law://eu/cjeu/1979/c-94-79/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-16In the view of the Netherlands Government it is appropriate before examining the questions on which the Court has been asked to give a ruling by the court making the reference to summarize the historical process which led to the delegation in the Netherlands of certain public duties to professional or trade bodies in the sector of agriculture and horticulture.As regards the production and marketing of material for propagation in particular, products have been officially approved and certificates issued by those active in the trade themselves since 1900. As time went on the various bodies governed by private law which fulfilled these functions showed a growing tendency to amalgamate, so that by 1941 the abovementioned activities were being performed by a single body for each particular variety of plant.The historical evolution explained above, the fairly limited number of persons concerned and the need to establish a direct link between the highly specialized knowledge of those concerned and the methods of application which had to be drawn up were taken into consideration in adopting the Z.P.W., section 6 of which deals with trade in material for propagation and with supervisory bodies.In view of these factors and the advisability of a rapid means of adopting the measures for implementing the Z.P.W., the Netherlands legislature entrusted the task of drawing up those measures and ensuring that they were observed to supervisory bodies governed by private law. Prior to their entry into force, the implementing measures have moreover to be approved by the Minister of Agriculture and Fisheries. The supervisory bodies have power to adopt rules covering the health, purity and quality of material for propagation, as well as other matters connected therewith. The central authority is empowered however to suspend the application of such provisions or to annul them if they are contrary to the general interest. Should the supervisory bodies fail to act, that authority is empowered to make the provisions in question itself.In addition, the Z.P.W. lays down the procedure to be followed in disputes which may arise between a supervisory body and its members. Two types of action are provided for: action against decisions concerning the approval of a product and action against other decisions. The latter is reserved to a Raad van Beroep (Appeals Board), which guarantees lack of bias in settling disputes.In order to compensate for the fact that the rules laid down by a body governed by private law are binding only on its affiliated members, and the fact that only affiliated members are subject to supervision by the body and to its disciplinary powers, it was provided that affiliation to the supervisory bodies is compulsory. Thus, compulsory affiliation must be considered as a part of the system whereby certain regulatory and supervisory powers are delegated to bodies governed by private law.In the opinion of the Netherlands Government the question of which national bodies or institutions are empowered in the Member States to perform public duties is not a question of Community law, whilst the manner in which such duties are delegated is a matter for the national law of the Member States.It has in fact been established by the case-law of the Court of Justice (cf. judgment of 15 December 1971 in Joined Cases 51 to 54/71 [1971] ECR 1107) that it is for the Member States to determine which institutions within the national system shall be empowered to adopt the appropriate measures to ensure fulfilment of the obligations arising out of the Treaty, and that the question of how the implementation of such obligations may be entrusted to specific national authorities is solely a matter for the constitutional system of each State. The inescapable conclusion to be drawn from this is that the rule concerning compulsory affiliation to a supervisory body governed by private law is not contrary to Community law, nor to Article 30 et seq. of the EEC Treaty.The rule may, however, when taken in conjunction with other provisions, amount to a restriction on trade prohibited by Article 30 of the Treaty. That would be the case, in particular, if affiliation could be refused or if it was compulsory only in relation to the marketing of imported material for propagation. But the Netherlands regulations contain no such provision.As to the second question, the procedure of the Raad van Beroep, as provided for by the rules of the supervisory body in conjunction with Articles 87 and 90 of the Z.P.W., is also compatible with Community law.According to the judgment given on 16 December 1976 by the Court of Justice in Case 45/76 ([1976] ECR 2043): “in the absence of any relevant Community rules, it is for the national legal order of each Member State to designate the competent courts and to lay down the procedural rules for proceedings designed to ensure the protection of the rights which individuals acquire through the direct effect of Community law, provided that such rules are not less favourable than those governing the same right of action on an internal matter”.For the sake of completeness, however, it should be pointed out that when public duties are delegated in a Member State to bodies governed by private law such bodies must be considered, for the purposes of applying the provisions of the EEC Treaty, as organs of that Member State. The provisions adopted by them and the manner in which they supervise the application thereof are therefore subject to judicial scrutiny in relation to Community law.Whilst the questions which have been referred to the Court do not concern the compatibility of the provisions adopted by the supervisory bodies with Community law, it should be recalled that those provisions brought into effect in the Netherlands the Community directives concerning the quality of material for the propagation of agricultural, horticultural and forest varieties. Those directives expressly mention, among the measures whereby the Member States may bring them into effect, measures adopted in the name of the State by persons subject to public or private law. In the preambles to those directives the need to adopt provisions designed to guarantee the quality of material for propagation is acknowledged. Article 3 of Regulation No 234/68 of the Council on the establishment of a common organization of the market in live trees and other plants, bulbs, roots and the like, cut flowers and ornamental foliage, provides in fact that the Council, acting on a proposal from the Commission, shall lay down quality standards, but no such standards have been adopted yet with regard to material for propagatingornamental shrubs. Consequently, pending the adoption of Community rules, the Netherlands are quite entitled in law to adopt national rules designed to guarantee the quality of material for propagating ornamental shrubs.The Commission of the European Communities observes that the essential point at issue in the first question is whether or not a Member State, in this case the Netherlands, has the power to fix quality standards in relation to material for propagating ornamental plants. This is one part of the more general problem of defining the discretion which is still left to Member States in the adoption of measures once Community rules have been established for markets.The Commission recalls the cases in which the Court has already had occasion to tackle this problem, also in relation to Regulation No 234/68 (Case 190/73 Van Haaster; Case 51/74 Van der Hulst's Zonen; Case 50/76 Amsterdam Bulb), and points out that according to the case-law of the Court national measures are to be considered incompatible with the existence of a common organization of the market only if they are of such a nature as to prejudice the aims and objectives of the Community rules.In the present case the national measures designed to encourage standards of quality in respect of the product in question have precisely the same aim as Regulation No 234/68, which provides likewise for the determining of quality standards and for the adoption of measures capable of improving the quality of the products. For so long as the Community has not adopted different quality standards in respect of the same product the national measures are therefore to be considered compatible with Regulation No 234/68.At this point it should be asked whether the method of compulsory membership is lawful under Community law. There are many forms of compulsory affiliation or registration which are not incompatible with that law on the ground that they cannot be considered to fall within the sphere of application of the provisions of Articles 30 and 34 of the Treaty. One need only recall, in this respect, the compulsory registration with Chambers of Commerce which is required in a number of Member States as a condition precedent to the carrying on of commercial, industrial or craft activities. Such is also the case with affiliation to the supervisory bodies in the Netherlands. Although in Case 83/78 Pigs Marketing Board, the Court condemned compulsory registration with a national authority, its view was due to the fact that that measure formed a single entity with other measures preventing the free circulation of products subject to the organization of the markets.As to the second question, the Commission observes that the N.A.K.S. and its Raad van Beroep are not applying rules of Community law and therefore the Community need not concern itself with whether rights are being safeguarded in the application of those rules.The situation could be quite different in the case of bodies empowered to apply Community law, which would be quite conceivable had the Community fixed quality standards in this sector for seeds, as it has done in other sectors.According to the case-law of the Court it is for each Member State to designate the competent courts and to lay down the procedural rules for proceedings designed to ensure the protection of the rights which individuals acquire through the direct effect of Community law', provided that such rules are not less favourable than those governing the same right of action on an internal matter. By virtue of Article 88 (1) (f) of the Z.P.W., the Chairman and the other members of the Raad van Beroep of the N.A.K.S. are appointed by the Minister of Agriculture and Fisheries. That Board cannot therefore be considered as a court which, by reason inter alia of its independence from the administration, is such as to offer individuals the same guarantees as those to which they would be entitled through the direct effect of Community law.For those reasons the Commission proposes the following replies to the questions which have been referred to the Court by the Gerechtshof, Amsterdam, for a preliminary ruling:1. The existence of national rules prohibiting the marketing, resale, importation, exportation and offering for export, by way of trade, of material for the propagation of chrysanthemums, such as chrysanthemum cuttings, irrespective of whether the material for propagation satisfies the quality requirements laid down by the Stichting in question, is not incompatible with Articles 30 to 47 of the EEC Treaty and Regulation (EEC) No 234/68 of the Council of 27 February 1968 on the establishment of a common organization of the market in live trees and other plants, bulbs, roots and the like, cut flowers and ornamental foliage.2. The existence of national rules which provide that those affiliated to a Stichting responsible for ensuring the maintenance of quality standards in respect of chrysanthemum cuttings are bound to accept the decisions of an Appeals Board is not incompatible with the aforementioned provisions of Community law, even in view of the fact that that Appeals Board cannot be considered as an independent tribunal and the decisions of the Appeals Board with respect to them have the character of binding opinions, which fetters the right of appeal to the civil courts against the decisions of the Appeals Board.”
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.