law://eu/cjeu/1977/c-41-77/hd_1_1_2_1@2026-11-20The insurance officer explains that the conditions for entitlement to invalidity benefit under the United Kingdom legislation are, first, that the person concerned should have been entitled, in the immediately preceding period, to sickness benefit for 168 days, and, secondly, that he should have paid at any time between his entry into insurance under the Great Britain Scheme and the expiry of the said 168 days a specified number of contributions. The reference to a specified number of contributions which must have been paid would fall within the definition of ‘insurance periods’ contained in Article 1 (r) of Regulation No 1408/71. Further, it is a pre-condition of entitlement to sickness benefit that a claim is made for it in a prescribed manner and within a prescribed time (section 48 (1) of the National Insurance Act 1965). If a person makes a claim for benefit outside the prescribed time-limit, it is provided by section 49 (3) of the same act that he shall be disqualified for the receipt of that benefit unless he can show the insurance officer that he has good cause for the delay. Whether insurance periods have been completed and whether or not a claim has been made in the prescribed manner are questions for determination by the Secretary of State and not for determination by the insurance officer. To acquire a right to invalidity benefit a person must, in order to have been entitled to sickness benefit for 168 days, have completed insurance periods and have made a claim for such sickness benefit.As to the first question she submits that Article 51 of the Treaty cannot be held to preclude the application of the legislation of a Member State which makes a period of entitlement to sickness benefit under that legislation a pre-condition for acquiring a right to invalidity benefit. Article 51 could be held to have such an effect only if construed as conferring on individuals a right to be exempted from any requirement of national legislation in the field of social security which can be said to discourage freedom of movement for workers within the Community. This would involve a departure from the principles settled by the Court in a number of cases (Case 26/62 Van Gend en Loos, [1963] ECR 1; Case 13/68 Salgoil, [1968] ECR 453; Case 2/74 Reyners, [1974] ECR 631). Article 51 may require the adoption by the Council of a measure to provide that a period during which a person has been entitled to sickness benefit in another Member State should be taken into account for the purpose of United Kingdom legislation and the insurance officer understands that a proposal for such an amendment to the relevant regulation has already been submitted by the Commission to the Council.In Case 20/75 (D'Amico, [1975] ECR 891) the Court held that Community legislation did not prohibit a rule of law which required, for the acquisition of a right to early retirement pension, that the person concerned should have been unemployed for a certain time and available to the unemployment bureau of the Member State in question. The present case should be considered by analogy with that case.As to the second question the insurance officer submits that Article 45 of the regulation does not apply. Although ‘benefits’ is defined in Article 1 (t) of the regulation as meaning ‘all benefits’, in the context of Article 45 it must be construed only as referring to benefits to which Chapter 3 applies, that is to say, invalidity benefits. Chapter 3 and Article 45 do not apply to sickness benefit. Under the legislation of Great Britain residence is only directly relevant for sickness and invalidity benefit purposes to avoid disqualification for receipt of benefit by reason of residence abroad. Article 45 as originally made by the Council referred only to the completion of insurance periods and a reference to periods of residence was inserted when the article was modified by Article 1 (13) of Regulation (EEC) No 2864/72 upon the accession of Denmark, whose legislation makes entitlement to benefit dependent upon periods of residence. Article 45 is concerned with determining acquisition of a right to (or, as the case may be, the retention or recovery of) benefit by taking periods of insurance or residence into account so far as is necessary for establishing entitlement to such benefit. Article 46 is directed only towards determining the amount of benefit. Therefore, the provisions of Article 46 can only apply after it has first been established that there is entitlement to, in this case, invalidity benefit.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.