law://eu/cjeu/1973/c-189-73/hd_1_1_3_2_2@2026-11-16The applicant states that he performs duties which appertain to Category A. Since his classification does not conform to his duties, it is contrary to the principle of correspondence between duties and grade. The applicant's right to reclassification accords with the principles relating to classification enshrined in the Staff Regulations. The ratio legis of those principles has been indicated by the Court in its judgment in Prelle v Commission (Case 77/70, Rec. 1971, p. 561). In the applicant's opinion, where reclassification is due, there is no question of promotion. Reclassification is a right, promotion a favour.The principle of the right to reclassification has been recognized by the Court in Mulders v Commission (Case 8/69 Rec. 1969, p. 561)Advancement from one grade to another is no different from advancement from one category to another. This argument is accepted by implication in Muller v Commission (Joined Cases 109/63 and 13/64, [1964] ECR 663).Alternatively, if the Court were to consider that promotion for one category to another could be effected only on the basis of a competition, the Commission would have to follow the procedure which it itself instituted by publishing Vacancy Notice COM/ 534/73.The Commission maintains that even if it is accepted that in deputizing for his superior, the applicant has for a number of years been performing duties appertaining to a level higher than his own grade, this fact cannot, of itself, give him the right to reclassification in the higher grade, unless he first succeeds in a competition leading to promotion to the higher category. If grade and duties do not correspond the only recourse open to a servant adversely affected by this fact is to request the annulment of the unilateral decision imposing the higher of lower duties upon him, so as to free himself of them; he cannot request the revaluation of the post:— Boursin v Commission (Case 102/63, [1964] ECR 691)— Prelle v Commission (cited above)— Tontodonati v Commission (Case 28/72, [1973] ECR 779)Apart from exceptional cases relating to the integration of officials in the system of grades, which was carried out in 1962, there has been no instance of an official's benefiting from an appointment involving reclassification in the next higher grade which has not itself been the result of promotion by selection or of success in a competition, as laid down by Article 45 (2) of the Staff Regulations in respect of appointment to a higher category.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.