Judgment_paragraph 26 · Anglo Austrian AAB AG, formerly Anglo Austrian AAB Bank AG and Belegging-Maatschappij 'Far-East' BV v European Central Bank (T-797/19) · GlobalLawDB
Anglo Austrian AAB AG, formerly Anglo Austrian AAB Bank AG and Belegging-Maatschappij 'Far-East' BV v European Central Bank (T-797/19)
26After noting that the type, number and frequency of the binding supervisory measures, such as formal orders, that had to be issued by the FMA emphasised the severity and long-lasting nature of the breaches found, the ECB cited the following in particular in support of its conclusions:– the report of the Oesterreichische Nationalbank (Austrian national bank) on the occasion of an on-site inspection on 22 January 2010 during which the bank had found substantial deficiencies in AAB Bank’s anti-money laundering framework;– the report of the FMA following its on-site inspection on 11 July 2013 finding 38 deficiencies or breaches of the legislation on combating money laundering and terrorist financing;– the report of 24 March 2015 finding irregularities in 18 out of 20 test cases whose findings were subsequently confirmed by a definitive court decision;– the FMA’s formal order of 18 August 2015 by which it instructed AAB Bank to apply the 2008 anti-money laundering provisions to all its customers;– the sanction imposed by the FMA on 14 September 2016 for individual and systemic breaches of the legal requirements relating to the combating of money laundering and terrorist financing;– the judgment of 7 February 2019 of the Bundesverwaltungsgericht (Federal Administrative Court, Austria) under reference W230 2138107-1/37E, confirming the FMA’s sanction of 14 September 2016 although reducing its amount;– the order of 15 May 2019 of the Verwaltungsgerichtshof (Supreme Administrative Court, Austria) under reference Ro 2019/02/0006-3, dismissing AAB Bank’s appeal against the judgment of 7 February 2019 of the Bundesverwaltungsgericht (Federal Administrative Court);– the judgment of 23 February 2017 of the Landesgericht für Zivilrechtssachen Wien (Regional Civil Court, Vienna, Austria) under reference 33 Cg 716s 18, in which the court stated that ‘in the case of nine back-to-back credit transactions with other banks examined in detail by the FMA or the external auditors, it was found that those nine transactions involved serious breaches of the applicable provisions’;– the FMA’s formal order of 24 October 2018 finding that AAB Bank had committed numerous breaches of the legislation in its relationship with Meinl Bank Antigua Ltd, in particular the fact that, after announcing that the accounts of Meinl Bank Antigua had been frozen, AAB Bank allowed transfers of EUR 19.5 million to be made from its main account and had no appropriate documentation about its business relationship;– the FMA’s report of 17 January 2019 drawn up after the 2018 on-site inspection (‘the FMA report on the fourth inspection’) finding 22 deficiencies or breaches of legal provisions including a number concerning Meinl Bank Antigua;– the procedure initiated by the FMA on 7 June 2019 to restore legal compliance in relation to the remaining 15 findings in its report on the fourth inspection, on which AAB Bank had submitted comments that were taken into account in the contested decision in the finding that, in essence, the majority of the breaches were still ongoing;– AAB Bank’s audit reports and a number of facts gathered during the administrative procedure.