law://eu/cjeu/1983/c-115-83/hd_1_1_3_2@2026-11-22The applicant, relying on the judgment of 31 May 1979 (Case 156/78 Newth v Commission [1979] ECR 1941) in which the Court, in interpreting the provisions of the Staff Regulations, took account of the principle of equality amongst officials, considers that the exclusive reference to the basic salary in the context of Article 72 (3) amounts to recreating, in terms of net purchasing power, the inequality between officials, according to their place of employment, which it is the very purpose of Article 64 of the Staff Regulations to avoid.The discrimination results from the fact that the Commission does not treat all officials in the same way as regards net purchasing power in the sense that the upper limit on reimbursement applies to all Community officials whilst the amounts which the officials themselves must pay vary according to their place of employment and the real cost of living.The applicant emphasizes in this regard that, in the light of the weighting applicable in Italy, officials working in that country always suffer loss in comparison to officials based in Brussels.The applicant emphasizes that it is precisely the fact that the special reimbursement is the same whilst salaries differ according to the place of employment which breaches the principle of equal treatment.The Commission considers that the rules regarding reimbursement of medical expenses take account of the principle of equality of treatment in the sense that all officials of the same grade and step are entitled, in all the places of work of the Community, to a special reimbursement of the same amount in respect of the same amount of medical expenses. If, as a consequence, the portion of those expenses borne by the official reduces the remuneration of an official assigned to a country with a low weighting to a greater extent than in the case of an official working in Brussels, that is no more than the consequence of general and objective rules intended to avoid a situation in which officials are reimbursed, in respect of a given amount in medical expenses, amounts which vary from one place of employment to another.In the Commission's view, the application of geographical weighting to the special reimbursement referred to in Article 72 (3) of the Staff Regulations would give rise to a double discrimination amongst officials.In the first place, discrimination would result from the fact that reimbursement of medical expenses would depend on purchasing power only in the case of the special reimbursement and not in cases of general reimbursement of medical expenses whose size did not justify reimbursement pursuant to Article 71 (3) of the Staff Regulations. It was to eliminate that risk that the applicant proposed applying weighting to the upper limits of the general reimbursement scheme. The Commission emphasizes once again however that such a reform of the sickness insurance scheme cannot result from a mere interpretation of the provisions in force in the light of higher principles of law.Secondly, the system proposed by the applicant would give rise to discrimination between officials receiving reimbursement pursuant to Article 72 (3) of the Staff Regulations. Supporting its arguments with numerical examples, the Commission states that to take the geographical weightings into account would mean that officials of the same grade, having incurred the same amount of medical expenses, would receive different amounts by way of reimbursement according to their place of employment. In the Commission's view, such inequalities are unjustified and contrary to the purpose of the joint sickness insurance scheme, which is intended to establish a uniform scheme amongst all officials and other employees and so to function that they receive the same amount in reimbursement in respect of the same amount of medical expenses regardless of their place of employment.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.