law://eu/cjeu/1975/c-95-75/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-19The plaintiff in the main action claims that its products contain only a relatively small proportion of starch which, especially in the case of the product FROLIC, does not come essentially from a percentage of cereals under Chapter 10 and under headings 11.01 and 11.02 of the Common Customs Tariff. They do not constitute sweetened forage in the sense of mixtures of different types of cereals or cereal products, but are composed rather of different types of meat and tripe. The disturbances occurring in the cereals sector could therefore only have affected them to a small extent.The fact of not having taken account of this situation amounts to an infringement of the system of the common organizations of the markets and consequently of Articles 39 and 40 of the EEC Treaty, of Article 19 of Regulation No 120/67/EEC and of Regulations (EEC) Nos 1968/73 and 2632/73.In applying the lawful and differentiated tariff of Regulation (EEC) No 433/73, the plaintiff in the main action should have paid a levy of only DM 4864,21 instead of DM 57028,60. A number of ingredients giving rise to the levy in accordance with Regulation (EEC) No 311/74 and later regulations, exported separately, were not made subject to the levy: rice-meal, flour, broken rice, maize swelling starch and maize gluten. Certainly other ingredients, exported separately, were made subject to the levy, but because of the small proportion which they comprised in the total product, the uniform rate of 26,25 u.a. per metric ton amounted to an excessive charge several times in excess of the value of these products and not merely the difference between their price on the world market and within the Community. Among these products appeared flour of common wheat, barley groats, wheat red dog, and probably starch of whole wheat germ. On the contrary according to Regulation (EEC) No 433/74 only certain products are subject to levy, and because of their low weight content in cereals, at a rate lower than 1/7 of that taken as a basis by Regulation No 311/74.The Commission had known the situation since the summer of 1973. It could not confuse the products . in dispute with those which might be manufactured in order to evade the rules and the levy. It knew that, for forage under tariff heading 23.07, gradations were necessary, within the framework of the organization of the market in cereals, on the basis either of the starch content or of the cereals content. That follows from the differentiations existing in the Common Customs Tariff, but above all from those contained in the Annex to Regulation (EEC) No 311/74 and in the later regulations. In fact the differentiations on the basis of the starch content are set out therein, but they were not given concrete expression in the rates of levy. It is incomprehensible that in spite of the haste with which the regulations had to be adopted, such a differentiation could not have been effected as was the case shortly afterwards.The judgments of the Court of Justice in Cases 5/73 and 9/73 quoted above cannot be relied upon, for they concern a completely different situation.The Commission is of opinion that there is no legal prohibition on fixing one and the same rate of levy for several products when the situation of the market demands it or permits it.The very wording of Article 3 (2) (b) of Regulation (EEC) No 1968/73, according to which the Commission must take into account the quantities of cereals necessary for the manufacture of the products concerned and, according to the circumstances, of the value of the secondary products, does not necessarily allow it to be concluded that there is any such duty to differentiate. The requirement thus laid down is satisfied when the Commission adopts rules differentiated in accordance with the tariff headings, without making other distinctions within a single tariff heading.Such a requirement would be contrary to the spirit of Regulation No 1968/73, the provisions of which are characterized not by obligations and rigid criteria but by the wide-power of discretion and of decision which they grant to the Commission within a framework.defined by directives which are very general in scope, especially in relation to the policy of the organization of the market. The Commission could for example fix the amount as low as possible, and base itself on average values when the different products and ingredients cannot be identified and differentiated with precision because of their large number. In order that the tariff of levies should remain practicable, it is impossible to make infinite differentiations. And why are uniform rates of levy permissible for several products gathered under a tariff subheading, but not in respect of a whole tariff heading? Thus the levies fixed in the disputed regulations are all subject to judicial supervision from the point of view of a misuse of powers.As regards the accusation of misuse of powers, the measures taken by the disputed regulations can be explained only by taking account of the serious crisis on the cereals market culminating at the end of January and at the beginning of February 1974. The situation on the cereals market at the time was analysed in detail in Cases 78/74 ([1975] ECR 421) and 5/75 ([1975] ECR 759). All the basic cereals and then all the products derived from them by general processing, to the exclusion of compound feedingstuffs for cattle, were subject to the levies. It is incorrect that cereal products used by the plaintiff in the main action, such as wheat red dog, wheat germ, rice-meal and barley groats were exempted from it.As the crisis became more acute, the amounts of the levies were raised, in the same way as it became increasingly necessary to take preventive steps in respect of the difficulties which might occur also in the sector of compound feedingstuffs for cattle containing cereals. Further, experience has shown that every strengthening of safeguard measures in external trade led to attempts to avoid these with the assistance of substitute products of the same value coming under tariff headings exempted from duties or subject to lower duties.Having regard to the increase in quantities of compound feedingstuffs for cattle which were the subject of export licences: September 1973: 7505 metric tons, October 1973: 14686 metric tons, November 1973: 16322 metric tons, December 1973: 18459 metric tons, and January 1974: 19790 metric tons, the Commission believed that this showed an increase in these exports which displayed striking analogies with the trends in world market prices and with the variations in export levies.Having regard to the number of products coming under tariff heading 23.07 liable . to contain any percentage of any cereal product in any combination, it was extremely difficult to ascertain with the necessary precision which compound ingredients for cattle constituted the major proportion of these exports.In that situation the Commission could give up preventive measures and fix export levies only for ‘cattle fodder’, on the exportation of which problems had appeared and the character and composition of which were known. But then it would not be able to keep control of the transactions in that way and could only react to events as they occurred. Further, to the extent that it was impossible to say with sufficient certainty that there were difficulties only for cattle feedingstuffs containing cereals, but not for products rich in starch or conversely, the Commission could not know whether the action it took was adequate and well directed if it differentiated products subject to the levy according to these contents. That is why it decided to resort to an overall preventive solution by way of levies in order to be able immediately to exempt products if that were justified in case of an improvement in the situation or of a fuller knowledge of market and export trends.Although the formal basis adopted in this matter was a nomenclature differentiated in relation to the starch content, that was due in particular to the fact that commercial circles and the authorities of the organization of the market had become familiar with that nomenclature through the import levies.Thanks to the development of market trends and to obtaining more accurate information, it was possible to limit the levies by Regulation No 433/74 to a small number of products capable of being supplied on the basis of their content in cereal products of a particular type.In these circumstances the Commission chose an amount based on 75 % of the levy imposed on maize, processed mostly as feedingstuffs for cattle; this amount came to approximately half the levy imposed on bran and starch and almost a third of the levy imposed on wheat.If matters are considered in retrospect, it might appear that the Commission should already, in Regulation (EEC) No 311/74, have laid down provisions corresponding to those in Regulation (EEC) No 433/74.In fact at the time when the Commission had to act, the only decisive factor from the point of view of evaluating the exercise of its powers, the conditions necessary for adopting provisions in accordance with those adopted in Regulation (EEC) No 433/74 had not yet come into existence.The plaintiff in the main action, represented by Mr Paetow, Advocate at the Hamburg Bar, and the Commission of the European Communities, represented by Mr Kalbe, its Legal Adviser acting as Agent, presented oral argument at the hearing on 28 January 1976.The Advocate-General delivered his opinion at the hearing on 17 February 1976.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.