law://eu/cjeu/1977/c-76-77@2026-11-17In Case 76/77Reference to the Court under Article 177 of the EEC Treaty by the Tribunal Correctionnel, Charleroi, for a preliminary ruling in the action pending before that court betweenAUDITEUR DU TRAVAILandBERNARD DUFOUR, S.A. CREYF'S INTERIM AND S.A. CREYF'S INDUSTRIALTHE COURTcomposed of: H. Kutscher, President, M. Sørensen and G. Bosco (Presidents of Chambers), A. M. Donner, J. Mertens de Wilmars, P. Pescatore, Lord Mackenzie Stuart, A. O'Keeffe and A. Touffait, Judges,Advocate-General: F. CapotortiRegistrar: A. Van Houttegives the following
The facts and the arguments advanced by the parties during the written and oral procedure may be summarized as follows:
It appears from the judgment making the reference that on 30 July 1975, as a result of a police check at Ronse, Belgium, a lorry used by Daniel Construction Company International and driven by Andre Gustin, driver, was found to be without the individual control book provided for under Article 14 (1) of Regulation (EEC) No 543/69 of the Council and, moreover, that the lorry was not carrying any recording equipment, which might have made the control book unnecessary. Daniel Construction Company International explained that it had hired the services of Andre Gustin, the driver, from S.A. Creyf's Interim to drive one of its own lorries. Bernard Dufour, the manager of the latter company, stated that he had hired to Daniel Construction Company International a driver who held a valid driving licence and explained that S.A. Creyf's possessed no vehicles.The Procureur du Roi brought proceedings against Bernard Dufour for contravention of the Arrêté Royal (Royal Decree) of 23 March 1970, which was authorized by Article 2 of the Law of 18 February 1969, and against S.A. Creyf's interim as being civilly liable.The Tribunal Correctionnel, Charleroi, thereupon found that the question which arose was whether the duty to issue an individual control book to crew members lay upon the undertaking whose sole business activity is the hiring out of labour, in this case a lorry driver, or with the undertaking which had taken that labour on hire and used the services of the said driver for its road transport business.The Tribunal Correctionnel found:— That Article 14 (1) of Regulation (EEC) No 543/69 of the Council (OJ, English Special Edition (I) p. 170) requires crew members of a vehicle not assigned to a regular service to carry an individual control book conforming to a model in the annex to the said regulation;— That Article 14 (7) provides that all undertakings must keep a register of the individual books and that the register must show the name of each crew member to whom a book is issued; and— That, under Article 14 (8), all completed individual books must be kept by the undertaking for at least one year.Having tried in vain to find a definition of the concept of undertaking in Article 1 of Regulation (EEC) No 543/69, in which the terms used in the subsequent provisions are defined, the Tribunal Correctionnel pointed out that as regards the laws, regulations or administrative provisions which might be necessary for implementation of the regulation, Article 18 of the regulation refers to the measures to be taken by the Member States themselves in due time and after consulting the Commission; Article 18 lays down that such measures shall cover, inter alia, the organization of, procedure for and means of control and the penalties to be imposed in case of breach.Having thus sought and studied the national provisions adopted by the Belgian authorities for the implementation of the Community regulation, No 543/69, the Tribunal Correctionnel considered the Arrêtés Royaux of 23 March 1970 and 7 May 1973 and came to the conclusion that they went no further than the Community provision in defining the concept of undertaking. Nor was there anything to be found in the Belgian Cour de Cassation on the point at issue.The Tribunal Correctionnel, Charleroi, thereupon decided to avail itself of the opportunity provided for in Article 177 of the EEC Treaty and to submit the following questions for a preliminary ruling to the Court of Justice of the European Communities:‘The interpretation to be given to the word “undertaking” appearing in the text of Article 14 (7) and (8) of Regulation (EEC) No 543/69 of 25 March 1969 and in the text of the annexes to the Belgian Royal Decrees of 23 March 1970 and 7 May 1973:1. Does the word undertaking refer exclusively to the natural or legal person who, in fact, either himself or through servants, is engaged in carriage by road, even if such carriage constitutes only a part of his business activities?2. Where the person described above employs hired labour for the purpose of driving his vehicle or vehicles, is that person released from the duty to issue an individual control book to every crew member, and in this case does the word “undertaking” refer to the natural or legal person who hires out the labour?3. Is it to be understood that the word “undertaking” means “employer” and that in this case the relationship of subordination as between the hirer of the labour and the worker continues to exist, or that such a relationship comes into existence as between the person to whom the labour has been hired and the worker?’The Commission of the European Communities and the Government of the Kingdom of the Netherlands submitted written observations under Article 20 of the Protocol on the Statute of the Court of Justice.Having heard the views of the Advocate-General, the Court decided to open the oral procedure without a preparatory inquiry. It did however request the court which submitted the questions to supply if possible:— ‘The contract for hire of services concluded between the “two undertakings” concerning the driver Andre Gustin;— The correspondence exchanged between the undertakings in this connexion;— The contract between the driver Gustin and the undertaking hiring out his services; and— A statement identifying the undertaking which pays Gustin's salary and pays social insurance contributions on his account.’The Commission was also requested to state during the hearing who, in its view, should ‘normally’ issue the control book: the owner of the lorry or the party which has hired out the driver.
The Commission states that it does not wish to make any comments as regards the admissibility of the request from the Tribunal Correctionnel, Charleroi, ‘to the extent to which it relates to the interpretation of provisions of Community law’.
The view of the Netherlands Government concerning the first question referred to the Court of Justice is that the concept of undertaking within the meaning of Regulation (EEC) No 543/69 refers exclusively to any natural or legal person who either on his own or through his own staff or hired labour is engaged, whole-time or part-time, in the business of road transport or in operations ancillary thereto.As regards Questions 2 and 3, the Netherlands Government is of the opinion that, in the circumstances described in the question, the concept of undertaking must be taken to refer to the natural or legal person for whom a crew member actually performs work in connexion with road transport. The duty to issue the individual control book is imposed on that person and that person must be liable in criminal law for the non-observance of any provision applicable to the undertaking and, inter alia, of the duty to issue the individual control book. In the view of the Netherlands Government, this is the most suitable answer if only because it is fair that the person who is in the best position to see that the above-mentioned rules are complied with should be responsible in criminal law.The Commission recalls the facts of the case and the position under the rules and emphasizes the importance of Regulation (EEC) No 543/69, the three objectives of which (social progress, harmonization of the conditions of competition and road safety) were referred to by the Court in its judgment of 25 January 1977 in Case 65/76
At the hearing on 26 October 1977 Etienne Lasnet, acting as Agent, appeared for the Commission.He replied to two questions from the Judge-Rapporteur and made the following points:— The Commission emphasizes that a situation like that which has given rise to the proceedings should normally be governed by a national provision.— In the absence of such provision, an alternative solution might be the existence of an amicable arrangement between the undertakings concerned.— In the absence of rules or private agreement, undertakings must ensure among themselves that the Community rules are observed; the driver himself should know them since ignorance of the law is no excuse.— In any case, the obligation to produce a ‘specific result’ under the Community rules is an unconditional one, and this is the basis of the possible joint responsibility of the undertaking.— Only where certain evidence is available can such responsibility be attributed to one undertaking rather than another, as the Government of the Netherlands suggests.The Advocate-General delivered his opinion at the hearing on 22 November 1977.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.