law://eu/cjeu/1981/c-14-81/hd_1_1_3_1@2026-11-21The Commission has informed the Court that the decision at issue was annulled and replaced by the decision of 24 February 1981 and contends therefore that the Court should declare that there is no need for the case to proceed to judgment since the subject-matter of the dispute has ceased to exist.The applicant challenges the Commission's assertion that the decision of 19 December 1980 has “ceased to exist” so that “there is no need for the case to proceed to judgment”.Apan from the question whether an authority may, after proceedings have been initiated before the courts, “rectify” its decision — and, moreover, not as requested in the application but in the opposite sense, that is to say by making it less favourable to the applicant — it is in any case not permissible for the authority whose decision is under attack to seek to evade the action by declaring in its rectification that the latter “annuls and replaces” the decision which is the subject-matter of the action.In fact the only new element in the so-called “new decision” is that it contains a statement of reasons which was wholly absent from the individual decision at issue. The applicant's action has not been deprived of its purpose: obviously it concerns the contested decision as amended. Far from having revoked its decision, the Commission has upheld it as far as the main objections thereto described in the application are concerned.The Commission expresses surprise that the applicant should contest the annulment of the decision of 19 December 1980, precisely that annulment which it was seeking, for the Commission thereby upheld one of the applicant's grounds for claiming that the decision was unlawful, namely the absence of a statement of reasons or the inaccuracy of the reasons given.The Commission maintains that the new decision annulled and replaced the previous one. The later decision is a wholly new one which differs from the first not only in the statement of reasons on which it is based but also with regard to the provisions which are applied, the reference production on which it is based and the quotas which are allocated. Thus no single element of the previous decision remains in effect.The Commission points out that in Case 4/54 Associazione Industrie Siderurgiche Associate (ISA.) v High Authority ([1954-56] ECR 91) and in Joined Cases 5, 7 and 8/60 Meroni and Others v High Authority ([1961] ECR 107) the Court has already held that a decision which is the subject-matter of an application may be declared void and that where the contested decision has been rescinded an action for a declaration that it is void ceases to have any purpose.Even if the result of the new decision was to allocate quotas lower than those contained in the decision of 19 December 1980 the applicant suffered no damage, according to the Commission, since by 1 March its production figures were only 3359 and 4162 tonnes respectively, and for the whole first quarter of 1981 5593 and 4162 tonnes.Moreover, the applicant has not chosen to bring an action directed against the new decision within the period prescribed by Article 33 of the Treat).The Commission therefore reiterates its contention that there is no need for the case to proceed to judgment.In its reply on the substance of the case the applicant maintains its submission, claiming that the Commission's decisioni may not be supplied with a statement of reasons ex post facto.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.