Judgment_paragraph 33 · Antonio Devillez, Henk Bunnik, Jerry Cadogan and Emile Kill v European Parliament (T-46/90) · GlobalLawDB
Antonio Devillez, Henk Bunnik, Jerry Cadogan and Emile Kill v European Parliament (T-46/90)
law://eu/cjeu/1990/t-46-90/para_33@2026-11-16
33In order to establish the administration's failure to act, the applicants allege that, as an employer, the Parliament is bound not only to observe Council Directive 86/188/EEC of 12 May 1986 on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to noise at work (OJ 1986 L 137, p. 28), but also the rules for the protection of workers in force in the place of employment, in this case the general regulations in force in Luxembourg on safety at work. However, as early as 27 July 1989, Dr De Wilde sent Mrs Gomez de Enterria the results of the measurements of the noise levels in the print shop. The applicants point out that Dr De Wilde found in his report that the noise level in the print shop reached 90.1 decibels; he stated that for a rotary press, a noise level of 85 decibels must be regarded as cause for concern and a noise level of 90 decibels as the danger level for the onset of occupational deafness; he stated that the frequencies recorded were ‘on the border-line of the danger zone for the human ear’; finally he proposed several measures for reducing the noise level of the rotary press and a compulsory audiogram during the annual medical check-up. However, no action was taken on those proposals.