law://eu/cjeu/1978/c-88-78/hd_1_1_2_1@2026-11-21(a) In the view of the plaintiff in the main action the first question referred to the Court for a preliminary ruling should be answered in the affirmative.The fact that in Article 3 of Regulation 945/70 there is provision for the adoption of lists of vine varieties in itself indicates the answer to this question: if white table wines produced 100 % from Miiller-Thurgau or Sylvaner vine varieties were alone included, there would be no need for any special list.In the view of the plaintiff in the main action it is necessary to establish, in accordance with the general principles of interpretation and having regard to the structure and objective of Regulation 945/70, what conditions must be fulfilled for a wine to be classified under Type AII within the meaning of that regulation.The objective of that regulation is to determine the types of table wines and for this it is not the precise botanical definition of the particular vine varieties which is decisive but the establishment of groups with a certain uniform character.This is apparent in article 2 (a) as regards ‘Type A I’: the criterion is not the vine variety but the alcoholic strength. It is the same as regards the following groups. Regulation 945/70 does not require that a given wine to be classified as ‘Type A II’ or ‘Type A III’ should be produced exclusively from a particular vine variety but rather the type of wine should be particularized. As regards types of red table wine this is even clearer: the only vine variety determining a type in Article 1 of the said regulation is the Portugieser, and otherwise there is reference only to the alcoholic strength.In the view of the plaintiff in the main action in the case of blends of the said vine varieties the decisive type of the wine is determined by application of the general rules for the interpretation of the nomenclature of the Common Customs Tariff. In its view the Common Customs Tariff applies to the present question. Article 12 (1) of Regulation 816/70 expressly so provides and refers to the said general rules for interpretation; this is particularly clear in the present case because of the close internal connexion between customs law, in the narrow sense, on the one hand and the law concerning refunds, including monetary compensatory amounts, on the other. Such a comprehensive reference is provided for and is general in organizations of the market in other products, for example, as regards cereals, in Article 18 (1) of Regulation 2727/75 of the Council of 29 October 1975 on the common organization of the market in cereals (Official Journal L 281 of 1 November 1975, p. 1). That reference is particularly pertinent to the present question since it refers to Regulation 2729/75 of the Council of 29 October 1975 on the import levies on mixtures of cereals, rice and broken rice (Official Journal L 281 of 1 November 1975, p. 18) which in its preamble states the principle that the Common Customs Tariff applies to levies and refunds in respect of agricultural products subject to an organization of the market:‘… the import levy on such mixtures results from their tariff classification, which is normally determined in accordance with the general rules for the interpretation of the Common Customs Tariff.’If the first question were answered in the negative then Type A I would serve largely as a catchment clause for blended wines. In the view of the plaintiff in the main action the Finanzgericht Hamburg rightly and convincingly rejected this: the classification of types of table wines must be regarded in the light of its objectives; the aim of the classification is to make it possible to determine the guide prices for each representative variety of table wine in Community production. Since the guide prices are determined on the basis of prices at the producer at the producer stage (thus obviously before any coupage) on the markets of the wine-growing areas of the Community, on which a significant part of the table wine production of the particular areas under consideration is marketed, and since, further, the guide prices for table wines of Types A II and A III are on average more than double those for wines of Types A I, it is quite out of the question that blends of table wines of Type A I with Types A II or A III should come unter Type A I.The plaintiff in the main action then stresses that since in its view the first question must be answered in the affirmative, it is making observations on the following questions only as a precaution and in the alternative.(b) As regards the second question referred to the Court for a preliminary ruling the plaintiff in the main action again stresses that the important factor in Regulation 945/70 is the type of wine. If a very small addition of wine of Type A I were capable of causing the whole wine to be classified as Type A I, this would mean a departure from the basic purport and structure of the regulation.If, however, the quantity of wine not coming under Type AII were to be taken as a criterion, then it ought not to be too strict. At least according to this view the addition of other wine varieties is harmless, in so far as there is still justification for describing the wine as a whole as being of the vine variety of the main component of the blend. Thus according to Article 8 of the German wine regulation of 15 July 1971 (Bürgerliches Gesetzblatt I p. 926) the appellation of the main vine variety may be used providing the addition of other vine varieties does not exceed 25 %. A lhigher percentage of wines of other vine varieties may be added if the added wine is of neutral taste. In effect, in proportions of 70 to 30 the predominant variety clearly dominates. In the view of the plaintiff in the main proceedings it may accordingly be assumed for the purpose of the second question that up to some 30 % may be added.(c) As regards the third question referred to the Court for a preliminary ruling the plaintiff in the main action points out that Regulation 2448/75 makes it clear that the suspension of the monetary compensatory amount does not concern inter alia table wines of Type A II within the meaning of Regulation 945/70. It necessarily follows from this that it would be wrong to adopt an interpretation according to which in the case of coupage no monetary compensatory amount at all would be granted.The view that no monetary compensatory amount at all and without exception is payable in respect of blends also conflicts with the general provisions of the law relating to refunds. Article 6 of Regulation 1380/75 of the Commission of 29 May 1975 laying down detailed rules for the application of monetary compensatory amounts (Official Journal L 139 of 30 May 1975, p. 37) refers, in respect of the application of monetary compensatory amounts in trade with third countries, to Regulation 192/75 of the Commission of 17 January 1975 laying down detailed rules for the application of export refunds on agricultural products (Official Journal L 25 of 31 January 1975, p. 1). Referring to the third subparagraph of Article 8 (1) of that regulation the plaintiff in the main action states that it is clear according to Community law that refunds and monetary compensatory amounts are payable in respect of components even where they have been combined with other products.It states further that the objective of the export refund and the monetary compensator. amount is to encourage the exportation of agricultural products from the Community to third countries. It makes no difference in this respect whether such products are exported from the Community in an unaltered state and then mixed or mixed within the Community and then exported.(d) As regards the fourth question referred to the Court for a preliminary ruling the plaintiff in the main action observes that if Regulation 2448/75 has to be interpreted according to the premise of Question 4, then it does not contain a sufficient statement of reasons to comply with Article 190 of the Treaty.In its view the regulation also conflicts with the principle of equality of treatment. To suspend the monetary compensator amount on table wines which do not come entirely within the special categories of Article 1 of Regulation 2448/75 is objectively unjustified, in any event if this means that wines whose character is determined by wines of Type A II which attract compensation are excluded from it. The objective of the compensatory system, which is to support and thus guarantee exports of wine in spite of currency fluctuations, applies, in the view of the plaintiff in the main action, to that wine in the same way as to the varieties excepted from the suspension. The external circumstances have not changed to such an extent that a partial suspension would be justified in respect of wines which, if they were exported separately, would undoubtedly attract monetary compensatory amounts.The plaintiff in the main action refers, but only as a very minor issue, to a further defect in Regulation 2448/75: it was adopted on 25 September and published on 26 September 1975 in the Official Journal but had as its date for taking effect 29 September 1975. The plaintiff in the main action had already entered into the relevant contracts before such date, that is at a time when there was not yet any question of suspending the monetary compensatory amount. Legally this means that having regard to the principle of the protection of legitimate expectations the suspension could not apply to quantities which had been contracted for before the regulation was adopted. In this connexion the plaintiff in the main action refers to the judgment of the Court of 18 March 1975 in Case 78/74 DEUKA, Deutsche Kraftfutter GmbH v Einfuhr- und Vorratsstelle für Getreide und Futtermittel, [1975] ECR 421.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.