law://eu/cjeu/1983/c-128-83/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-16The Direction Régionale des Affaires Sanitaires et Sociales de Haute-Normandie submits that paragraph 1 of Article 71 refers to unemployed persons who, during their last employment, were residing in the territory of a Member State other than the competent State. In the present case, Mrs Guyot's last employment was in Germany until 30 June 1977. On that date and until September 1977, she lived in German territory. Germany is therefore both the State of residence during the period of the last employment, and the State of the competent institution since Mrs Guyot registered as unemployed in her country of origin from 1 August 1977. The Direction Régionale submits that those factors alone suffice to show that Mrs Guyot does not fulfil the conditions set out in Article 71 (1) (b) (ii) but that she falls within the exception laid down by that article in the following terms :“However, if such worker has become entitled to benefits at the expense of the competent institution of the Member State to whose legislation he was last subject [in the present case Germany], he shall receive benefits under the provisions of Article 69” of Regulation No 1408/71.The Commission examines the scope of Articles 69 and 71 in the light of the judgments of the Court of Justice on the subject: judgment of 10 July 1975 in Case 27/75 Bonaffini and Others v Istituto Nationale della Previdenza Sociale [1975] ECR 971; judgment of 23 November 1976 in Case 40/76 Kermaschek v Bundesanstalt für Arbeit [1976] ECR 1669; judgment of 15 December 1976 in Case 39/76 Metaalnijverheid v Mouthaan [1976] ECR 1901; judgment of 17 February 1977 in Case 76/76 Di Paolo v Office National de l'Emploi [1977] ECR 315; judgment of 1 December 1977 in Case 66/77 Kuyken v Rijksdienst voor Arbeidsvoorziening [1977] ECR 2311; judgment of 20 March 1979 in Case 139/78 Coccioli v Bundesanstalt för Arbeit [1979] ECR 991; judgment of 19 June 1980 in Joined Cases 41, 121 and 796/79 Testa and Others v Bundesanstalt für Arbeit [1980] ECR 1979; judgment of 27 May 1982 in Case 227/81 Aubin v Unedic and Assedie [1982] ECR 1991. The following principles may be discerned.Normally a worker who is unemployed claims unemployment benefits in the State where he was last employed. Article 67, which makes provision for the aggregation of periods of insurance or employment, makes such aggregation subject to the condition that the person concerned should have completed lastly either periods of insurance or periods of employment, as the case may be, in accordance with the provisions of the legislation under which the benefits are claimed.However, for certain categories of workers Article 71 (1) provides an exception to that requirement. Workers who, during their last employment, retained close links with a country other than that where they were employed, namely the country where they were settled or where they habitually resided, have a choice: they may either apply to the unemployment benefit scheme in the State in which they were last employed or claim benefits in the State in which they reside. The worker makes that choice, in particular, by making himself available to the employment office of the State from which he is claiming benefits (see paragraph 19 of the decision in Aubin cited above).The Commission submits that Article 71 (1) (a) (ii) and (b) (ii) provide an exception to the general rule set out in Article 67 and are therefore to be interpreted narrowly (see paragraph 13 of the decision in Di Paolo cited above).Article 69 is intended to make it easier for an unemployed person to look for employment by maintaining his right to benefits for three months, thus freeing him, during that period, from the requirement of making himself available to the employment office of the competent State and therefore being subject to any checks organized in that State (see Coccioli judgment, cited above).The Commission is of the view that in the present case the respondent in the main action falls exclusively within the general rule set out in Article 67. Her last employment was in the Federal Republic of Germany, the country where she also resided. She did not settle in France until after having resigned from her employment. She could therefore have continued to receive benefits from Germany for three months pursuant to Article 69.The Commission points out a misunderstanding on the part of the Cour d'Appel which misconstrued the expression “the competent State”. The Cour d'Appel took the view that France was the competent State, because the competent institution from which benefits had been claimed was in its territory.The Commission observes that the competent State concerned in Article 71 is the State of last employment envisaged by Anicie 67. This is evident from the combined effect of the definitions in Article 1 (o) and (q) and of Articles 13 and 67 of the regulation.Mrs Guyot is therefore entitled to receive German benefits for three months, and to continue to receive them on condition that she returns to Germany or that she obtains an extension of the time-limit. She was at no time entitled to French unemployment benefits, on the other hand, since her last employment was not in France.Unemployment benefits may be paid to unemployed persons who are not in the Member State where they were last employed in two cases only:For a period of three months, subject to the conditions laid down by Article 69;For an unlimited period, provided that the worker was already resident in another Member State during his last employment (Article 71).The Commission points out that the unlimited retention of entitlement to unemployment benefits in the case of a change of residence after the cessation of employment is not provided for by the Community rules as they now stand. The reason is that at the time Regulation No 1408/71 was drawn up, the Community was experiencing a period of economic prosperity and unemployed persons could thus find work reasonably quickly. The need to retain the right to unemployment benefits outside the country of last employment had not yet made itself felt. The change in the situation has prompted the Commission to submit a proposal to the Council for a regulation amending the original regulation (proposal submitted by the Commission to the Council on 18.6.1980, Official Journal, C 169 of 9.7.1980, p. 22).The Commission's analysis is unaffected by the fact that the respondent in the main action received French unemployment benefits granted by the French institutions without reference to the criterion of last employment laid down by Anicie 67. Article 25 (2) is not applicable in the present case, inasmuch as the respondent in the main action is not covered by Article 71 (1) (b) (ii).In conclusion, with regard to the reply to be given to the question submitted by the Cour d'Appel, Rouen, the Commission recalls that that court considers France as being the competent State, although it has correctly noted the fact which prevents Mrs Guyot from relying upon Article 71 (1) (b) (ii), and therefore, by the same token, on Article 25 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71, namely the fact that during her last employment she did not reside in a State other than the State where she was employed.It therefore suggests that the question submitted by the Cour d'Appel be answered as follows:As is shown, in particular, by the title of Section 3 of the Chapter in which it is included, Article 71 of Regulation No 1408/71 is applicable only in the case of unemployed persons who, during their last employment, were already residing in a Member State other than the State where they were last employed.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.