law://eu/cjeu/1983/c-242-83/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-17In its observations, the Fund starts from the premise that, although the two questions purport to deal with separate subjects, only one issue is raised. That issue is simply whether Article 51 of the EEC Treaty empowered the Council to issue regulations which have the effect of conferring upon migrant workers, at the expense of the authorities of a Member State, direct entitlement to family allowances which are not payable under the law of that Member State. The essential question, therefore, concerns the extent of the powers conferred on the Council by Article 51 of the EEC Treaty.The first part of the Fund's observations explains in detail precisely what is new about the factors upon which the Fund — followed cautiously by the Cour de Cassation — relies as the basis for asking the Court of Justice to reconsider an earlier preliminary ruling and to depart from its previous decision. In the Fund's view, the new and decisive aspect of the circumstances of this case is to be seen in the light of earlier judgments of the Court of Justice on the matter at issue. According to the Fund, the judgment in Laterza, to which the judgment of 25 September 1981 of the Cour de Travail, Mons, expressly refers, is the only ruling of the Court of Justice on the interpretation of Article 77 (2) (b) (i) of Regulation No 1408/71; that judgment merely interprets that provision in the light, first, of the aims of the EEC Treaty and, secondly, of the recitals in the preamble to Regulation No 1408/71 and, more specifically, of the seventh and eighth recitals. In the Fund's view that judgment does not consider the question of the limits to which the powers conferred on the Council by Article 51 of the EEC Treaty are subject or the possibility that the provision at issue might be invalid if the interpretation given to it disregarded those limits. Subsequently, the Fund reviews the decisions of the Court relating to Regulation No 3/58, as amended by Regulation No 1/64, although it acknowledges that any reference to the various solutions adopted in conformity with those instruments must be made with caution. Perusal of the judgments of 17 June 1970 in Case 3/70 (Beninato (née Di Bella), [1970] ECR 415), of 13 July 1976 in Case 19/76 (Triebes, [1976] ECR 1243) and of 13 October 1976 in Case 32/76 (Saieva, [1976] ECR 1523) does not provide a clear answer to the question raised in this case. Finally, the Fund reviews the judgments relating to the implementation of Regulation No 1408/71, that is to say, first, the judgment of 6 May 1979 in Case 100/78 (Rossi, [1979] ECR 831), and then the judgments of 22 May 1980 in Case 143/79 (Walsh, [1980] ECR 1639), 9 July 1980 in Case 807/79 (Gravina, [1980] ECR 2205) and 15 September 1983 in Case 279/82 (Jerzak, [1983] ECR 2603), and concludes that those judgments also fail to clarify the extent of the powers conferred on the Council by Article 51 of the EEC Treaty. As far as the Fund is concerned, no doubt can remain that new factors have emerged justifying a reexamination of the interpretation of Article 77 (2) (b) (i) of Regulation No 1408/71.As regards the substance of the question concerning the extent of the powers conferred on the Council by Article 51 of the EEC Treaty, the Fund starts from the premise that Article 51 is intended essentially to empower the Council to make arrangements to secure for migrant workers and their dependants aggregation, for the purpose of acquiring and retaining the right to national social security benefits, of insurance periods (Article 51 (a)) and the payment of benefits to persons resident in the territories of Member States (Article 51 (b)). Furthermore, the arrangements to be made pursuant to Article 51 of the EEC Treaty are left to the Council's discretion, subject solely to the proviso that the Council may not replace the national schemes by a single system and should (and hence certainly may) depart from national law with regard to two specific matters, namely: (a) the calculation of insurance periods and (b) the actual payment of benefits in the territories of all the Member States. In the Fund's view, any regulation which fails to comply with these requirements should be regarded as invalid.Accordingly, the Fund considers it appropriate to examine the following two questions:(1) Does Article 51 of the EEC Treaty require the Council to adopt rules whereby a recipient who is not resident in the territory of a Member State retains entitlement to benefits payable under the legislation of that State, even if that legislation imposes, as a condition for payment, the requirement that recipients are to be resident in the territory of that State and even if the legislation of the State in which the recipient is resident also entitles him to similar benefits?(2) Does Article 51 of the EEC Treaty authorize the Council to adopt such rules?As regards the first question, the Fund observes that the Court has held that the aims of Articles 48 to 51 of the EEC Treaty included the (negative) objective of not depriving migrant workers or their dependants of the benefit of a part of the legislation of a Member State, a finding which led the Court to decide that the rule against overlapping benefits should be applied only partially, that is to say, where an allowance which ceases to be paid in one Member State is greater than the allowance that is payable in another. It is on this precise point that the Fund asks the Court to reconsider its position on the ground that, where an instrument confers powers and itself enumerates the aims that the legislative authority concerned (the Council in this instance) is required to pursue, those aims alone, as they are set out, should be taken into account for the purpose of interpreting the instrument in question. Accordingly, the only aims which the Council is required to pursue are the two set out in Article 51 (b), which is the relevant provision in this case, the only aim that it requires the Council to pursue is that of making arrangements whereby migrant workers and their dependants retain entitlement to the payment of benefits payable under the national legislation, even though the recipients reside in the territory of another Member State.The Fund goes on to draw attention to the differences between the separate circumstances intended to be covered by Article 77 (2) (a) and Article 77 (2) (b) of Regulation No 1408/71. The first of those provisions, which is not criticized by the Fund, embodies the Council's logical reaction to its duty to make sure that where entitlement to a benefit exists under the legislation of only one Member State, it cannot be jeopardized (as a result of its being suppressed or suspended) merely because the recipient transfers his residence to the territory of another Member State — even where the legislation of the recipient's Member State of origin provides, as a precondition for entitlement to, or for the actual payment of, benefits, that the recipient must be resident in its own territory. However, as far as Article 77 (2) (b) is concerned, the Fund maintains that, whilst it is true that the general aims of Article 48 to 51 of the EEC Treaty certainly include the desire to ensure that migrant worker's rights are retained, as a matter of principle, irrespective of the workers' movements within the Community, it is none the less true that Article 51 (b) defined the aim that the Council is required to pursue in precise terms. That aim consists solely in securing the actual payment of benefits where they are payable under the legislation of a given Member State and would, in principle, be lost in the event of the recipient's moving within the Community. Where two bodies of legislation apply and a choice is to be made between them to avoid overlapping benefits, Article 51 (b) in no way precludes the Council from making a straightforward election. So the Fund's first question must definitely be answered in the negative, since Article 51 (b) of the EEC Treaty certainly does not require the Council to make a choice combining two bodies of legislation so as to enable workers to continue to enjoy the benefit of the most favourable legislation. By providing for the actual payment of the benefits payable by the Member State in which the worker resides — and the Council did no more than that according to the Fund's interpretation of Article 77 (2) (b) (i) of Regulation No 1408/71 — the Council has not therefore failed to comply with the precise objectives that it is required to pursue under Article 51 (b) of the EEC Treaty.As regards its second question, the Fund starts by expressing doubts about the proposition that the Council — which is expressly authorized to waive a residence clause where its implementation would have the effect of removing entitlement to social security benefits payable in a Member State and, in the absence of any entitlement in another Member State, of totally removing any entitlement to the social security benefits in question — has sufficient discretion to decide that where the legislation of more than one State applies concurrently the provision against overlapping benefits will be put into effect partially and the right to the “difference” at issue in this case will be left intact. The Fund considers that the provisions of Article 51 of the EEC Treaty essentially constitute a device — as the Court has already pointed out — for identifying the applicable national law, a kind of rule of private international law within the Community legal order. So once the legislation of a particular Member State has been declared to be applicable as a result of the application of the “renvoi rule” embodied in the Community regulation adopted pursuant to Article 51 of the EEC Treaty, that legislation should be applied as it stands, together with all the conditions for its implementation, including the residence requirement. Accordingly, the Council is authorized to waive a residence clause laid down by national law solely in the eventuality expressly provided for in Article 51 of the EEC Treaty (to secure actual payment of benefits that would otherwise be forfeited as a result of the recipient's moving within the Community) and not in other circumstances (concurrent application of laws providing for benefits of differing amounts). In conclusion, the Fund considers that, as worded at present, Article 77 (2) (b) (i) of Regulation No 1408/71 is not intended to ensure that rights arising in the State of origin are retained as regards the portion of benefits in excess of the level of benefits payable in the State of residence, in the absence of a provision to that effect in the relevant national legislation. It would be appropriate to construe Article 77 (2) (b) (i) in that way, contrary to its literal meaning, only if it were considered that Article 51 (b) of the EEC Treaty required the Council to ensure that that objective was achieved and if it were therefore considered that the provision in question had to be interpreted in that way in order to preserve its validity under Article 51 (b) of the Treaty. The Fund. does not consider that Article 51 of the EEC Treaty lays down any such requirement.The Fund considers that Article 77 (2) (b) (i) of Regulation No 1408/71 must be construed in accordance with the natural meaning of its wording, and therefore to the effect that once the right to the benefits provided for in Article 77 (1) arises under the laws of several Member States, the benefits are to be granted in accordance with the legislation of the State in whose territory the recipient resides and in accordance with that legislation alone. Moreover, if there is no provision to that effect in that legislation there is no right to the difference between the benefit paid in this way and the — ex hypothesi — higher benefit payable under the law of another Member State.Consequently, Article 77 (2) (b) (i) of Regulation No 1408/71 should, despite its express terms, be interpreted as having the effect of maintaining the application of part of the legislation of a Member State other than that in which the recipient resides only if it is held that Article 51 (b) of the EEC Treaty requires such an interpretation, and this, in the Fund's view, is manifestly not the case.As regards the validity of Article 77 (2) (b) (i) of Regulation No 1408/71, the Fund considers that, if it is accepted that Article 51 (b) of the EEC Treaty merely authorizes the Council to make arrangements to secure actual payment of the benefits, it inevitably follows that, where entitlement to benefits arises under the legislation of several Member States, the Council has no power other than that of designating, by means of a provision designed to prevent the overlapping of benefits, the national legislation which will be exclusively applicable. It also follows that the Council may designate the legislation of a particular Member State as applicable, even if the residence clause contained therein is not satisfied, only in the event that, were that national legislation not applied, the recipient would be completely deprived of any benefit. Although the opposite interpretation has previously been adopted by the Court, the effect of that interpretation is, in the Fund's view, to render Article 77 (2) (b) (i) of Regulation No 1408/71 invalid under Article 51 (b) of the Treaty.In conclusion, the Fund proposes that the questions submitted by the Court of Cassation of the Kingdom of Belgium should be answered as follows:
“Article 51 (b) of the Treaty must be interpreted as merely requiring the Council of Ministers to make arrangements to secure the actual payment of benefits to persons resident in the territories of the Member States and, exclusively for that purpose, to override the laws of Member States which have the effect of depriving of those benefits persons resident in the territory of another Member State. Consequently, Article 77 (2) (b) (i) of Regulation No 1408/71 must be interpreted as meaning that, where a worker receives pensions under the laws of several Member States, the benefits are to be granted in accordance with the legislation of the State within whose territory he resides, irrespective of which State that is — provided that entitlement to one of the benefits arises under the legislation of that State — and to the exclusion of any benefit or part of a benefit that is payable by virtue of the legislation of another State.”
“Article 51 (b) of the Treaty must be interpreted as not authorizing the Council of Ministers to establish a system whereby entitlement to family benefits payable by the State in whose territory the recipient of an invalidity pension resides does not take away the right to higher benefits awarded previously by another Member State or at least to a supplement equal to the difference between the two amounts, thus causing a right to accrue to the recipient which was not created by the legislation of either of the Member States. Consequently, if it were necessary to interpret Article 77 (2) (b) (i) of Regulation No 1408/71 in such a way as to create such a system, that Article would not be valid in the light of Article 51 (b) of the Treaty.”In his observations submitted to the Court, Salvatore Patteri maintains that by transferring his residence to Italy he has not forfeited his entitlement to family benefits previously awarded in Belgium, and that he ought to receive — in accordance with the case-law of the Court of Justice — the difference between the benefits paid under the Belgian scheme and those paid under the Italian scheme. In his view, Article 77 of Regulation No 1408/71 governs the grant of family benefits as follows :(a) Where the migrant worker is the recipient of a pension from one Member State alone, family benefits are to be granted to him in accordance with the legislation of that State (Article 77 (2) (a));(b) Where the migrant worker is the recipient of pensions from several Member States, family benefits are to be granted to him, in order of priority, in accordance with the legislation of the Member State in which he resides (Article 77 (2) (b) (i)) or, in the alternative, in accordance with the national legislation under which he has completed the longest period of insurance (Article 77 (2) (b) (ii)).To determine which law is applicable and, hence, the institution responsible for payment of the benefits, regard should be had to the situation of the insured person when the event which created the right to the benefits occurred (in this case, award of the invalidity pension). A change of residence merely creates a conflict of laws which must be settled in accordance with the relevant case-law of the Court of Justice (judgments in Case 733/79, Laterza, Case 807/79
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.