law://eu/cjeu/1978/c-128-78/hd_1_1_3@2026-11-17According to the Commission the only measures of application adopted by the United Kingdom Government are those contained in the Passenger and Goods Vehicles (Recording Equipment) Regulations 1977. The British Government admits that these regulations are only ‘initial’ measures and that they are intended to enable vehicles registered in the United Kingdom to comply with tachograph regulations whilst travelling in other Community countries.However, the regulations do not require the compulsory installation of tachographs even for international journeys. In fact they provide only for a voluntary scheme applying to both national and international traffic. It is only by reason of rules applicable in other Member States that operators are compelled to install tachographs for international journeys.The British regulations lack any provision creating offences and laying down penalties for failure to install and use tachographs in accordance with Community legislation.The British Government cannot, by pleading the risk of damaging industrial relations and an increase in wage claims in case of introduction of tachographs and by claiming that the failure to comply with the regulation for national journeys will not affect significantly conditions of competition, justify in law the failure of the United Kingdom fully to implement the regulation in question.The United Kingdom solemnly undertook to abide by its Treaty obligations, subject to the various modifications which were incorporated in the Act of Accession and amending regulations by which the special needs of the United Kingdom were taken into account.The Community system would become unworkable if a Member State could reserve the right to decide not to apply in whole or in part a binding Community measure which had been duly adopted according to Community procedure if in its opinion it was more advantageous not to do so.In accordance with Regulation No 1463/70, with the provisions of the Treaty, in particular Articles 5 and 189, and with the Act of Accession, the United Kingdom is bound to adopt in good time all the necessary measures of application after consultation with the Commission.The Commission feels that in many respects the Community legislature has taken into consideration the needs of the United Kingdom (in particular the provision made in Point 4 of Part Three of Annex VII to the Act of Accession). Moreover the United Kingdom had ample opportunity during the subsequent adoption of amending regulations to make clear its opposition by arguing that tachographs were unnecessary for domestic transport. The Community however has not accepted that case.In these circumstances, any practical difficulties of implementation of Regulation No 1463/70 by the United Kingdom cannot be accepted as a justification.In its defence the United Kingdom Government denies that it failed to consult the Commission before introducing the measures adopted in application of Regulation No 1463/70.On 2 September 1975 the United Kingdom submitted to the Commission a memorandum on the serious obstacles to the compulsory introduction of tachographs under Regulation No 1463/70 and sought the Commission's views thereon.Moreover the Commission itself has stated in its application that the Permanent Representative of the United Kingdom sent to the Commission on 25 February 1976 the measures proposed by the United Kingdom. The Commission gave its opinion thereon and asked the United Kingdom to send it an amended draft of the measures proposed.In concluding that in the United Kingdom the objectives of the Treaty and of Regulations Nos 543/69 and 1463/70 were more likely to be furthered in the form proposed by the United Kingdom than in the form sought by the Commission, the British Government appreciated that that decision was not acceptable to the Commission.However, in these circumstances it cannot accept that it came to that decision without consultation with the Commission. The practical consequences of attempting to enforce compulsory measures when important sections of the industry concerned are demonstrating a deep-seated resentment against the measures proposed cannot be ignored. The United Kingdom believes that there is a serious risk that labour would be withdrawn from a critical sector of the national economy and that the stability of the economy would or at least might well be jeopardized.In fact some operators were forced to remove a considerable number of tachographs from their vehicles. Such circumstances would place the law-enforcement agencies in an impossible position and would lead inevitably to a situation in which respect for the law would be undermined. The far-reaching consequences would be out of all proportion to any advantage which might be gained by the implementation of the obligation.The general use of tachographs is more likely to be achieved without major disruption in the light of experience with the equipment on a voluntary basis.The United Kingdom feels that in practice the objectives of Regulation No 1463/70 have substantially been achieved in relation to the United Kingdom, in particular for vehicles travelling between Member States.In comparison with standards of road safety in the other Member States those in the United Kingdom are more severe both for international and domestic journeys.According to the United Kingdom it is not easy to see in these circumstances how other Member States or the Community as a whole could be prejudiced by the fact that on certain domestic journeys the introduction of recording equipment is not compulsory.In its reply the Commission observes that it has never claimed that the United Kingdom has failed to consult it at all. It points out however that in application of Article 23 of Regulation No 1463/70 (as amended), the Commission has been consulted only on partial measures of application. It follows that the United Kingdom has failed to consult the Commission on all the measures necessary for the implementation of the regulation.The Commission denies that the objectives of Regulation No 1463/70 can be achieved by means other than those determined by the specific provisions of the regulation in question.Member States are not free to set aside certain provisions of a regulation — provisions which are binding in their entirety and directly applicable in all Member States (Article 189 of the EEC Treaty) — if they consider that domestic difficulties are too great to permit of the application of the regulation (judgment of 11 April 1978, Case 100/77 Commission v Italian Republic, paragraph 21, [1978] ECR 887).The Commission emphasizes that in giving an opinion on the measures of application proposed it acted in accordance with Article 155 of the EEC Treaty.It is no defence to a charge of not having taken the necessary measures to implement a regulation to claim that as a result of its non-application no particular prejudice has ensued to other Member States or the Community. That would amount to saying that Member States retain a residual discretion as to whether to implement their obligations under the Treaty.The Treaty contains no provision making it possible to support a thesis of this kind. Otherwise no Member State could rely on legal undertakings solemnly arrived at, often with the greatest of difficulty, being applied in practice by its partners. The Commission refers to the case-law of the Court of Justice, in particular Case 95/77 (Commission v Kingdom of the Netherlands, judgment of 11 April 1978 [1978] ECR 863) and to the opinion of Mr Advocate General Reischl in that case.The Commission maintains that the incomplete application of Regulation No 1463/70 is by its nature conducive to causing prejudice. Indeed the open defiance by a Member State of its obligation to apply fully an important regulation is far from being conducive to the well-being of the Community. Moreover on the commercial level prejudice is evident.Finally the Commission states its views on the request of the defendant that the Court should refrain from making a declaration pursuant to Article 169 of the EEC Treaty (see Point II above, conclusions of the parties). It observes that it is not aware of the existence of such a power of dispensation. Moreover, even assuming the existence of such a power, the Commission takes the view that the letters sent by the defendant and the utterances of the Minister responsible do not make it possible to conclude that a serious effort has been made to fulfil the legal obligations of the United Kingdom in this respect.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.