law://eu/cjeu/1980/c-70-80/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-22Mrs Vigier submits that the provisions of the Reparation Law cannot form part of the special schemes referred to in Article 4 (4) of Regulation No 1408/71. On the contrary, they are an integral part of German social security law. Consequently, Article 9 (2) of that regulation must be applied to Article 10 a (2) of the Reparation Law.There is no foundation for the doubts expressed by the Bundessozialgericht as to whether, in view of the arrangement and objectives of the provisions of the Reparation Law, the scheme for the reparation of injustice perpetrated under National Socialism in the field of social insurance in Germany comes within the scope of Regulation No 1408/71. Whilst the provision of compensation for National Socialist injustices is, at federal level, the responsibility of the Federal Minister for Finance, the rules on the reparation of National Socialist injustice in the field of social security are a matter for the Federal Minister for Labour and Social Affairs. Moreover, the provisions concerning the reparation of injustice in the field of social insurance have the same aim as Regulation No 1408/71, namely the improvement of the position in connexion with social insurance by means of the elimination of disadvantages arising from a person's choice of his place of residence within the EEC.According to Mrs Vigier, the main obstacle to a decision in her favour has been the Bundessozialgerichťs doubts on the question whether, as well as applying to insurance periods on which entitlement to benefits is based, Article 9 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 also applies to periods of prior insurance which create the relationship between the social insurance scheme and the insured person and thus the status of insured person. Mrs Vigier maintains that Article 9 (2) must not be construed narrowly to the effect that it does not apply to a contribution which first creates the status of insured person: the golden rule of interpretation recognized in international law is that the words used are presumed to mean what they say.In view of that rule, compelling reasons would have to be advanced in order to justify deviating from the terms of that provision and to explain why it is necessary to adopt a narrow construction to the effect that the contribution which creates the status of insured person cannot be replaced by a corresponding payment in another Member State. No such reasons exist. On the contrary, a narrow construction of Article 9 (2) would entail the very disadvantages, already referred to, which Regulation No 1408/71 seeks to avoid and would be contrary to the principle of equality of treatment laid down in Article 3 of Regulation No 1408/71.Finally, Mrs Vigier draws the Court's attention to the consequences of a narrow construction of Article 9 (2). The failure to pay the German contribution required in order to be entitled to pay retroactively voluntary contributions for invalidity and old-age insurance was caused by persecution. The consequences of that persecution would be perpetuated if retroactive payment were prevented.In view of the nature of the German legislation in question in this case and in order to avoid the perpetuation of the consequences of the National Socialist regime, Mrs Vigier submits that the insurance period of 60 months, required for entitlement to pay contributions retroactively, including the single contribution which is required to create the status of insured person, may also be completed by corresponding contributions paid in other Member States.The Bundesversicherungsanstalt fiir Angestellte states that the provisions of the Reparation Law must be regarded as legislation within the meaning of Article 1 0) of Regulation No 1408/71, since they amend or supplement inter alia certain provisions of the Reichsversicherungsordnung [Insurance Code], the Angestelltenversicherungsgesetz [Clerical Staff Insurance Law] and the Reichsknappschaftsgesetz [Law on invalidity and old-age insurance for miners]. According to the declaration made by the Federal Republic of Germany, those laws come within the scope or Regulation No 1408/71.The provisions of the Reparation Law confer upon the persons concerned rights which are not dependent on any discretionary assessment of their personal situation and needs. It is therefore a question of statutory provisions which belong to the field of social security within the meaning of Article 51 of the Treaty and Article 1 (j) of Regulation No 1408/71. Those rules concern only a section of persons covered by social insurance in Germany, namely those who as victims of National Socialist persecution have suffered prejudice in the field of social insurance. But the fact that its scope is limited in this way does not prevent the Reparation Law from forming part of the general law on social security, for it is not unusual in German legislative practice for rules which apply only to a particular category of insured persons to be dealt with in a special law.Under the Reparation Law the link between the victims of National Socialist persecution and the German pension insurance scheme derives from the payment of one contribution to a German invalidity and old-age insurance institution. In respect of that condition, which concerns a person's status as a victim of persecution, neither Article 9 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 nor any other provision of Community law puts periods of insurance or residence in other Member States on a par with German contributions. The Bundesversicherungsanstalt submits that the social security law of the Community does not in principle have any bearing on the general legal status which a Member State attributes to particular categories of persons in the area covered by national legislation. Consequently, the defendant in the main action supports the opinion expressed by the Bundessozialgericht to the effect that Article 9 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 must be construed narrowly as meaning that it does not affect a contribution which creates a person's status as an insured person.The Commission observes that the question whether Regulation No 1408/71 applies to the plaintiffs rights under Article 10 a (2) of the Reparation Law is determined by reference not only to the provisions defining the matters covered by the regulation, but also to those which define the persons covered thereby. The plaintiff must be a “worker” within the meaning of Article 2(1) and Article 1 (a) of that regulation. In terms of Article 1 (a) the plaintiff's status as a worker depends on her status as an insured person under a social security scheme. The conditions of affiliation are a matter for the national provisions of each Member State (Case 110/79 Coonan [1980] ECR 1445). The main action concerns the applicability of the regulation to a right claimed under German legislation and the plaintiffs status as a worker must therefore be judged from the point of view of German social security law. Thus in the absence of affiliation to the German social security scheme the plaintiff is not a worker within the meaning of the regulation for the purpose of the possible application of the internal provisions of German law.It is true that the view may be taken that for the purpose of applying French legislation on social insurance the plaintiff is to be regarded as a worker within the meaning of Article 1 (a) of the regulation. However, that status as a worker is of no significance for the internal law of another Member State in which the plaintiff has never worked.The Commission considers that the benefits under the Reparation Law should be regarded as social security benefits within the meaning of Article 4 of Regulation No 1408/71.A right to reparation is conferred by the Reparation Law on insured persons who have suffered prejudice in the field of accident insurance and invalidity and old-age insurance as a result of National Socialist persecution. To that end, in respect of the statutory invalidity and old-age insurance it allows victims of persecution to obtain continued insurance and to pay contributions retroactively. Thus in this type of case the reparation provided by the Reparation Law consists in giving persons an opportunity to acquire entitlement to benefits which it was not possible to obtain as a result of persecution. Those compensatory benefits form an integral part of pension benefits in the general scheme of social security benefits. The Reparation Law supplements existing legal provisions with particular provisions. It constitutes a part of the German legislation on social security. It confers upon the beneficiaries a legally defined right which is not dependent on any discretionary assessment of personal needs or situations. The regulation cannot be held to be generally inapplicable by virtue of Article 4 (4) thereof, because the provisions of the Reparation Law do not relate to social and medical assistance, to a benefit scheme for victims of war or to a special scheme for civil servants and persons treated as such. The Reparation Law therefore comes within the scope of Regulation No 1408/71. But it might be objected that the right given by that law to pay contributions retroactively does not concern the worker in his capacity as an insured person, but in his capacity as a victim of persecution and that the principles of the law on the free movement of workers within the Community cannot be transferred to the field of national law on compensation.The decision therefore depends solely on the question whether the right to pay contributions retroactively under the Reparation Law relates to a social security benefit even though the aim pursued is the compensation of victims of persecution. The Commission answers that question in the affirmative because the right to pay contributions retroactively under the Reparation Law is closely connected to the scheme of statutory invalidity and old-age insurance by reason of the conditions governing it, its aim and its legal consequences. Admittedly, it is a question of reparation, but it is confined to the field of statutory invalidity and old-age insurance, to tne persons who are affiliated to that insurance and to the replacement of lost or missed opportunities to acquire pension rights.The function of Article 9 (2) is confined to the aggregation of insurance periods: it does not enable the status of insured person to be established.Article 51 (a) of the Treaty requires the legislature to make arrangements to secure for migrant workers and their dependants aggregation, for the purpose of acquiring and retaining the right to benefit and of calculating the amount of benefit, of all periods taken into account under the laws of the several countries.The status of insured person is the condition sina qua non for the application of the regulation. The acquisition of that status depends on the legal provisions of the Member States; it cannot be acquired by virtue of the assimilation of insurance periods completed in other Member States to insurance periods completed internally. Access to social insurance is given only by the internal law of the Member State concerned (Case 266/78 Brunon [1979] ECR 2705 and Case 110/79 Coonan [1980] ECR 1445).In conclusion, the Commission considers that the questions submitted for a preliminary ruling may be answered as follows :1. Article 9 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 is applicable to entitlement to pay contributions retroactively under the German Law of 22 August 1949 on the reparation of injustice perpetrated under National Socialism in the field of social insurance, as amended on 27 June 1977, in so far as the victims of persecution must be regarded as workers within the meaning of Article 1 (a) of that regulation. Affiliation to a social security scheme of the Federal Republic of Germany is decisive in that regard.2. The right to pay contributions retroactively under the Reparation Law does not form part of a benefit scheme within the meaning of Article 4 (4) of Regulation No 1408/71, such as would exclude the applicability of the regulation.3. Article 9 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 applies to the insurance period of 60 months required under Article 10 a of the Reparation Law only in so far as a person's status as an insured person under Article 1 (1) of that Law is not thereby created.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.