130Furthermore, at the hearing the applicant observed, first, that the Court of Justice had recognised the penal nature of fines in competition matters in Case C-199/92 PHüls v Commission [1999] ECR I-4287; the judgment of 22 May 2008 in Case C-266/06 PEvonik Degussa v Commission and Council, not published in the ECR; and Case C-45/08Spector Photo Group and Van Raemdonck [2009] ECR I-12073, and, second, that the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, which entered into force on 1 December 2009, was of immediate application in disputes pending before this Court. In that connection, the applicant maintains that its fundamental rights have been breached, since the Commission wrongly considered that ‘it is the undertaking, and not each of the legal persons taken separately, that must benefit from fundamental rights’.