law://eu/cjeu/1978/c-95-78/hd_1_1_2_4_3@2026-11-19As to Question 1, it is to be noted that the introduction of monetary compensatory amounts is subject to there being a risk of disturbances. This is a matter of ex ante anticipation in respect of which the Commission has discretionary power. In reviewing the legality of acts adopted by virtue of that discretionary power, the Court must confine itself to considering whether there has been manifest error, misuse of powers or manifest excess of the limits of the discretionary power.As regards the products at issue, it should be noted that at the time when Regulation No 800/77 was adopted the differences between the exchange rates of the currencies taken into consideration for the fixing of the monetary compensatory amounts were particularly large. As regards the risks of disturbance, a considerable increase was observed in Italian exports between 1974 and 1976.As to Question 2, for the application of monetary compensatory amounts the Commission can carry out an examination product by product but, in certain cases when it is faced with a multitude of products, it must also adopt an abstract, general method. In the present case, the criterion adopted was in principle that of the degree of incidence of the monetary compensatory amounts, applied when that incidence rose to approximately 5 % of the value of the goods.As regards pasta, the monetary compensatory amounts were reintroduced by Regulation No 2604/77 of 25 November 1977 (cf. Cases 12/78 Italy v Commission and 84/78 Tomadini, sub judice).Gingerbread and similar products coming under tariff subheading 19.08 A were included in the monetary compensation system, but only for a short time. Complete examination of the statistics relating to recent years showed that there had been no appreciable variations in trade and, in these circumstances, it was considered that it was not necessary to apply monetary compensatory amounts to those products.For white chocolate, no request has so far been submitted for monetary compensatory amounts to be applied; neither has there been any complaint.Before 1975, monetary compensation was applied to cocoa powder and similar products within subheading 18.06 A, but the statistics available in spring 1977 disclosed no trend giving reason to think that there was a risk of disturbance.The answers to the first two questions make Question 3 (a) purposeless.As to Question 3 (b), it suffices to state that the Management Committees were consulted but did not express any opinion. Moreover, on the date when the regulation at issue was adopted, the prolongation was fully justified if what is stated in the preamble corresponds to the truth, namely that the differences between the currencies were particularly large on that date and that there was a risk of disturbance in trade in the products at issue.The Commission considers that the reference to the date of 31 December 1977 had a precise meaning, in relation to which the prolongation laid down in Regulation No 2657/77 involves no contradiction. Member States and traders thus krew that in order to prolong the application of the compensatory amounts beyond that date, the Commission had to adopt a new regulation.As to Question 4, in the field of monetary compensatory amounts it is not possible to rely upon a legitimate expectation of being exempted from paying them when the monetary situation makes it necessary to maintain or introduce them (cf. the setded case-law of the Court).Regulation No 2657/77 allowed a period of one month, so that traders should know in advance what arrangements would apply as from 1 January 1978. It may even be presumed (cf. the letter of 24 October 1977 from Italy's Permanent Representation, relating to the proposed prolongation of Regulation No 800/77) that traders were aware well before 30 November 1977 of the Commission's intention to prolong the period laid down in Regulation No 800/77.Dulciora and the A.I.D.I., represented by G. M. Ubertazzi and F. Capelli, Advocates of the Milan Bar, the Irish Government, represented by J. Murray, Barrister-at-Law, the Italian Government, represented by I. M. Braguglia, Avvocato dello Stato, and the Commission of the European Communities, represented by its Legal Adviser, C. Maestripieri, acting as Agent, presented oral argument at the hearing on 12 December 1978.The Advocate General delivered his opinion at the hearing on 1 February 1979.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.