law://eu/cjeu/1976/c-73-76/hd_1_1_3_2@2026-11-16The applicant points out, in respect of the Selection Board's finding that the duties performed by him from 1 June 1972 onwards were primarily executive duties, that it appears from his periodic reports for the period in question that, on the contrary, his duties were advisory ones.He notes, as regards the Selection Board's finding that he does not have a university degree, that the great majority of the candidates accepted for the competition did not have university degrees either. Therefore, just like the applicant, they did not fulfil that first condition required by the notice of competition. Moreover, not only have certain other candidates not commenced higher education, as the applicant has, but they do not even possess secondary school-leaving certificates.As regards experience, he notes that the Selection Board accepted for the competition at least two candidates whose experience was manifestly less than his own. In doing so, the administration has itself accepted that the applicant possesses adequate experience. In refusing to take that experience into account, the Commission has committed a misuse of powers.The Commission points out that according to the case-law of the Court a misuse of powers involves a use by an administrative authority of a power conferred on it for a purpose other than that for which the power was conferred (Opinion of Mr Advocate-General Warner in Case 31/75 mentioned above; [1975] ECR 1579).The fact that the applicant was appointed to Grade B 3 before two other persons taking part in the competition does not mean that he possesses better experience. The officials in question acquired equivalent experience in employment prior to their recruitment by the Communities. Furthermore, while not holding university degrees, they completed some years of university studies and sat for certain examinations; all this places them at a higher level of general culture than the applicantThe applicant's offer to prove that he possesses experience equivalent to a university degree is inadmissible. That question is so elusive that it is capable of solution only by means of a value judgment, that is to say by means of a judgment which, by definition, is not capable of judicial review. On this point, the Commission refers, inter alia, to the judgment of the Court of 5 December 1963 in Cases 35/62 and 16/63, Leroy v High Authority ([1963] ECR 197) and to the judgment of 17 March 1971 in Case 29/70, Marcato v Commission ([1971] ECR 243).The applicant replies that the Selection Board for the competition seems to hold against him his not having applied for admission to a university. That criterion has been invented in order to justify ex post facto the admission of candidates without university degrees who commenced university studies but never sat for any examinations.He mentions four candidates who had less experience than himself as assistant proof-correctors at the Publications Office at the time of the competition, but who nevertheless were accepted as candidates.The experience of the two candidates who, according to the Commission, possessed equivalent experience acquired in a post prior to their recruitment by the Communities, was based, according to their applications forms, on the performance of executive duties: type-setting by hand, pagination, stitching, folding, cutting of overlays and entering of statistical records, that is to say dudes analogous to those which the Selection Board refused to take into account in examining his application form.In view of these facts, he is astonished that the Selection Board did not hold interviews with the candidates, as provided for by the notice of competition, so as to proceed ‘to a further consideration of the qualifications and other references with regard to employment and of the statements relating to the qualifications required’.It has been held in previous cases that value judgments come at the second stage in a selection board's work. As Mr Advocate-General Warner said in his opinion in Case 31/75 already mentioned, the first stage of the competition procedure is subject to review by the Court.The applicant argues that the experience which he has acquired since 1966, if not since 1972, is superior to that of the other candidates.In its rejoinder, the Commission examines the applicant's allegation that the Selection Board seems to have held it against him that he never applied for admission to a university course. As to this, it replies that it would be absurd to draw from the letter of 26 May 1976, the conclusion that the Selection Board intended to grant a privilege to candidates having enrolled at a university. The Selection Board merely found that the applicant had not completed a university course and obtained a degree, as required by the provisions of the first indent of the aforesaid point 1 of the qualifications required as stated in the notice of competition.Contrary to the applicant's opinion, the experience of the four candidates mentioned in the defendant's reply was not acquired in the performance of mere executive duties, but was experience at a given level. The applicant, however, upon entering the ECSC, did not have any experience in the field of printing and editing. From 1966 to 1971, he was an assistant proof-corrector. Thus he performed mere executive duties, which could not have given him experience equivalent to a university degree.As for the applicant's astonishment as regards the fact that the Selection Board did not proceed to an additional inquiry into qualifications and other employment references, the Commission points out that in the case at issue qualifications do not play a preponderant part. The main problem is rather to examine candidates' experience. Moreover, the matter was one for the Selection Board's discretion.The applicant's reasoning to the effect that value judgments only arise at the second stage of the work of a selection board is not convincing. In the present case, the first stage of the competition involved not only an objective examination of the qualifications of the candidates in order to establish whether they were those required by the vacancy notice, but also an assessment of whether a certain level of experience was equivalent to a certain level of education.Such a question can only be answered by a value judgment.The Commission contends that the applicant has not proved either that his knowledge was of a university level or that the experience of the other candidates was inferior to his own.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.