law://eu/cjeu/1979/c-618-79/hd_1_1_3@2026-11-18The applicant alleges in the first place a breach of the law of contract. When the agreement was entered into the parties stipulated for repayment of the loan at the rate at which it was advanced, namely LIT 12.5 = BFR 1. The Commission is not entitled to amend the agreement unilaterally and to the detriment of the applicant. Had the applicant had notice of so onerous a provision he would not have signed the loan agreement since the long-term risk of depreciation of the lira was, as far as he was concerned, incalculable. Similarly, the applicant adds, he would not have obtained in lire the real value at the material time of his loan expressed in Belgian francs, but rather an amount calculated according to the special rate applicable to internal dealings.Both the applicant's remuneration and his loan have been and are determined in Belgian francs but paid in the currency of his country of residence. If now the loan were to be repaid in Belgian francs the Commission could make deductions from the remuneration determined in Belgian francs and subsequently convert the amount, still expressed in Belgian francs, into lire and pay that amount in lire to the applicant. But the Commission wishes precisely to avoid that situation because, from a formal point of view, it distinguishes between the loan and the payment of remuneration and because subsequently, when the loan is repaid, it achieves a very significant gain. However, to regard the grant of the loan as the payment of remuneration is contrary to Article 62 et seq. of the Staff Regulations.Moreover, the Commission's procedure is also at variance with the obligation to provide assistance which it must discharge with respect to the applicant. Had there been any intention to impose upon the applicant a monetary risk for a period which now, as a result of the increase in the amount to be repaid, extends beyond his retirement, an express provision to that effect should have been included in the agreement.If, when in 1975 it brought pressure to bear on officials to apply for updating, the Commission was planning the present measures, it has laid itself open to allegations of fraudulent conduct.In 1975 the applicant obtained a single reduction of the amount of his loan. It is to be acknowledged that officials who then availed themselves of the opportunity to update their agreements in fact obtained a higher rate for the repayment of the loan expressed in Belgian francs by reason of the reduction of the principal debt. As the applicant did not wish to obtain any unjustified advantage either from his remuneration or from his loan, he is naturally prepared to redeem his loan on the basis of that higher rate of exchange applied for the advance of the loan. It is not, however, permissible to impose on him burdens such as those resulting from the Commission's subsequent decision to which effect was given as from April 1979.The Commission thinks that the view put forward by the applicant presupposes that the loan agreement offered him a legal guarantee that payment of the monthly amounts expressed in Belgian francs would be made at the same rate as that used for the advance of the loan. That view of the legal position is not supported either by the provisions of the contract or by the general implementing provisions of 17 June 1971 according to which the loan and the monthly amounts payable by the applicant are expressed in Belgian francs.The amounts due from the applicant no longer bore any legal relationship with the Italian lira as from the time when his principal debt was reduced and the repayment table was amended.Adherence to the parity of LIT 12.50 per Belgian franc never became an implied term of the contract which the defendant was not entitled unilaterally to delete. In fact, the parties performed the agreement on the basis of the IMF parities, but subject to the express provision that those parities might be changed (cf. in that regard the contractual provisions and the criterion of “parity ruling on the date of the payment or transfer”).After convertibility of the dollar into gold was discontinued (15 August 1971) nobody could seriously believe in fixed parities. The Jamaica Agreements (January 1976) officially abolished IMF parities and as from March 1973 the de facto position was that currencies floated freely. Consequently, redrafting of Article 63 of the Staff Regulations and Article 17 of Annex VII no later than 1 January 1978 became not only an economic but also a legal requirement.If the applicant's view regarding maintenance of the stipulated parity of LIT 12.50 were to be upheld, the reduction of his debt by BFR 150694 would constitute an unjustifiable gift in the view of the Community budgetary authorities — the applicant would then be able to repay without loss his loan of BFR 787500 by repaying the sum of LIT 9843750 which he had received; the updating of the contract would not have been necessary. The fact that updating was agreed between the Commission and the applicant in 1975 is in effect conceivable only if the two parties also expected an imminent adjustment of the outdated IMF parity, which was applicable to the repayment of the loan.The Commission considers that the principle of equality requires it to treat the monthly instalments payable by the applicant in the same way as a transfer in Belgian francs made by an official employed outside Belgium to a Belgian credit establishment. When transfers are made to a credit establishment in accordance with Article 17 of Annex VII the amount transferred is adjusted on the basis of the weighting for Belgium and consequently a rate much more favourable than the market rate is applied (LIT 18.35 per Belgian franc instead of more than LIT 26 in April 1979).In reply to the argument relating to the duty of protection and of assistance, the Commission states that it is under no general obligation, by virtue of the Staff Regulations, to safeguard officials against risks of a monetary nature (cf. Opinion of Advocate General Dutheillet de Lamothe in Joined Cases 63 to 65/70 Bode [1971] ECR 549). For that reason it is likewise under no obligation to bear that risk within the context of a low-rate loan agreement of the kind involved in this case.The updating of the parity of the lira against the Belgian franc was not an unforeseen event justifying amendment of the agreement; on the contrary it was the underlying reason for updating the debt. The agreement, as updated in 1975, takes into account the updating of the parity, which came about after a considerable delay (in 1979), of which the applicant had the benefit.Moreover, the applicant is free to make early repayment of his debt in Italian lire, on the understanding that the amount is converted into Belgian francs at the rate ruling on the date of the transfer.Finally, since the Commission has properly discharged its contractual obligations, there can be no obligation, contractual or otherwise, to pay compensation.The applicant replies that it appears from the wording of the Commission decision of 25 July 1975 that the detailed arrangements for payment of the loans were to be amended: for new agreements to be entered into, by payment in Belgian francs and for agreements under which payments had previously been made in the currency of the relevant country, by conversion, and therefore reduction of the sum granted by way of building loan, into Belgian francs according to the parity ruling on the date of the payment, and thus on the date of the transfer. The problem of payment of the loans was in fact known to staff and was reflected in part of Written Question No 26/72 of 13 April 1972 put by Mr Bermani.It is clear from Article 2 of the provisions of 25 July 1975 that the deductions and payments remain unchanged as regards existing agreements and only the opportunity to make early repayment has been changed. The letter accompanying the decision of 25 July stated that “... all repayments made subsequently must be made in Belgian francs. You may therefore no longer make any early repayment in the currency which was used for the advance of the loan”. The monthly deductions continue to be made, as in the case of non-updated agreements, in accordance with Article 15 of the agreement (“in Belgian francs or in the currency of the country in which the financed property is situated and in which this loan is advanced”), that is to say on the basis of the parity ruling on the date of the transfer of the loan.The applicant emphasizes that Article 9 of the implementing provisions of 17 June 1971 provides that, as regards transactions outside Belgium, the loans in question are, as from the time of the first advance, loans in the currency of the country in question, that is to say in this case a loan in lire and not a loan in Belgian francs. The meaning of that provision goes even further: since there is no further mention elsewhere of parities and repayments, it may be regarded as self-evident that the “corresponding payments” relate not only to the payments (made by the lender to the borrower) but also to the payments of interest and the repayments of the loans (made by the borrower to the lender) according to the principle whereby the amount of the loan is due, as regards the principal and therefore the interest and repayments, in the currency in which the loan was advanced. The basic idea of granting loans in each of the countries of employment or origin of officials within the framework of an accommodation policy was subsequently also included in the wording of the loan agreement, in Article 15. The expression “parity ruling on the date of the transfer” appearing in the second paragraph of that provision manifestly means “parity ruling on the date of the transfers” in exactly the same sense as the expression “transfer” is used and defined in Articles 1 and 5 of the agreement.The grant of building loans to officials at a favourable rate of interest (4%) would be completely deprived of its social objective if, seven years after the agreement was entered into, the conditions for repayment were amended unilaterally, exposing borrowers to the problem of variable monetary parities. Commercial usage alone should prevent the Commission from making speculative monetary gains to the detriment of its officials. A change of parity is tantamount to a de facto change in the interest rate or of the principal debt, which is prohibited by Article 4 (6) of the implementing provisions.The applicant shows that, although he received LIT 9843750 in 1972, the remaining amount of his debt as at 15 April 1979 amounted to LIT 10335509 (although he had made repayments since 1973) and, in March 1981, despite two further years of repayments, to LIT 10943614.In 1971 it was clear that the fixed exchange rates could not remain permanently fixed. Both parties were therefore aware of the risk and, for the advance of the loan and repayment thereof, the parities which were used at the time of the advance were firmly agreed upon. In reply to Mr Bermani's question, the Commission stated that “the correct application of Article 9 of the implementing provisions for the grant of building loans to officials requires fixed official parities”, from which it is clear that in the absence of such parities Article 9 cannot be correctly applied. It added that “for repayment of the loans, the opportunity to choose the currency ensures that the borrower is protected against possible fluctuations of exchange rates from time to time”, which clearly means that the borrower may repay in lire the lire obtained by him and that he is not obliged to repay them in Belgian francs. The choice of the currency in which the loan is to be repaid offers protection against variations in exchange rates only if the rate in force on the date the loan was advanced is retained and the rate ruling on the date of repayment is not used.Regulation No 3085/78 amends only the provisions of the Staff Regulations concerning the monetary parities “used in application of the Staff Regulations and the detailed arrangements for the transfer of part of an official's emoluments to a country other than the country of employment of the persons concerned”. Regulation No 3085/78 has therefore in no way changed the “parity ruling on the date of the transfer”, and therefore of the payment, referred to in the loan agreement. In its unilateral action, the administration failed even to inform the applicant of the detailed arrangements for securing repayment applied as from 1 April 1979, not to mention the fact that no reasons were given to him and his consent was not even sought. It should also be made clear that the “parity ruling on the date of the transfer” was not the same as the parity of 1 January 1965 referred to in Article 63 of the Staff Regulations in the version prior to Regulation No 3085/78.The applicant claims in the alternative that the amendment made to the agreement in 1975 is inoperative. Had the Commission had the intention, when the loan agreement was amended, to change not only the early repayments but also the monthly repayments or deductions from salary, it would have been under an obligation to inform the borrower clearly and unequivocally. If, moreover, it gave him a false impression as to the aim of the amendment, the borrower has a right of revocation, of which he states his intention to avail himself. If it is found that after the amendment of the agreement, in this case four years later, that amendment nevertheless affected his rights, the amendment must be regarded as void. Had it been truly necessary to amend the old agreements in 1975, it would have been more honest to terminate them, at the request of the official, by means of a repayment in lire.The request for early repayment on the basis of the rate ruling on the date of the advance, within a period of three years from the date on which the judgment becomes effective, is justified from the legal point of view by the possibility that such a judgment might detract from the balance between the duties of each party on which the agreement is based. Should the Court be of the opinion that the duties of the parties which constitute the basis of the contract no longer display the equivalence provided for by the previous contractual terms, it may direct that the legal relationship be altered and require compliance with the earlier agreement. In that respect, the applicant refers to the provisions of the agreement which bar the use of the loan for speculative purposes.The provisions of the agreement define the “transfer” as the advance of the loan. Otherwise, it uses the expression “repayment”. The expression “corresponding payments” in Article 9 refers also to the monthly payments for redemption of the principal and discharge of the interest which are to be made in lire and converted into Belgian francs on the basis of the parity of the advance.The acceptance of the Commission's proposal of 25 July 1975 did not convert the amounts due from lire into Belgian francs except in the case of “early repayments”. In consequence, the deductions from salary should still be treated in the same way as those under the non-updated agreements.It is untrue that continuance of the IMF parity, applicable by virtue of Article 63 of the Staff Regulations, became an element of the agreement. Nowhere was any reference made to the parities provided for in Article 63. In fact, the IMF parities ruling in 1971 and 1972 were applied without their being referred to explicitly as such. It is untrue to say that those parities might be amended and that contractual provisions to that effect had been adopted.The parity to be applied between the lira and the Belgian franc was specified in the contract as a fixed magnitude, since Article 15 in the existing agreements was not amended. Likewise, the latter are not affected by Regulation No 3085/78.The reduction of the applicant's debt does not constitute an unjustifiable gift. It merely offsets the fact that he no longer has the opportunity to make early repayments of the loan in lire and must make them in Belgian francs. Since the conditions for transfers lay down a higher upper limit for any transfers made, namely 35 % of the net salary, the fact that the deductions from salary are treated as transfers made pursuant to Article 17 of Annex VII effectively diminishes the total amount which an official may transfer in order to maintain his purchasing power.The parties did not agree to an updating in 1975 by reason of the fact that the IMF parity was soon to be updated. In fact, there was no question of updated parities in 1975 or else the Commission had the intention as from that date of exposing the monthly repayment instalments to the monetary risk.The Community should not, otherwise than in the case of exceptional agreements, safeguard officials against risks of a monetary origin. But in this case there was the loan agreement and also the reply given to Mr Bermani's question (“for repayment of the loans, the opportunity to choose the currency ensures that the borrower is protected against possible fluctuations in the exchange rates from time to time”).The contractual right of repayment referred to by the Commission is of little use to the applicant if the parties disagree on precisely that point, namely the question of repayment.The defendant states by way of rejoinder that the relevant provision of Article 2 (I) (c) of the decision of 25 July 1975 (“All repayments to be made after the decision to reduce the debt must be made in Belgian francs”) does not apply only to early repayments of the loan but also to all the detailed arrangements for repayment provided for in the first paragraph of Article 15 of the agreement, including the monthly repayment instalments. That interpretation is confirmed by the scheme of the conditions applicable to repayment of the loan. There is no objective reason for treating the applicant's obligation to repay the loan in a manner which differs according to whether it is discharged by early payments or by means of setoff in response to an application for the monthly repayments to be deducted from salary. Only that interpretation endows the decision with any meaning consonant with the interests involved. In fact, if the applicant were able to continue to repay his loan of BFR 787500 by means of deductions from his monthly remuneration at the rate of LIT 12.50 BFR = BFR 1, he would have to pay only the amount of LIT 9843750 (plus interest) actually received by him. The updating of the debt would in that case be a gift financed by the Community budget and unacceptable to the budgetary authorities.If the applicant's view that the debt might be paid off by means of monthly deductions of the repayment instalments from his salary up to the amount of LIT 9843750 (plus interest) were correct, there would be no perceivable grounds for the Commission's having abandoned an opportunity for protection from a collapse of the parity of the lira against the Belgian franc, in this case early repayment of the loan, and having offered the applicant a reduction of his debt outside the terms of the agreement.The application would be unfounded even if the initial loan agreement had remained applicable since the opportunity to repay the loan in lire does not mean that each repayment must be appropriated in lire to discharge the debt expressed in Belgian francs on the basis of the rate which was in force at the time the loan was advanced. Only in the event of the Court's refusing to uphold the Commission's claims in the parallel case of Flamm (Case 567/79 A) would the applicant's present opposition to the updating of the debt offer him any advantage; if that course is not followed, it can only result in a financial loss for him. The Commission counters that opposition with an objection of inadmissibility and any argument which falls within the scope of that objection is in any event too late in this case.Repayment of the loan in Belgian francs does not entail any particularly burdensome consequences for the applicant from a social point of view since the application to the portion of the remuneration used for that purpose of the weighting for Belgium, within the context of the conditions applicable to the transfers referred to in Article 17 of Annex VII to the Staff Regulations, is no more costly for the applicant than for an official employed in Brussels.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.