.…
(ii)The assessment criteria applied to assess the credibility of future investment plansnote.…
(iii)Whether the stakeholders concerned were invited to sign commitment agreements regarding the implementation of the declared investment plansnote.☐Yes ☐NoIf yes, please clarify whether such commitment agreements include milestones and obligations to report progressnote.…
(iv)Whether the results of the assessment and the relative justified conclusions were communicated to all stakeholders who submitted information about their private investment plans (and how)note.…
(b)At least one of the existing or credibly planned networks provides a download speed of at least 300 Mbps under peak-time conditions but does not provide a download speed of at least 500 Mbps under peak-time conditionsnote.☐Yes ☐NoIf yes, please clarify why your authorities are of the view that no networks will evolve towards providing the same download speed (and, if appropriate, the same additional features) of the networks subsidised under the aid measure and, therefore, State intervention is needed to address a market failurenote.…
(b)Content of each public consultationnote.…
(b)Performance criteria of the existing and planned (in the relevant time horizon) networks that have been mapped (for example, download speed, upload speed, latency, packet loss, packet error, jitter, service availability)note.…
(c)All undertakings capable of providing the eligible broadband services may request to be included in the registry (or in the alternative platform chosen).…
(c)Publicly accessible Internet site (at regional and national level) where the consultation was publishednote.…
(c)How future investment plans in the relevant time horizon of the aid measure have been assessed to establish their credibility. Inter alia, please indicate:
(i)The evidence requested to, and submitted by, the relevant stakeholders to demonstrate the credibility of their investment plansnote.…
(ii)The assessment criteria applied to assess the credibility of future investment plansnote.…
(iii)Whether the stakeholders concerned were invited to sign commitment agreements regarding the implementation of the declared investment plansnote.☐Yes ☐NoIf yes, please clarify whether such commitment agreements include milestones and obligations to report progressnote.…
(iv)Whether the results of the assessment and the relative justified conclusions were communicated to all stakeholders who submitted information about their private investment plans (and how)note.…
(c)Publicly accessible Internet site (at regional and national level) where the consultation was publishednote.…
(c)For aid measure concerning backhaul networks, please explain if and how, as a result of the State intervention, the subsidised networks represent a significant investment in backhaul infrastructure and adequately support the increasing needs of fixed and/or mobile access networksnote.…
(c)If no, please confirm that the State intervention is implemented through a direct investment model and provide adequate justification of the choice of network and of the technological solution adoptednote.…
(c)Whether the provision of that information is a condition for participation in the selection procedurenote.☐Yes ☐No
(c)Wholesale access products.
(i)Fixed access networks deployed in white areas. Please list the wholesale access products that the subsidised network must provide, taking into account that it must provide at least bitstream access, access to dark fibre and access to infrastructure (including street cabinets, poles, masts, towers, and ducts)note and, in addition, at least physical unbundling or VULAnote.…
(ii)Fixed access networks deployed in grey and black areas. Please list the wholesale access products that the subsidised network must provide, taking into account that it must provide at least bitstream access, access to dark fibre and access to infrastructure (including street cabinets, poles, masts, towers, and ducts) and, in addition, physical unbundlingnote. If your authorities intend to grant a derogation from the obligation to provide physical unbundling, please provide relevant justifications, demonstrate that the derogation does not risk unduly distorting competition and indicate the comments received in this regard in the public consultation (and how they were addressed)note.…
(iii)Mobile access networks. Please list the wholesale access products that the subsidised network must provide, taking into account that it must provide at least roamingnote and access to poles, masts, towers and ducts. Moreover, please confirm that the subsidised network will have to provide the access products necessary to exploit the more advanced features (for example, MORAN, MOCN, network slicingnote) of mobile networks, such as 5G and future generations of mobile networks, as soon as they become availablenote
(c)Please explain how the design of clawback mechanism will consider and balance two objectives, namely the recovery by the Member State of the amounts that exceed a reasonable profit and the safeguard of incentives for undertakings to participate in a competitive selection procedure and to strive for cost efficiencies (efficiency gains) when rolling out the networknote. In this regard, please specify the criteria adopted to incentivise efficiency gains.…
(c)Please confirm that, for aid that is unlawful but subsequently found to be compatible, the relevant information is published on a State aid website (specifying the relevant web address) within 6 months from the date of the Commission’s decision declaring the aid compatiblenote.☐Yes ☐No
(c)Publicly accessible Internet site (at regional and/or national level) where the consultation was published.…
(c)All undertakings capable of providing the eligible broadband services may request to be included in the registry (or in the alternative platform chosen).…
(c)Publicly accessible Internet site (at regional and/or national level) where the consultation was published.…
(c)Please confirm that, for aid that is unlawful but subsequently found to be compatible, the relevant information is published on a State aid website (specifying the relevant web address) within 6 months from the date of the Commission’s decision declaring the aid compatiblenote.☐Yes ☐No
(c)Start and end date of each step of the mapping exercise.…
(c)At least one of the existing or credibly planned networks provides a download speed of at least 500 Mbpsnote.☐Yes ☐No
(c)Publicly accessible Internet site (at regional and national level) where the consultation was publishednote.…
(c)How future investment plans in the relevant time horizon of the aid measure have been assessed to establish their credibility. Inter alia, please indicate:
(i)The evidence requested to, and submitted by, the relevant stakeholders to demonstrate the credibility of their investment plansnote.…
(ii)The assessment criteria applied to assess the credibility of future investment plansnote.…
(iii)Whether the stakeholders concerned were invited to sign commitment agreements regarding the implementation of the declared investment plansnote.☐Yes ☐NoIf yes, please clarify whether such commitment agreements include milestones and obligations to report progressnote.…
(iv)Whether the results of the assessment and the relative justified conclusions were communicated to all stakeholders who submitted information about their private investment plans, and hownote.…
(d)The registry (or the alternative platform chosen) provides additional information to assist consumers (for example, type of services provided by different undertakings, etc.). If so, please indicate the additional information provided.…
(d)A recap of the main observations submitted by contributors in each public consultation, specifying how they were addressed.…
(d)Please confirm that any concession or other entrustment by a public authority or in-house entity to a third party to design, build or operate the subsidised network is allocated through an open, transparent and non-discriminatory competitive selection procedure, in line with the principles of public procurement, based on the most economically advantageous offernote. Please provide details in this regard.…
(d)Whether and, if so, how all available information on existing infrastructure that could be used for rolling out broadband networks in the intervention areas are made accessible, specifying whether a Single Information Point has been set up pursuant to Article 4(2) of Directive 2014/61/EUnote.…
(d)Wholesale access pricing. Please indicate on which of the following benchmarks and pricing principles the wholesale access price for each product is based:
☐average published wholesale prices that prevail in other comparable and more competitive areas of the Member Statenote.
☐regulated prices already set or approved by the National Regulatory Authority (NRA) for the markets and services concernednote.
☐costs orientation or a methodology mandated in accordance with the sectoral regulatory frameworknote.
(d)Please indicate the maximum incentive amount (in percentage of the reasonable profit allowednote). Moreover, please specify the notion of reasonable profit applied for the purposes of the clawback mechanismnote.…
(d)A recap of the main observations submitted by contributors in each public consultation, specifying how they were addressed.…
(d)The registry (or the alternative platform chosen) provides additional information to assist consumers (for example, type of services provided by different undertakings, etc.). If so, please indicate the additional information provided.…
(d)A recap of the main observations submitted by contributors in each public consultation, specifying how they were addressed.…
(d)Number and identity of contributors to each step of the mapping exercise.…
(d)A recap of the main observations submitted by contributors in each public consultation, specifying how they were addressed.…
(d)Start and end date of each step of the mapping exercise.…
(d)A recap of the main observations submitted by contributors in each public consultation, specifying how they were addressed.…
(d)Start and the end date of each step of the mapping exercise.…
(e)Intermediate results and final results of the mapping exercise.…
(e)Number and identity of contributors to each step of the mapping exercise.…
(e)Number and identity of contributors to each step of the mapping exercise.…
(e)Please confirm that any extra profit equal or below the threshold below (i.e., the reasonable profit increased by the incentive amount) will not be clawed-back by the Member State, whereas any profit in excess of the threshold will be shared between the aid beneficiary and the Member State, on the basis of the aid intensity resulting from the outcome of the competitive selection procedurenote. Please provide details in this regard.…
(f)Confirmation that the mapping exercise has been carried outnote:
☐for fixed wired networks, at address level on the basis of premises passednote.
☐for fixed wireless networks, at address level on the basis of premises passed or on the basis of a maximum 100 x 100 metre (or smaller) grids. Please specify which of the two criteria was applied: …
(f)Intermediate results and final results of the mapping exercise.…
(f)Intermediate results and final results of the mapping exercise.…
(f)Please confirm that the clawback mechanism takes into account also profits made from other transactions concerning the subsidised networknote.☐Yes ☐No
(g)Confirmation that the mapping exercise also mapped existing networks that could be upgraded with marginal investments (such as an upgrade of the active components) to provide 1 Gbps download and 150 Mbps upload speeds and that such areas have been carved out from the intervention areanote.☐Yes ☐No
(g)Confirmation that the mapping exercise has been carried out at address level on the basis of premises passed or on the basis of a maximum 100 x 100 metre (or smaller) gridsnote. Please specify which of the two criteria was applied.…
(g)Confirmation that the methodology and the underlying technical criteria for mapping have been made publicly available (and how)note.…
(h)Whether your authorities complied with the best practices for applying the mapping methodologies described in Annex I of the Broadband Guidelinesnote.
☐Yes
☐No. In this case, please specify in which respects your authorities deviated from Annex I of the Broadband Guidelines and for what reason.…
(h)Whether your authorities complied with the best practices for applying the mapping methodologies described in Annex I of the Broadband Guidelinesnote.
☐Yes
☐No. In this case, please specify in which respects the your authorities deviated from Annex I of the Broadband Guidelines and for what reason.…
(i)Confirmation that the methodology and the underlying technical criteria for mapping have been made publicly available (and how)note.…
(i)Confirmation that the methodology and the underlying technical criteria for mapping have been made publicly available (and how)note.…
☐Social vouchersnote
☐deployment of mobile access networksnote.
☐4G
☐5G
☐other
☐Gap fundingnote
☐Fixed access networks
☐Mapping exercisenote. If so, please provide details: …
☐Economic impact of the cost of subscribing to broadband services. If so, please provide details.…
☐Impact assessment of the aid measure …
☐Subscribe to new broadband services. Details:…
☐Consumers
☐Subscribe to new broadband services. Details:…
☐No. Please explain why you consider the criteria for ex post evaluation plan not to be fulfilled.…
☐Yes. If so, please indicate the confidential information and provide reasons for confidentiality.
☐deployment of fixed access networksnote. If so, please specify the type of areas targeted by the aid measure.
☐Whitenote
☐Greynote
☐Mixed (white and grey)note
☐Blacknote
☐Connectivity vouchersnote
☐Support in kindnote
☐Mobile access networks
☐Assessment of private investment plansnote. If so, please provide details: …
☐Lack of awareness of the benefits brought by the subscription to broadband services. If so, please provide details.…
☐Ex post evaluation plans of similar predecessor schemes …
☐Retain existing subscriptions. Details:…
☐Businesses
☐Upgrade existing subscriptions. Details:…
☐Yes. If so, please indicate according to which criteria the aid measure is considered for ex post evaluation and provide the relevant information on the ex post evaluation plan described in section 8 of the Broadband Guidelines.…
☐No.
☐deployment of backhaul networksnote.
☐only backhaul
☐backhaul linked to the deployment of an access networknote
☐Other reasons. If so, please provide details.…
☐Counterfactual analysis demonstrating that the measure has positive effects compared to what would have happened without the aid …
☐Others. Details:…
☐Confirmation that the vouchers cannot be used for retaining existing subscriptions. Details:…
☐Direct investmentnote
☐Both of them
☐Public consultationnote. If so, please provide details: …
☐Concessionairenote
☐Assessment of the fulfilment of the step change requirementsnote. If so, please provide details: …
☐Other. If so, please provide details. …
☐Definition of wholesale access products, conditions and pricingnote. If so, please provide details: …
☐Resolution of disputes related to wholesale accessnote. If so, please provide details: …
☐Existing infrastructures subject to ex ante regulationnote. If so, please provide details: …
☐Definition of the clawback mechanism. If so, please provide details: …
1.4.Please explain how the aid measure fits with the national broadband strategy and the Union digital policy and environmental objectivesnote.…1.5.Please explain whether the reason justifying the aid measure isnote:1.6.Please explain the context of the aid measure (for example, current level of coverage of broadband networks in the Member State, current level of take-up of broadband services), indicating the sources of information provided.…1.7.Please confirm that all speeds mentioned in this notification are deemed to mean speeds under peak-time conditionsnote.☐Yes ☐No1.8.If available, please submit the following documents and provide a description of their content.2.SOCIAL VOUCHERS2.1.Please identify the particular categories of individual consumers targeted by the aid measure, specifying the financial circumstances that justify the granting of aid for social reasons (for example, low-income families, students, pupils, etc.) and the objective criteria used to identify eligible consumersnote.…2.2.Please provide an estimate of the number of consumers that could benefit from the aid measure.…2.3.Please identify the eligible service providers.…2.4.Please indicate the eligible services covered by the aid measure (for example, in terms of download speed, upload speed, etc.) and explain how your authorities identified such services.…2.5.Please specify how the vouchers will be used and provide specific detailsnote:2.6.Please list the eligible costs covered by the aid measurenote
(iii)If the State intervention concerns black areas, please confirm that the subsidised networks fulfil the following cumulative conditionsnote:
—They at least triple the download speed provided by the existing networks.
—They provide a download speed of at least 1 Gbps and an upload speed of at least 150 Mbps.
—They represent a significant new infrastructure investment bringing significant new capabilities to the market (for example, in terms of availability, capacity, speeds and competition).…
.
☐Yes ☐No
(v)Please confirm that the access obligations will be enforced irrespective of any change in ownership, management or operation of the subsidised networknote.☐Yes ☐No
(vi)Please explain whether the aid beneficiary and/or access seekers linked to the aid beneficiary are permitted to extend their networks into adjacent areas outside the target area using their own resourcesnote.☐Yes ☐NoIf yes, please confirm that:
—In the public consultation it was indicated that private extensions were permitted at a later stage and useful information regarding the potential coverage of such extensions was providednote.☐Yes ☐No
—The results of the public consultation do not show evidence of risks of significant distortions of competitionnote.☐Yes ☐No
—Please confirm that extensions into adjacent areas may only be carried out 2 years after the subsidised network enters into operation, where one of the following situations occursnote:
—in the public consultation, stakeholders demonstrate that the planned extension would risk entering an adjacent area which is already served by at least two independent networks providing speeds comparable to those of the State-funded network; or
—there is at least one network in the adjacent area providing speeds comparable to those of the subsidised network which entered into operation less than 5 years before the subsidised network enters into operationnote.☐Yes ☐No…
.
…
(iv)Backhaul networks. Please list the wholesale access products that the subsidised network must provide, taking into account that it must provide at least one active service and access to poles, masts, towers, ducts and dark fibrenote. Moreover, please confirm that the aid measure foresees the deployment of sufficient capacity for new infrastructure to ensure effective access under fair and non-discriminatory conditionsnote.…
(v)Wholesale access on the basis of reasonable demand. Should your authorities intend to limit the provision of certain wholesale access products to cases of reasonable demand from an access seeker, please:
—provide well-reasoned, objective and verifiable data and arguments (including cost calculations) proving that the provision of such products would disproportionately increase investment costs without delivering significant benefits in terms of increased competitionnote.
—confirm that the access seeker’s demand is considered reasonable if the access seeker provides a business plan that justifies the development of the product on the subsidised network and no comparable access product is already offered in the same geographic area by another undertaking at equivalent prices to those in more densely populated areasnote.☐Yes ☐No
—confirm that, if an access request is considered reasonable, the additional cost of meeting the access request must be borne by the aid beneficiarynote.☐Yes ☐No…
.
…2.7.Please indicate the maximum duration of the voucher (if any).
…2.8.Please indicate form and amount of the vouchers, specifying how such amount has been set and the percentage of the cost of subscription covered by the voucher.
…2.9.Please explain if and how the aid measure complies with the principle of technological neutralitynote.
…
2.10.
To demonstrate that the aid measure ensures equal treatment of all possible service providers and offer consumers the widest possible choice of suppliersnote, please confirm (providing relevant details) thatnote:
2.11.Please explain in detail the implementing procedure of the aid measure.
…
2.12.
Public consultationnote. Please provide the following information:
2.13.Please indicate whether additional safeguards to avoid possible misuse of social vouchers will be implemented. If so, please provide detailsnote.
…2.14.Please indicate whether the aid measure provides for specific rules concerning the management of the subscription, with regard, inter alia, to early termination of the subscription, possibility to migrate the subscription to another provider during the period covered by the voucher (if so, under which conditions), continuation of the subscription after the expiry of the voucher. If so, please provide details.
…3.CONNECTIVITY VOUCHERS
3.1.
Please indicate the type of end-users targeted by the measure.
3.2.Please explain the eligibility conditions for end-users to get connectivity vouchers.
…3.3.Please provide an estimate of the number of end-users that could benefit from the aid measure.
…3.4.Please identify the eligible service providers.
…3.5.Please indicate the eligible services covered by the aid measure (for example, in terms of download speed, upload speed, etc.) and explain how your authorities identified such services. In this regard, please indicate end-users’ needs capable of being addressed by connections providing the eligible services, submitting verifiable supporting evidence thereof (for example, consumer surveys, independent studies)note.
…
3.6.
Please specify how the vouchers will be used and provide specific details Moreover, please confirm that the vouchers cannot be used for retaining existing subscriptionsnote.
3.7.Please list the eligible costs covered by the aid measurenote.
…3.8.Please indicate form and amount of vouchers, specifying how such amount has been set and the percentage of the costs of subscription covered by the voucher)note.
…3.9.Please explain if and how the aid measure complies with the principle of technological neutralitynote.
…
3.10.
To demonstrate that the aid measure ensures equal treatment of all possible service providers and offer consumers the widest possible choice of suppliers, please confirm (providing relevant details) thatnote:
3.11.Please explain in detail the implementing procedure of the aid measure.
…
3.12.
Public consultation. Please provide the following informationnote:
3.13.Please indicate whether additional safeguards to avoid possible misuse of connectivity vouchers will be implemented. If so, please provide detailsnote.
…3.14.Please indicate whether the aid measure provides for specific rules concerning the management of the subscription, with regard, inter alia, to early termination of the subscription, possibility to migrate the subscription to another provider during the period covered by the voucher (if so, under which conditions), continuation of the subscription after the expiry of the voucher. If so, please provide details.
…3.15.Please identify the economic activities that will be facilitated by the aid measure through the increase of connectivity and the access to performant broadband services, and explain how the development of those activities is supportednote.
…3.16.Please provide evidence for the incentive effect of the aid measurenote.
…3.17.Please confirm that the aid measure, the conditions attached to it (including its financing method where that method forms an integral part of the aid) or the activity it finances do not entail any violation of provisions or general principles of Union law.
☐Yes ☐No. In this case, please provide explanations.
…3.18.Please explain why alternative measures to State aid (for example, administrative and regulatory measures, market-based instruments, loans, tax measures) are not capable of addressing the objective(s) of the aid measurenote.
…3.19.Please submit a market assessment containing: (i) an assessment of the risk that the aid measure gives a disproportionate advantage – at the retail and/or at the wholesale level – to some providers to the detriment of others, possibly reinforcing (local) market dominance; (ii) an assessment of the actual need to implement a connectivity voucher by comparing the situation in the intervention area(s) with the situation in other areas of the Member State or the Union; (iii) an analysis of the trends in take-up of eligible services by end-usersnote.
…3.20.Please indicate if any of the eligible provider of broadband services is vertically integrated and has a retail market share above 25 %.
☐Yes ☐No.3.21.In case the answer to the previous question is positive, please confirm that any vertically integrated provider of broadband services which has a retail market share above 25 %, will offer, on the corresponding wholesale access market, wholesale access products on the basis of which any access seeker will be able to provide the eligible services under open, transparent and non-discriminatory conditions.
☐Yes ☐No3.22.Please indicate the duration of the aid measure and the period of validity of the vouchers for individual end-usernote.
…3.23.Please explain what potential negative effects on competition and trade the aid measure may have and what elements in the design of the measure could minimize those risks.
…4.OTHER INFORMATION (APPLICABLE TO BOTH SOCIAL AND CONNECTIVITY VOUCHERS)4.1.Please explain the role played by the NRA in the design, implementation and monitoring of the aid measure.
…4.2.Please report the opinion of the NRA on the aid measure (if available).
…4.3.Please report the opinion of the National Competition Authority on the aid measure (if available).
…
4.4.
Transparency.
4.5.Reporting. Please confirm that your authorities will submit to the Commission (i) annual reports in respect of each measure approved under the Broadband Guidelines, and (ii) a report every two years containing key information on the aid measure approved under the Broadband Guidelines, in accordance with Annex III to the same Broadband Guidelinesnote.
…4.6.Monitoring. Please confirm that your authorities will maintain – for 10 years from the date of award of the aid – detailed records regarding all aid measures, which contain all information necessary to establish that all the compatibility conditions set out in the Broadband Guidelines are fulfilled, and that it commits to provide them to the Commission upon requestnote.
…
4.7.
Please indicate whether the aid measure is considered for ex post evaluation plan.
4.8.Please indicate any other information relevant for the assessment of the aid measure under the Broadband Guidelines or any other information that is relevant from the point of view of Union competition and internal market rules.
…
4.9.
Please indicate whether this supplementary information sheet contains confidential information which should not be disclosed to third partiesnote.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION SHEET ON STATE AID FOR THE DEPLOYMENT OF BROADBAND NETWORK
This supplementary information sheet should be used for notifications of aid for the deployment of broadband networks covered by the Commission Guidelines on State aid for broadband networksnote(“Broadband Guidelines”).
1.GENERAL INFORMATION1.1.Please provide a detailed description of the aid measure and of its objectives.
…
1.2.
Please identify the type of broadband networknote supported by the aid measure.
1.3.Please explain how the aid measure fits with the national broadband strategy and the Union digital policy and environmental objectivesnote.
…1.4.Please confirm that all speeds mentioned in this notification are deemed to mean speeds under peak-time conditionsnote.
☐Yes ☐No1.5.Please indicate the time horizonnote of the aid measure and how it has been determined.
…
1.6.
Please indicate the investment model through which the aid measure is implemented.
2.FACILITATION OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF AN ECONOMIC ACTIVITY2.1.Please identify the economic activities that will be facilitated by the aid measure and explain how the development of those activities is supportednote.
…2.2.Please confirm that the aid measure, the conditions attached to it (including its financing method where that method forms an integral part of the aid) or the activity it finances do not entail any violation of provisions or general principles of Union lawnote.
☐Yes ☐No. In this case, please provide explanations …3.POSITIVE EFFECTS OF THE AID3.1.Please describe whether and, if so, how the aid measure will bring about positive effects (for example, in terms of reduction of digital dividenote, correction of social or regional inequalities, equity, sustainability goalsnote, lower prices and better choice for end-users, higher quality and innovation, completion of the Digital Single Marketnote)note.
…4.MARKET FAILURE AS REGARDS FIXED ACCESS NETWORKS4.1.Please indicate the performance in terms of download speed (and, if applicable, of upload speed and other parameters) that the subsidised networks will have to providenote.
…4.2.Please indicate end-users’ current and future needs capable of being addressed by fixed networks providing the performance mentioned at point 4.1 (and not by the existing fixed networks), submitting verifiable supporting evidence thereof (for example, consumer surveys, independent studies)note.
…
4.3.
Mapping exercisenote. Please provide the following information.
4.4.
If the aid measure targets areas in which at least two independent networks providing at least 100 Mbps download speed under peak time conditions are present or credibly plannednote, please clarify if:
4.5.
Public consultation. Please provide the following information:
4.6.Please indicate the final scope of the aid measure in terms of the size of the intervention area and its population density.
…5.MARKET FAILURE AS REGARDS MOBILE ACCESS NETWORKS5.1.Please indicate the performance in terms of download speed (and, if applicable, of upload speed and other parameters) that the subsidised networks will have to providenote.
…5.2.Please indicate end-users’ current and future needs capable of being addressed by mobile networks providing the performance mentioned at point 5.1 (and not by the existing mobile networks), submitting verifiable supporting evidence thereof (for example, consumer surveys, independent surveys)note.
…5.3.Please confirm that the aid measure cannot be used for the fulfilment of any legal obligations (for example, obligations linked to the rights to use spectrum)note.
…5.4.Please indicate whether the aid measure targets areas where there is already at least one existing or credibly planned mobile networknote capable of addressing identified end-users’ needs.
☐Yes ☐No
If yes, please demonstrate (with the support of verifiable evidence): (a) why such network is considered insufficient to provide end-users with sufficient quality of services to satisfy their evolving needs; and (b) if and how the aid measure will provide such quality of services, thus bringing about a material improvement that the market cannot delivernote.
…
5.5.
Mapping exercisenote. Please provide the following information:
5.6.
Public consultation. Please provide the following information:
6.MARKET FAILURE AS REGARDS BACKHAUL NETWORKS
6.1.
Please clarify whether the subsidised backhaul networks support:
6.2.Please indicate the technical characteristics of the subsidised backhaul networks, including their desired level of performance, reliability, capacity or dimensioningnote.
…6.3.Please explain the expected development of fixed or mobile access networks based on current and future end-users’ needs and why the existing or planned backhaul capacity cannot cope with such expected development, submitting verifiable supporting evidence thereof (for example, independent surveys)note.
…6.4.Please clarify whether State intervention is considered necessary, because existing backhaul networks provide a suboptimal combination of service quality and pricesnote.
…
6.5.
Mapping exercisenote. Please provide the following information:
6.6.
Public consultation. Please provide the following information:
7.APPROPRIATENESS OF THE AID AS A POLICY INSTRUMENT7.1.Please explain why alternative, less distortive measures to State aid (for example, administrative measures, regulatory measures, market-based instruments, loans, tax measures, etc.) are not capable of addressing the objective(s) of the aid measure and the identified market failurenote.
…
7.2.
Step-changenote.
8.PROPORTIONALITY OF THE AID
8.1.
Competitive selection procedure.
8.2.Technological neutrality. Please explain if and how the aid measure complies with the principle of technological neutralitynote.
…
8.3.
Use of existing infrastructure. Please provide the following information:
8.4.
Wholesale access for third parties to the subsidised networks.
8.5.
Clawback. Please indicate whether a claw-back mechanism will be applied to the aid measure:
☐Yesnote ☐No
If not, please explain why: …
If yes, please provide the following information:
8.6.Accounting separation. Please confirm that the aid beneficiary must ensure accounting separation so that the costs for deployment and operation, as well as the revenues from the exploitation of the subsidised network are clearly identifiednote.
☐Yes ☐No9.ROLE OF THE NATIONAL AUTHORITIES
9.1.
Please explain the role played by the NRA in the design, implementation and monitoring of the aid measurenote. Inter alia, please clarify whether it was involved on:
9.2.Please provide the opinion of the NRA on the aid measurenote (if available).
…9.3.Please indicate whether the NRA issued guidelines on, among others, carrying out market analysis and definitions of wholesale access products and pricing. If so, please provide the content of the guidelines and clarify whether they take into account the relevant regulatory framework and recommendations issued by the Commissionnote.
…9.4.Please provide the opinion of the National Competition Authority on the aid measurenote (if available).
…9.5.Please indicate whether the Broadband Competence Office has been involved in the design of the aid measurenote.
…10.TRANSPARENCY, REPORTING AND MONITORING OF THE AID
10.1.
Transparency.
10.2.Reporting. Please confirm that your authorities will submit to the Commission (i) annual reports in respect of each measure approved under the Broadband Guidelines, and (ii) a report every two years containing key information on the aid measure approved under the Broadband Guidelines, in accordance with Annex III to the same Broadband Guidelinesnote.
…10.3.Monitoring. Please confirm that your authorities will maintain – for 10 years from the date of award of the aid – detailed records regarding all aid measures, which contain all information necessary to establish that all the compatibility conditions set out in the Broadband Guidelines are fulfilled, and that it commits to provide them to the Commission upon requestnote.
…11.NEGATIVE EFFECTS ON COMPETITION AND TRADE11.1.Please explain what potential negative effects on competition and trade the aid measure may have (for example, potential to cause crowding out of private investmentsnote or reinforcement of a dominant position) and what elements in the design of the measure could minimize those risksnote.