15In reply to the applicant's argument that the defendant did not, in the decision of 20 January 1981, state its position with regard to applying the fourth paragraph of Article 77 of the Staff Regulations, the defendant states that it had already ruled, in Decision No 157/81 A, implicitly but clearly, that that provision did not apply to the calculation of the applicant's entitlement to invalidity pension. In this connection the defendant stresses that Decision No 157/81 A states in paragraph 5 that the minimum pension is equal to ‘120% of the basic salary D 4/17’ that is the amount specified in the fifth paragraph of Article 78 of the Staff Regulations. According to the defendant, the decision in question therefore, indirectly but necessarily, precluded the application of the fourth paragraph of Article 77 of the Staff Regulations. Consequently the defendant, referring to the judgment of the Court of Justice in Cases 118/82 to 123/82 Celant v Commission [1983] ECR 2995, argues that it is clearly that decision which constituted notification of the final calculation of the applicant's pension entitlement and started time running for bringing an action. It concludes therefore that the action is out of time.