Judgment_paragraph 391 · Front populaire pour la libération de la Saguia el-Hamra et du Rio de oro (Front Polisario) v Council of the European Union (T-279/19) · GlobalLawDB
Front populaire pour la libération de la Saguia el-Hamra et du Rio de oro (Front Polisario) v Council of the European Union (T-279/19)
391It follows from all of the foregoing that, in adopting the contested decision, the Council did not take sufficient account of all the relevant factors concerning the situation in Western Sahara and wrongly took the view that it had a margin of appreciation to decide whether it was necessary to comply with the requirement that the people of that territory must express their consent to the application of the agreement at issue, as a third party to that agreement, in accordance with the Court’s interpretation of the principle of the relative effect of treaties in relation to the principle of self-determination. In particular, first, the Council and the Commission were wrong to take the view that the current situation in that territory did not make it possible to ascertain the existence of that consent and, in particular, to do so through the agency of the applicant. Second, in taking the view that the consultation process conducted by the Commission and by the EEAS, which was not intended to obtain such consent and was not addressed to ‘representative bodies’ of that people, had made it possible to comply with the principle of the relative effect of treaties as interpreted by the Court in paragraph 106 of Council v Front Polisario, the Council was mistaken as to both the scope of that consultation and the scope of the requirement set in that paragraph. Third, the Council was wrong to consider that it could rely on the letter of 29 January 2002 from the UN Legal Counsel to substitute that requirement with the criteria purportedly established by that letter. It follows that this part of the third plea is well founded and is capable of leading to annulment of the contested decision.