Judgment_paragraph 118 · Arkema France, Altuglas International SA and Altumax Europe SAS v European Commission (T-217/06) · GlobalLawDB
Arkema France, Altuglas International SA and Altumax Europe SAS v European Commission (T-217/06)
law://eu/cjeu/2006/t-217-06/para_118@2026-11-19
Key facts
Court
General Court · Fourth Chamber
Case
T-217/06 · ECLI:EU:T:2011:251
Decided
7 Jun 2011
Procedure
Action for annulment
Applicants
Arkema France; Altuglas International SA; Altumax Europe SAS; represented initially by A. Winckler, S. Sorinas Jimeno and P. Geffriaud, and subsequently by S. Sorinas Jimeno and E. Jégou, lawyers
118In the fifth place, with regard to the argument that no document in the file shows that Arkema received an instruction or recommendation from Elf Aquitaine or Total concerning the commercial policy on the methacrylates market, this on its own is irrelevant, since Arkema’s independence must not be assessed solely with regard to that market. Moreover, as has already been held, the fact that it is not apparent from the documents in the file that the parent company gave instructions to its subsidiary cannot prove that such instructions did not exist (see, to that effect, Lafarge v Commission, paragraph 113 above, paragraph 545).