law://eu/cjeu/1982/c-175-82/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-19The plaintiff in the main action considers that the concept of “Other prepared ... meat” within the meaning of tariff heading 16.02 of the Common Customs Tariff must be interpreted in such a way as to encompass the simple addition of salt and pepper to the meat, even in quantities which are discernible only microscopically. In support of that argument it essentially puts forward three arguments.First, the plaintiff observes that it is clear from the Note to Chapter 16 of the Common Customs Tariff that meat prepared or preserved by processes other than those provided for in Chapter 02 come within heading 16.02. Therefore, it is important first to examine the processes referred to in Chapter 02. The descriptions given in that Chapter are in particular “fresh, chilled or frozen”, “salted or in brine”, “dried or smoked”, “boiled or steamed.” On examination, the plaintiff reached the conclusion that the terms used in Chapter 02 of the Common Customs Tariff are confined essentially either to describing the condition of a product (fresh, chilled, frozen or dried), or to mentioning methods of preserving products. Only three genuine methods of preparation are mentioned, namely smoking, boiling or steaming. Consequently, a preparation within the meaning of tariff heading 16.02 of the Common Customs Tariff must always be assumed whenever a product has been treated otherwise than by smoking, boiling or steaming.Secondly, the plaintiff relies on the terms of the Explanatory Notes to the Brussels Nomenclature relating to Chapter 15.02. A section of that Note is worded as follows :“Meat and meat offals prepared or preserved by other processes not provided for in Chapter 2, including those merely covered with batter or breadcrumbs, truffled or seasoned (e.g. with pepper and salt)”.In view of that Explanatory Note it matters little whether the seasoning was carried out with salt and pepper since it is sufficient that seasoning did take place.Finally, the plaintiff refers to the terms of the preamble to Commission Regulation No 3092/76 of 17 December 1976 on the application of monetary compensatory amounts to certain beef and veal products (Official Journal L 348, p. 18). The second recital in the preamble to that regulation, is worded as follows :“... the simple seasoning of, or addition of other substances to, fresh, chilled or frozen meat has the consequence that such treated meat is considered as being prepared or preserved meat for the purposes of application of the Common Customs Tariff; ...”That wording as well as the wording of Article 1 of that regulation show that for the Community legislature a simple, that is to say, light seasoning of the product is sufficient to enable it to be regarded as prepared meat within the meaning of tariff heading 16.02 of the Common Customs Tariff.The plaintiff observes that the first question raises a second problem in addition to that of interpreting the concept of “Other prepared ... meat”. In fact, the court making the reference also wishes to know whether proof of seasoning must be obtained by means of objective criteria (for example, microscopic examination) or subjective criteria (for example, by means of the sense of taste). In the plaintiff's view, only objective criteria of proof can be decisive for a tariff classification. In support of that view, it observes that the principles generally observed as regards tariff classification refer exclusively to the objective condition of products at the time of importation. That accords, moreover, with the well-established case-law of the Court. Furthermore, the plaintiff considers that the objective of Community law is to create a uniform legal system within the Community and that to rely on subjective sensitivity to taste would run counter, to that objective. In fact, the use of that criterion would result in the same seasoned meat being given a different tariff classification within the Community. Finally, the plaintiff claims that other forms of preparation within the meaning of tariff heading 16.02, mentioned in the Brussels Explanatory Notes, always have to be ascertained on the basis of objective criteria.As far as the second question is concerned, the plaintiff states that, in its view, a reply is not necessary, regard being had to the view set out above. Moreover, the question as posed is scarcely comprehensible: consumers in the Member States of the European Community are not accustomed to eating raw meat and it is therefore difficult to imagine that the turkey-meat in question would be consumed in the condition in which it is at the time of importation. The use of taste as a criterion thus implies in practice that the customs authorities would be obliged, for example, to cook or roast the samples taken for inspection purposes. That procedure would however conflict with the rule of tariff classification that goods must be appraised in the state in which they are at the time of importation.The plaintiff also considers that it would be questionable to rely on the particular sensitivity to taste of the customs official responsible for the tariff classification. That would lead to discrepancies in the tariff classification of the same goods by different customs officers. In fact it must be borne in mind that within the Community the customs officials of different countries have a differing sensitivity to taste.In the light of the foregoing considerations, the plaintiff considers that gustatory proof of a product's having undergone another kind of preparation within the meaning of tariff heading 16.02 of the Common Customs Tariff can only be obtained from a product which is ready to be consumed. It adds that, if organoleptic proof is held by the Court to be the correct one, a tasting would have to be carried out by an independent group of persons, who were not capable of being influenced and were representative of the different nationalities and peoples of the Community. Only in that way would that method of tariff classification be reconcilable with the principles of legal certainty and clarity which require that individuals must always be able to know without ambiguity their rights and duties.The Commission of the European Communities suggests that the reply to be given to the national court's first question should be that heading 16.02 of the Common Customs Tariff must be interpreted in such a way that meat to which salt and pepper have been added may be regarded as “Other prepared ... meat” only if that addition amounts to a seasoning which is perceptible to the taste. In support of that interpretation, it puts forward, in essence, two arguments.First, the Commission argues that, in order to pass from Chapter 02 to Chapter 16 of the Common Customs Tariff, the meat must have undergone a true preparation changing the condition of the product. The Commission's argument on that point stems from the distinction between tariff headings 02.02 and 16.02. In fact, Chapter 02 comprises edible poultrymeat, which is either fresh, chilled, frozen, salted, in brine, dried or smoked. Products having undergone a more advanced treatment are to be regarded as prepared and classified accordingly in Chapter 16. That is the case if they are processed into sausages, for example, or if they are prepared in ways not mentioned in Chapter 02 such as pâtés, meat sauce, marinades, etc.Secondly, the Commission emphasizes that there is a direct relationship between seasoning and taste. Even if the seasoning by means of salt and pepper were to be considered a preparation not falling within Chapter 02, the question would arise at what point it might be regarded as “seasoned”. In the Commission's view, seasoning in common parlance signifies the addition to food of spices to bring out its flavour. Consequently, whether a product is seasoned or not can only be ascertained by resorting to organoleptic criteria. Therefore, if the seasoning is not perceptible to the taste, the product cannot be regarded as “Other prepared ... meat” within the meaning of heading 16.02 of the Common Customs Tariff.As to the second question, the Commission considers that the customs authorities are perfectly able to ascertain with a sufficient degree of objectivity, whether a product has been seasoned. In a doubtful case, it is always possible to call upon an expert in the matter. Consequently, the Commission suggests that the Court reply that organoleptic proof must be obtained by relying upon the perceptive capacity of the average customs official.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.