law://eu/cjeu/1976/c-7-76/hd_1_1_2_1_2@2026-11-17The Commission refers to Article 6 of Regulation No 974/71 which consists of a particularly wide delegation of powers given by the Council to the Commission. The limits to that delegation are to be found in the very purposes of the system of compensatory amounts. In addition, the regulation lays down a series of criteria which the Commission should take into account. Amongst the detailed rules of application which the Commission is required to adopt, the fixing of compensatory amounts is particularly mentioned (Article 6 (2)). This fixing, which is not a purely automatic calculation, therefore calls for an evaluation which must take into account currency fluctuations and changes in the levels of the prices of the products. Admittedly, the Commission should also take into account the interests of individual traders, but its major concern ought to be to avoid ‘abnormal price movements disturbing the normal development of the conjunctural situation in the agricultural area’ and ‘disturbances in trade in agricultural products’. Finally, in setting the compensatory amounts, it is necessary to take into account Article 4 (a) (2), first paragraph, of Regulation No 974/71, introduced by Regulation No 509/73. The Commission took this complex situation into account and performed the duty which had been placed upon it as part of the powers conferred on it by the Council.The fact of reducing the compensatory amount by an adjusting amount does not run counter to the purposes of compensatory amounts. On this point, the Commission stresses the importance of Article 4 (a) (2) of Regulation No 974/71 in this system. The purpose of that provision is to prevent imports from third countries below the world market price. A further fact, however, is that the said provision presupposes that the import charge which, in the case of beef and veal subject to ‘ad valorem’ duty, varies for each consignment of goods imported, is calculated so as to determine the level of the compensatory amounts in intra-Community trade.The Commission cites the case-law of the Court confirming that compensatory amounts are not automatic (Judgment of 15 January 1974 in Case 154/73, Becher v Hauptzollamt Emden, [1974] ECR 19), stating the purposes of the system of compensatory amounts (Judgment of 12 November 1974 in Case 34/74, Roquette v France [1974] ECR 147) and recognizing the difficulties which would arise from having varying compensatory amounts, which might have tended to provoke deflections of trade (Judgment of 24 October 1973 in Case 5/73, Balkan-Import-Export v Hauptzollamt Berlin Packhof, [1973] ECR 1091).Finally, the Commission refers to the opinion of the Advocate-General in Case 46/75 concerning the problem at issue.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.