law://eu/cjeu/1978/c-10-78/hd_1_1_1@2026-11-20The Sozialgericht (Social Court) Geilenkirchen summarizes the facts as follows:Tayeb Belbouab, born on 14 April 1924 in Algeria, was an underground worker in the French mines from 29 March 1947 to 17 November 1950 and subsequently from 6 June 1951 to 4 October 1960 (155 months in all). At that time he possessed French nationality. In 1960 he emigrated to the Federal Republic of Germany to avoid possible political difficulties. Since Algeria became independent on 1 July 1962 he has not obtained a French passport; he has since possessed Algerian nationality and holds an Algerian passport.From 26 May 1961 he worked in Germany as an underground worker in a mine and, by his 50th birthday, he had completed 142 months of contributions to the old-age insurance scheme of the Bundesknappschaft. He then applied for a mineworker's pension in accordance with Article 45 (1) (2) of the Reichsknappschaftsgesetz (German Law on social insurance for mineworkers) which is worded as follows:‘On application by the insured the mineworker's pension shall be granted when the insured:(1) Suffers a reduction in his capacity for work as a miner and has completed the qualifying period in accordance with Article 49 (1); or(2) Having reached the age of 50 years, no longer has a post whose economic value is equivalent to the previous post as a mineworker and has completed the qualifying period in accordance with Article 49 (2).’Article 49 (2) provides that the ‘qualifying period’ for entitlement to a mineworker's pension under Article 45 (1) (2) is completed when the insured person has completed insurance periods of 300 calendar months in continuous employment as an underground or assimilated worker.Tayeb Belbouab's application was rejected by a decision of the Bundesknappschaft of 2 September 1974 on the ground inter alia that the provisions of Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71 read in conjunction with Regulation No 574/72 and the provisions of the Franco-German Convention were not applicable in view of the fan that the applicant possessed Algerian nationality and that in consequence the entitlement to a pension could only be examined in the light of national law. By a letter of 26 September 1974 Tayeb Belbouab protested against that rejection arguing that he had paid contributions in France as a French citizen. The protest was rejected by a further decision of the Bundesknappschaft of 7 June 1975 in particular for reasons which are summarized by the Sozialgericht as follows:‘The plaintiff has been an Algerian citizen since the independence of Algeria and has been registered as such with the residents' registration office. Under Article 1 in conjunction with Annex A to Regulation (EEC) No 3 on social security for migrant workers that regulation was applicable to the French Departments and to Algeria. Algeria was, however, deleted from Annex A to Regulation (EEC) No 3 by Regulation No 109/65 of 30 June 1965, on the understanding that Regulations Nos 3 and 4 should no longer apply as from 19 January 1965 to Algeria and Algerian citizens. The same naturally also applies to Regulations (EEC) Nos 1408/71 and 574/72 which replaced Regulations Nos 3 and 4. Contrary to the plaintiff's view it was not a question of what nationality he possessed during the period when he was employed in the French mines, but his nationality at the time of consideration of the application for a pension.’Tayeb Belbouab subsequently brought an action before the Sozialgericht Gelsenkirchen against the rejection of his protest. The parties then reached an arrangement to enable the defendant to reconsider its decision in the light of the judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Communities of 26 June 1975 in Case 6/75 (Horst v Bundesknappschaft [1975] 1 ECR 823) in which the Court ruled that ‘In so far as is necessary for the acquisition, the maintenance or the recovery of the right to benefits, insurance periods completed in Algeria before 19 January 1965 must be taken into consideration in calculating the pensions referred to in Chapters 2 and 3 of Regulation No 3 even if the risk materializes and the claim for a pension is made after that date’ and in the light of a judgment of the Bundessozialgericht (Federal Social Court) of 26 November 1975 also in the Horst case following the judgment by the Court of Justice.In its decision of 1 April 1976 the Bundesknappschaft reiterated its previous view. In the grounds of the decision it stated that it was not possible to take into account the French insurance periods; nor did the judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Communities have any effect on the decision to be adopted, since that judgment was concerned with a German, that is a national of a Member Sute of the Community, who sought to have account taken of periods completed in Algeria.After a further written protest by the plaintiff in the main action followed by a further rejection by the defendant, the plaintiff brought an action for annulment before the Sozialgericht Gelsenkirchen. He stated in support of his application that the aforesaid Community regulations were applicable to him. The fact that he was subsequently arbitrarily accorded Algerian nationality cannot be a ground for not taking account of the French insurance periods; that would be unfairly harsh. By order of 7 December 1977 received at the Registry of the Court of Justice of the European Communities on 1 February 1978 the Sozialgericht stayed proceedings and asked the Court of Justice to give a preliminary ruling on the following questions:1. Does the legal principle that legal rights under public law acquired by a person's own efforts may not be encroached upon by sovereign measures without compensation, which finds expression in German law in Article 14 of the Grundgesetz (Basic Law), apply in the law of the European Community?2. Do Regulations Nos 1408/71 and 574/72 violate that legal principle in so far as they contain no rule corresponding to Article 16 (2) of Regulation No 109/65?3. Or does Article 16 (2) of Regulation No 109/65 continue to apply, directly or by analogy, so that Articles 2 (1), 38 (1) and 94 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 are to be interpreted as meaning that the insurance periods completed in France by an employed person before 19 January 1965 are to be taken into consideration if during such periods he was a French citizen and as such enjoyed the advantages conferred by Article 1 (a) in conjunction with Annex A to Regulation No 3 on social security for migrant workers, although at the time of applying for a German pension he possesses Algerian nationality?’In the statement on the grounds for its decision the Sozialgericht set out the reasons for its doubts which caused it to ask the above questions:— The plaintiff is not one of the persons covered by the regulation cause he is not, within the meaning of Articles 1 and 2 of Regulation No 1408/71, a national of one of the Member States, a stateless person or a refugee as he has not sought that su tus.— The nationality of the members of his family is irrelevant (cf. Judgment in Case 40/76 of 23 November 1976Kermaschek v Bundesanstalt fur Arbeit [1976] ECR 1669).— On the other hand the plaintiff has acquired, by virtue of his work, certain legal rights under public law; such rights are protected by Article 14 of the Grundgesetz (Basic Law) of the Federal Republic of Germany in that they cannot be adversely affected by the act of a public authority without compensation.— Following the independence of Algeria Article 16 (2) of Regulation No 109/65 deleted Algeria from the Annex to Regulation No 3 ‘without prejudice to accrued rights’ (cf. Judgment in Case 6/75 of 26 June 1975Horst v Bundesknappschaft, already referred to) which means that such a right, which is similar to a reversionary interest, is under German law to be given the same protection as a proprietary right.— However, Regulation No 109/65 which amended Regulation No 3 ‘lost its point of reference’ by virtue of the repeal of Regulation No 3 by Article 99 of Regulation No 1408/71; it is for that reason that the defendant held that the accrued rights of the plaintiff were extinguished without any compensation.It was in the light of these considerations that the Sozialgericht raised the question whether Community law also recognizes a kind of proprietary guarantee, similar to a basic right, protecting legal rights acquired under public law as a result of personal effort. In practical terms the question is whether the regulations in force — Regulations Nos 1408/71 and 574/72 — contain provisions which also guarantee rights whose maintenance had previously been ensured by Article 16 (2) of Regulation No 109/65. It may be asked whether Article 94 (2) of Regulation No 1408/71 is henceforward sufficient in this respect in view of the fact that Article 2 (1) of that regulation provides that the regulation is applicable only to workers who are nationals of one of the Member States?Furthermore, does Article 99 of Regulation No 1408/71 which repeals Regulation No 3 but does not refer to Regulation No 109/65 enable Article 16 (2) of the latter regulation to be applied directly or, in particular, by analogy with regard to the provisions of the current regulation, No 1408/71, which replaced Regulation No 3 and which, in principle, should not restrict or withdraw without compensation the rights of employed persons working in Europe as this would be contrary to the principle of protection reflected in Article 16 (2) of Regulation No 109/65?The order of the Sozialgericht Gelsenkirchen was received at the Court Registry on 1 February 1978. In accordance with Anide 20 of the Protocol on the Statute of the Court of Justice the Commission of the European Communities submitted written observations.Upon hearing the repon of the Judge-Rapporteur and the views of the Advocate General the Court decided that a preparatory inquiry was not necessary but it expressed the wish to take note of the judgment of the Bundessozialgericht of 26 November 1975 (Case 5 RKn 11/72) to which reference was made in the course of the efforts to achieve a seulement between the parties to the main proceedings which led to the suspension of the proceedings before the Sozialgericht Gelsenkirchen.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.