law://eu/cjeu/1982/c-159-82/hd_1_1_3_2_3@2026-11-19In this respect the applicant points out that she was previously entered on the list of suitable candidates for another competition the notice for which laid down the same conditions for admission as the competition at issue regarding applicants' university qualifications. The Court recognized in its judgment of 5 April 1979 (Case 112/78 Kobor v Commission [1979] ECR 1573) that “it cannot be accepted that the objective requirements for admission to the tests, which are formulated in identical terms, should be given a different interpretation from one competition to another ... unless the statement of the reasons on which the decision is based clearly justifies such a difference of appraisal.” In this case the statement of the reasons on which the selection board's disputed decision was based does not show the grounds on which the appraisal of the applicant differed from that made on the occasion of the previous competition.A liberal interpretation of the objective conditions for admission to the competition is all the more necessary since the Commission's recruitment policy is inconsistent. A subsequent notice of a competition organized by the Commission to constitute a reserve for future recruitment of administrative assistants did not exclude applicants possessing a university degree or in their final year of a long course of university studies.The Commission denies first of all that the applicant's argument based on her admission to a previous competition constitutes a valid submission unless based on a breach of a provision of a regulation or a general principle of law. In that respect it states that selection boards are fully independent and cannot be bound either by a stipulation laid down by the appointing authority or by an attitude adopted by another selection board.Further the argument that the statement of the reasons on which the contested decision is based is unsufficient must be left out of discussion pursuant to Article 42 (2) of the Rules of Procedure since it was raised for the first time in the reply. In any event that argument is without foundation since the reason for excluding the applicant from the competition is clearly apparent from the wording of the letter from the administration of 7 September 1981 which also explains the different treatment as compared with the view taken at the time by the selection board for the previous competition.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.